This isn't the first time that we've seen questionable papers from this group. See:
Comparing DNA Methylation Landscapes in Peripheral Blood from [ME/CFS] and Long COVID Patients, 2025, Peppercorn et al | Page 4 | Science for ME
The raw data of the experiments, for example, in CSV format.
A big problem I see is that almost all studies misrepresent their data in the abstract and text (to make it look like a bigger deal than it is or to promote the authors' favoured theory).
So I think machine learning/AI/network...
Seems like a useful commentary. If I understand correctly:
- The groups are independent; this wasn't a longitudinal study following the same people over time
- Although there were differences between groups, they were relatively modest and still within normal limits
- The difference might be...
Thanks for trying this. I gave up because my coding skills are rather amateurish. There was also the issue that I wouldn't be entirely sure if it worked or if I had misapplied it somehow.
I was hoping that either researchers would use this in future publications (e.g. the official DecodeME...
Thanks. If I understand correctly, though, your network analysis is based on mentions in abstracts and the text of a publication and not on the actual data of studies?
Was curious what would happen if ME/CFS patients got interferon treatment. Would it make their fatigue/malaise even worse, would it have less effect, or, if this pathway is involved in ME/CFS pathology, might it help correct it or induce inhibitory pathways?
Found this 1993 report on...
Yes would be interested. Had plans to write blog posts about the history of ME/CFS (there seems to be a lot of myths about it), but never got to it. Perhaps somewhere in the future.
Looks like a complex analysis that must have been lots of work (kudos to the authors)!
But I have my doubts about how relevant the results are. In my view, it's mainly the comparison with controls that matters, while this study seems to have focused on correlations with SNPs and metabolites...
I suppose their combinatorial analysis can be useful to get new or clearer findings, but in this case, it seems to have made things more complicated and muddled.
Their disease signatures map to 2,311 genes, while humans only have approximately 20.000-25.000 protein-coding genes.
The paper writes:
But on X someone commented:
"There is already a known autoimmune disease of the CNS, where autoantibodies directed against AQP4 its named Neuro Myelitis Optica (NMO) The autoantibodies were discovered in 2006/07."
"The AQP4 autoantibodies causes extensive and severe...
Yes, so these are probably too important to be defective in ME/CFS; otherwise, we would see other abnormalities in patients.
So it should likely be something more specific to this pathway that is defective in ME/CFS, and if DecodeME results are to be believed, might be more on the brain than...
Yes, that's also the explanation I was thinking of: that the sickness behavior pathway involves proteins that are too important elsewhere in the body, so that mutations aren't viable.
But that begs the question of why we don't see clear immune dysfunction elsewhere in ME/CFS and why DecodeME...
These seem like the main results:
Self-reported activity was the strongest predictor but there was no relationship between objectively measured activity and fatigue changes:
Some also suspect that the effect can be explained by people with depression improving with CBT, but not LC. This also...
Yes, feeling terribly awful so that nobody in such condition would be able to ride a Tour stage. The more similar to ME/CFS the better.
Which immune responses cause sickness behavior and which don't is interesting, but a different question from the one I wanted to ask. Namely, if there are...
Thanks for the responses.
I was mainly thinking about an antiviral immune response that makes most people very sick and fatigued, but in some exceptions, don't cause any symptoms at all. So localised immune activation in the gut or eczema wouldn't count.
The main idea is: if sickness...
Was wondering if there is any medical condition where the immune response works normally (for example, in response to an infection) but where patients don't feel ill with fatigue and malaise. In other words, an immune response without sickness behavior.
It could be like the opposite of ME/CFS.
Looks like it was very well done, professionally organized, nice turnout, moving speeches, and lots of national press coverage. Kudos to the organizers and everyone who participated.
EDIT: screenshot from the livestream:
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.