Search results

  1. Jonathan Edwards

    ME/CFS services in the United Kingdom

    Sounds a bit like Lord High Everything Else (Pooh-Bah from the Mikado). A one woman multidisciplinary team no less.
  2. Jonathan Edwards

    The illness-disease dichotomy and the biological-clinical splitting of medicine, Tesio and Buzzoni, 2021

    Full marks for the comprehension, @Trish Now turn over the paper and do the vocabulary test.
  3. Jonathan Edwards

    Covid-19 vaccines and vaccinations

    Nobody knows for sure but if you go on the basis of what is much most likely a booster is very likely to stop you getting a nasty illness. I would take the data on antibodies and stuff with a pinch of salt. We know the vaccines provide immunity in the sense of reducing the likelihood of being...
  4. Jonathan Edwards

    CBT for Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (CFS) - Psychology tools.com

    Which year were you thinking of? Might be a draught down a chimney though. (As long as Snow White isn't doing the washing again.)
  5. Jonathan Edwards

    Maddox Prize again

    The winner is probably a jolly good sort but Tracey Brown of SAS says: “The shocking thing about what Elisabeth is doing in challenging fraud and misrepresentation of scientific findings is that this is something that most people think already happens. Only it doesn’t. And in fact she has been...
  6. Jonathan Edwards

    Maddox Prize again

    https://www.theguardian.com/science/2021/dec/01/misinformation-fuelled-by-tsunami-of-poor-research-says-science-prize-winner Read and enjoy the ironies. Apparently the message of a bad paper can now be spread through the internet - something that was never so before. Well, there was the Lancet.
  7. Jonathan Edwards

    Covid-19 vaccines and vaccinations

    We were talking to a young couple who are local friends this weekend. They are around 35. They got Covid despite to vaccinations and they said it was truly awful. OK they are alive, but not something they would want again.
  8. Jonathan Edwards

    Respiratory Physiotherapy for POTS and disordered breathing

    You may be right, the abstract is potentially confusing. But why would panic attack patients hyperventilate on this test? Panic attacks usually occur at unpredictable times. I also think there is a major problem with suggestibility in this sort of study. If POTS patients know that their...
  9. Jonathan Edwards

    CBT for Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (CFS) - Psychology tools.com

    Well they have made a start. They will need to read my book before they can really get it right though!
  10. Jonathan Edwards

    Respiratory Physiotherapy for POTS and disordered breathing

    So that is what is so puzzling - that they did tell them to over breathe as far as I can see. I guess they had to tell the panic patients to over breathe to order so they did the same for POTS patients. But if over breathing is a problem for POTS patients it will be an involuntary problem, surely.
  11. Jonathan Edwards

    United Kingdom: Newcastle-upon-tyne Hospital Trust

    FOI request: Who got it so wrong? Response: We all did. (And anyway we were already doing what the new guideline that we are so cross about says.)
  12. Jonathan Edwards

    Respiratory Physiotherapy for POTS and disordered breathing

    I don't get the relevance of the first study. It seems the patients were told to overbreath upright and then they looked at the pattern. That seems to me a totally artificial situation that is unlikely to tell us anything about their illness. Panic patients would be likely to reproduce their...
  13. Jonathan Edwards

    Chronotropic Incompetence in Non-Hospitalized Patients with Post-COVID-19 Syndrome, 2021, Jimeno-Almazán et al

    What they are describing here is unrelated to POTS. And only a small minority of their post-Covid patients had it
  14. Jonathan Edwards

    BPS attempts at psychologizing Long Covid

    Maybe move the little marks around a bit: 'It's Deconditioning' = Stupid
  15. Jonathan Edwards

    Respiratory Physiotherapy for POTS and disordered breathing

    Is there really anything solid on this? It sounds implausible. Is there any published literature?
  16. Jonathan Edwards

    Respiratory Physiotherapy for POTS and disordered breathing

    I have not seen any literature on this but I am sceptical about the idea that a respiratory physiotherapist can achieve anything for someone hose breathing seems 'a bit all over the place' - or for that matter shallop or deep or whatever. Are you sure this is not just selling therapy for the...
  17. Jonathan Edwards

    Virtual Reality-Based Therapy Reduces the Disabling Impact of Fibromyalgia Syndrome in Women..., 2021, Cortés-Pérez et al

    It says that they would like to say that a load of researchers have said that lots of patients have said they got better after having a treatment that encouraged them to say they are better. More proof that patients will say they are better if they are told to.
Back
Top Bottom