That reminds me (though I can't remember the specifics) of some politician or other who wanted league tables for hospitals, including rating surgeons on how many of their patients survived their operations. Until someone pointed out that the best surgeons often have rather high death rates...
They've got figures showing that a lot of people who claim sickness benefits for six months or less return to work, but people who claim for longer than a year are less likely to ever work again, and yes, they're spinning this as meaning that long-term support makes you sick.
The analogy would...
I'd love to get this guy into a conversation with the FND guys who insist that you mustn't test patients for anything at all because that will make them ill by suggesting their symptoms might be real.
I have constant internal tremors but my cortisol was normal when tested. all I can say for sure is they're worse when I've over-exerted and when I'm hungry.
I actually have thoughts on this whole subject which I would love to put into a few coherent paragraphs, but my brain is not co-operating :rofl: so I'll just say "yeah."
It's like reading a treatise by a couple of medieval theoreticians earnestly explaining the theory of the humours and how digestive disorder is caused by excess phlegm driven out from your brain to your stomach by the autumn winds. Those guys probably had a good old sneer at their patients'...
Interesting that some of their subjects had objective cognitive deficits in some domains but didn't subjectively report experiencing it.
So a better title might be Post-COVID-Syndrome Patients Might Overestimate or Underestimate Own Cognitive Impairment. Or perhaps Post-COVID-Syndrome Patients...
Their 'Good Day/Bad Day Questionnaire' is quite interesting. Don't think I've seen a discussion of it here? (Keywords are too short to search the forums.) It's obviously a blunt instrument, but giving answers for both ends of a spectrum of functioning might be more helpful than the majority of...
"After an hour-long stand-off (pictured), the activists eventually persuaded Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) civil servants to allow one of them, Rick Burgess, to address the disabled people taking part in the consultation.
He asked those present to vote on whether they wanted to give...
Good point.
The whole thing is probably pretty tenuous anyway given the infant nature of the art of trying to interpret psychological states from fMRI, and perhaps especially so in the context of other people's findings on cerebral blood flow.
So they expected to find PCS patients were less reward-motivated (because of our "anhedonia" causing us to imagine that we're fatigued, innit)
but they actually found the opposite?
It's likely that not everyone who currently has an 'ME/CFS' diagnosis will actually have whatever problem the new biological explanation points to. Some will be left as a 'mysterious chronic fatigue' afterthought and they'll be great prey for the psychologisers - not only are all their tests...
Thread on the preprint here. https://www.s4me.info/threads/long-covid-brain-fog-treatment-findings-from-a-pilot-randomized-controlled-trial-of-constraint-induced-cognitive-therapy-2024-uswatte-et-al.39224/
My comment there was:
(edit to add: sorry for the unnecessary duplicate post, should...
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.