As far as I can tell, despite claiming to have made all analysis code publicly available, they did not share any of the EEfRT analysis code. I've...
I think that this is a really important point. This is a complete misrepresentation of EEfRT. *Editing because it's more nuanced than my...
The lab I worked in ran 1 participant per day and the visit took the full day. We would review participant data quickly at the end of the session...
It stands for Generalized Estimating Equation, it's the statistical model that Wallit used to analyze the EEfRT data. They're pretty complicated...
Yeah I think they would likely push back on it being an arbitrary choice. It could be something to look for in the other EEfRT studies, whether...
This response is infuriating (the whole message, not just this quote). Can someone correct me if I'm wrong here: they keep claiming in their...
I named the category hard_task_completer, with 1 indicating success rate on hard tasks above 90% and 0 success rates on hard tasks below 90%. When...
This is great! It's is gold for the critique. There is an established precedent in the literature for performing individual calibration of the...
I'll take a look! I'd be up for taking on a portion if it'd be helpful.
We understand the findings perfectly well. The issue is that we disagree with their weaponizing of pseudoscience to string together a theory that...
@Karen Kirke any chance you could share the SF-36 data file with me or let me know how I could request a copy? Is my understanding correct that it...
@EndME I know you've read a bunch of EEfRT papers at this point, have any of these studies asserted that EEfRT is meant to measure "effort...
That's great to know. It would especially be helpful to have some folks contribute who have experience with the PACE initiatives and can...
And as our reward... drum roll please... More info about HV F! I wrote the authors asking why HV F was excluded in the analyses, and was told...
@bobbler @Murph @Karen Kirke I love all of your visualizations, they've been really helpful for trying to see all of the pieces at play, it's so...
Sorry I haven't been very active the past two days, all this work has me crashing pretty hard. Yes I think I'd like to write a letter to the...
Interesting, yeah I could see why they might justify that to themselves as being enough of an outlier to exclude them (even if I don't think its a...
From what I can tell they only performed the GEEs using the binary ME vs Control variable in place of the anhedonia scales that Treadway used....
I agree that HV F's data suggests that they were not performing the task in the way that it was meant to be performed but I don't think that is...
Answer to #2: I reran the GEE models and when you include participant HV F (who was excluded for having "invalid data") the effect is no longer...
Separate names with a comma.
