Search results

The journal publisher has previously been accused of publishing so-called "predatory" journals. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MDPI#Controversial_articles

Hi I'm confused how this would work. You got CBT from this private organization rather than NHS? But NHS covers the cost?

I can understand that. They have different goals. It's good for me to try to do a mix of both.

Thanks. I'm sure there are other instances out there as well. I'm sure most don't read the study but just pick up the mistake from previous mis-citations.

Roughly, the calculated cost (and I'm not endorsing Bemingham et al's figures) was about 3 billion pounds in the year examined. The total NHS budget that year was around 100 billion. The cost of services for those of working age was about 30 billion. So the misstatement makes it seem like the...

It's been a while but did anyone notice if "later next year" actually happened? It's a bummer that the document isn't OCRed, makes going through it harder than it should. The issue does not seem to have come up in the rest of the minutes that I could see. Lucibee also mentioned that in her...

Hey Richard--can you tell me where in the trial meeting notes this is? I'm trying to write a post about the actometer issue. I see some of the references in the trial meeting notes but didn't see that point being made. The main issue raised as I saw was that the failure to demonstrate any...

Right. and yet she still let herself get used by the SMC to promote that piece of crap And when I pointed out to her the methodological problems, she misread them and, for a second time, gave the study a clean bill of health. Her actions on this matter have been disgraceful.

yes, as did I. And I wrote him back thanking him for letting me know. I don't see a reason not to prompt these folks when things seem slow. They don't have a good track record of following up. I'm glad Professor Jones decided, in the end, to take the issue seriously and not continue to downplay...

this is true and definitely good to remember. however, none of those involved had really earned this trust. nor did Professor Jones with his initial responses. I think being concerned about whether the journal really intended to follow through was warranted.

really? interesting. thanks for the heads up.

They seem to posting them as they're ready. The special issue of JHP did the same, more or less. The link is to the journal's "latest content"--the last 3-4 days they've all been about biopsychosocial and/or psychosomatics. So I assume the Sharpe/Greco opus will be coming in in next few days...

This is true of course. But I still think it is important to have a disclaimer that it is not medical advice. Even when you get things right, people misinterpret or over-interpret based on whatever.

What is the actual role of this question-asking in government policy-making?

That was my initial thought of what you mean as well, actually. The problem is they could say, well, APT was also "therapy" so there was something different about the "therapies" we liked, i.e. CBT and GET.

I have tried to give Dr Segal the benefit of the doubt. However, I can also say that I would have thought an expert in the field would have known or heard about the editor's note, given that it's been up for a year. She has not bothered to clarify what happened or what she thinks. the longer she...

Good point. even if you "help" it work you might not be expecting it to.

It's a shocker. I had not heard anything about this. From the cryptic announcement, it sounds like it was an interpersonal relations issue and not a research issue. but very hard to interpret.

Since they swapped outcomes to make sure it "worked," it wasn't clear to me how she could have been surprised. that seems to me to have been, let's say, not quite a true statement.

well, he hasn't actually made a change yet. he has promised to make it. on Wednesday, he said he was making it "now." it is Friday. perhaps he will not actually make the correction until after I send him another letter next week asking him to notify me when it finally happens.