She's a psychiatrist. She will know Paul Garner very well. She's co-authored stuff with him eg https://www.bmj.com/content/354/bmj.i3507
No, she didn't think it was substandard when she allowed it to be published in 2019. One of the IAG and I met with her in July 2019 and he begged...
I sent lots of questions and points I wanted to be recorded, particularly in the beginning. As well as her responses. i was under the impression...
I came across this randomly. https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7288507835515101184/. It rings true for Cochrane although it...
All the correspondence to and from the IAG email address. cochrane.iag@gmail.com. I will try and find where she committed to this.
I hope the collected email correspondence is published, as Hilda promised it would be. And the collated report of criticisms. There is an awful...
I have requested that Wiley investigate my complaint of editorial misconduct and they said in November an investigation is underway. I wrote to...
yes please
It doesn't apply to reviews which is classed as secondary research. That's the loophole for Cochrane - they set a protocol for reviews making...
You're right. And it explains why Larun has started responding to comments again. I will put in another FOI request to NIPH for correspondence...
I got the more recent emails (June 2019) between Cochrane and Norwegian Institute of Public Health via a FOI to NIPH. But I imagine they stopped...
It was withdrawn in 2018 (I think) and then reinstated because the authors and supporters kicked up a fuss...
Yes. It always fascinated/appalled me when I worked for them that most reviewers of treatments like homeopathy, acupuncture, CBT for just about...
100% this
I imagine Ann Milne will reply. For Larun to say the point estimate (-3.4) is clinically significant is very misleading (what a surprise) as the...
Ann Milne made another comment on the Exercise review in December and the authors (Larun) have responded....I think this is the first time Larun...
I think Cochrane probably moved because of this whole palaver. It would be possible to get correspondence about it via FOI. That's how we got the...
I don't this has ever been revealed.
It was taken away from the "Common Mental Disorders Group" and moved to under the "control" of the Editor in Chief. She was advised by Chris...
It's the GRADEing methods group which is based at McMaster. https://www.cochrane.org/ms/about-us/our-global-community/methods-groups#g-30 I think...
Separate names with a comma.
