I said this over and over to Hilda and she was determined it would go ahead. I paraphrase, but her response to me was "we're doing it whether you...
I had completely forgotten, but I made a comment...
This is the review that was abandoned at protocol stage - the one that Jo Edwards saw. White, Glasziou, Sharpe etc. were co-authors!)...
There's a guy called Andy Oxman, well known in Cochrane, who was at the NIPH at the time, who is also very close with Iain Chalmers. Chalmers is...
She's a psychiatrist. She will know Paul Garner very well. She's co-authored stuff with him eg https://www.bmj.com/content/354/bmj.i3507
No, she didn't think it was substandard when she allowed it to be published in 2019. One of the IAG and I met with her in July 2019 and he begged...
I sent lots of questions and points I wanted to be recorded, particularly in the beginning. As well as her responses. i was under the impression...
I came across this randomly. https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7288507835515101184/. It rings true for Cochrane although it...
All the correspondence to and from the IAG email address. cochrane.iag@gmail.com. I will try and find where she committed to this.
I hope the collected email correspondence is published, as Hilda promised it would be. And the collated report of criticisms. There is an awful...
I have requested that Wiley investigate my complaint of editorial misconduct and they said in November an investigation is underway. I wrote to...
yes please
It doesn't apply to reviews which is classed as secondary research. That's the loophole for Cochrane - they set a protocol for reviews making...
You're right. And it explains why Larun has started responding to comments again. I will put in another FOI request to NIPH for correspondence...
I got the more recent emails (June 2019) between Cochrane and Norwegian Institute of Public Health via a FOI to NIPH. But I imagine they stopped...
It was withdrawn in 2018 (I think) and then reinstated because the authors and supporters kicked up a fuss...
Yes. It always fascinated/appalled me when I worked for them that most reviewers of treatments like homeopathy, acupuncture, CBT for just about...
100% this
I imagine Ann Milne will reply. For Larun to say the point estimate (-3.4) is clinically significant is very misleading (what a surprise) as the...
Ann Milne made another comment on the Exercise review in December and the authors (Larun) have responded....I think this is the first time Larun...
Separate names with a comma.
