I was looking forward to you meeting her too. I would have paid A LOT for tickets to see it in fact. I met her in July along with two patients....
I have suggested on Twitter it go to the Cochrane Work Group - so the review will focus on objective outcomes. The editor of that group (Jos...
I am fairly sure the only reason the Exercise one didn't get withdrawn is because the authors didn't agree to let it happen
Latest timeline of link-gate - correspondence with Rachel Marshall, Senior Editor, Cochrane It's so confusing. They changed the conclusions of...
Hilda is a scientist Twitter says:- Scientist, writer, cartoonist. Blogs Absolutely Maybe (@PLOSBlogs), @BMJ_Latest Statistically Funny on...
This is why I don't understand why Hilda didn't push for withdrawal of the review - which is what David Tovey explicitly said he wanted before he...
There is now a confusing dog's dinner on the information page What's New and History...
Rachel Marshall is the person who has been dealing (since January) with my request (made in October) to link from the amended 2 October review to...
yeah sorry. You're right. I spent a lot of time bugging her to look at it in late 2018/early 2019 and I also emailed her in 2016/7 ish?. I know...
Wow. Just read her blog. And she says she is critical of the Exercise review. Well good. Glad I bugged her about it for ages on Twitter
Yes, it's much more about politics than science. And yes, he is obsessed with the evils of drugs - with good reason - but so ignores the crap...
I am sure she has never criticized the exercise review...
No - she has never been critical of the Cochrane exercise review.
Very Ben "I think you'll find it's more complicated than that" Goldacre
From Wikipedia.... Despite some mockery of the phrase, its use is still widespread, and in the opinion of one commentator, "the type of evasive...
This policy does nothing to address problems of the past. It continues to ignore the fact that Cochrane reviews uncritically include studies such...
Great. Another person I thought might be concerned about this bites the dust...
Separate names with a comma.
