It’s not just the model it’s how they’re used. And I think that’s where I’m comes down to who is using them but also what their expectations are.
Quite a few people on these forums will know I am probably ‘pro’ AI, see great potential for AI/ML (including LLMs) and anyone who follows the field...
Thanks for your expert eye @jnmaciuch
So the sceptical view is they may have found something (that MAIT cells are there and likely doing something which is helpful), but it’s in mice and the wider narrative they’ve drawn may be a stretch?
I had a bit more of a dig and there’s more from the same group. Still mice but it’s obviously something someone has an interest in… not sure if it adds anything of use to us but for reference
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12974-025-03413-7...
I’m not sure it’s being ignored, more perhaps a case of asking what is the mechanism that keeps it going?
So in the fire analogy a spark may trigger it but to understand and extinguish the fire you need to understand different mechanisms.
I hadn’t fully appreciated these factors in the approach you’re taking and it makes a lot of sense. Look forward to hearing more on what you find.
Beyond that, there’s lots of interesting discussion here, most of which is beyond me but hopefully I’ll be able to do some more reading.
Interesting. So the clinic obviously wasn’t a going concern financially speaking?
I guess we watch and see if/what impact this has on their research arm and work with PrecisionLife…
Edit: I really dislike terms like “healthcare journey”
I see your point. And agree that saying we don’t know for sure is probably best. We also do not know that there is a prodromal or early phase or that there is a progression, many talk of sudden onset. And I think that is the argument, we have no evidence that inflammation or any of this is...
But don’t we know that it is not universal? I had loads of blood tests early on because I was hospitalised for a serious infection and CRP was fine and was for those initial years.
Isn’t this part of the problem we’re talking about? Not just that these things are not universal in people with...
Agree with this and the comments from @MrMagoo and that this is part of a wider thing, not just ME/CFS but a general quackery and use of ‘inflammation’ as a term to justify it.
So we seem to have covered (i) questions over definition (ii) issues of reproducibility and mechanisms within ME/CFS...
Sounds like a load of Advanced Rehabilitation Service Eh
Sorry, not particularly analytical but people profiting from desperate sick patients are the worst imho
Yeah that’s the other aspect of this isn’t it, beyond definition of what inflammation is, it’s reproducibility and mechanism. Even if we could agree on what inflammation means we couldn’t say for sure everyone with me/cfs has it let alone why.
I guess that applies to a lot of claims.
It’s a great question and I look forward to the responses. My uneducated reading is inflammation is specifically about permeability of blood vessels, so tissues actually get inflamed. While a lot of what is talked about as inflammation is more inflammatory adjacent signals (like cytokines), so...
Great, thanks.
I’m just posting in this thread so people should be aware of the source but it’s the DecodeME team from their webinar on their facebook page and it’s a pcloud share so freely available
https://u.pcloud.link/publink/show?code=XZyDiW5ZVromEDI80OXT4WvoJue2i5erTIDV
Hopefully this...
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.