Shame in the treatment of patients with psychogenic nonepileptic seizures: The elephant in the room, 2021, Myers et al

Highlights

• Shame commonly contributes to the aetiology and clinical presentation of PNES.
• Shame may cause difficulties with engagement in treatment of PNES.
• High shame proneness and shame dysregulation are important treatment targets.
• The relationship with the therapist may be more important in shame treatment than the psychotherapy modality.

Abstract

Previous research has established a link between psychogenic nonepileptic seizures (also known as dissociative or functional seizures) and abnormal emotion processing. In a companion article to this multidisciplinary narrative review, we have argued that, in the context of a biopsychosocial understanding of the condition, the emotion of shame is particularly likely to contribute to the aetiology, manifestation, semiology and perpetuation of psychogenic non-epileptic seizures (PNES).

Here we demonstrate how unrecognised and unaddressed shame may cause difficulties when clinicians explain the diagnosis, attempt to engage patients in psychological treatment, construct a diagnostic formulation and undertake psychotherapy. Case vignettes are used to bring theoretical considerations to life and to illustrate the complex interactions which may be observed between high shame proneness, chronic and dysregulated shame, stigma and PNES. The particular focus on shame does not mean that recent explanatory models of PNES are obsolete. Rather, we demonstrate how the inclusion of shame helps to embed the emotional, cognitive and behavioural aspects of the Integrative Cognitive Model (ICM) of PNES in a social / interpersonal context.

While we describe how a number of different psychotherapeutic approaches can help to address shame-related processes we conclude that specific modalities are less important than the eventual enhancement of emotional literacy and tolerance through a healing relationship with the psychotherapist.

Paywall, https://www.seizure-journal.com/article/S1059-1311(21)00346-0/fulltext

 

Surely shame comes from somewhere, like how the medical establishment treats people with this condition, so logically it could be removed as a factor by simply not treating patients like *&^&*(&*?

 

Medicine: shames patients, making them explicitly feel worse for being ill by explicitly blaming them for it and all its consequences.

Also medicine: wow they sure seem to feel a lot of shame, I wonder where that comes from, best study this 589 times over the next century or so.

 

• Highlights
• Shame commonly contributes to the aetiology and clinical presentation of PNES.
• How do you know?
• You don’t, do you?
• Shame may cause difficulties with engagement in treatment of PNE.
• “May” it?
• You haven’t really committed to this one have you?
• High shame proneness and shame dysregulation are important treatment targets.
• They “are” ?
• Well I guess these are your “treatment targets” and you know what’s “important” to you.
• The relationship with the therapist may be more important in shame treatment than the psychotherapy modality.
• You sound rather unsure on basics of your endeavour here.
• “shame treatment”unfortunate terminology or rather apt?

 

Shameless