I'm hoping this is a good place to ask about diagnosis practices in the Netherlands. Along with Audrey Ryback (a researcher at Edinburgh in...
@Jonathan Edwards, did you see this? I’ll be interested in your response (apologies if you responded and I missed it)
I'm assuming the RA/Lupus/omplement example also ties in with your point about making all the details fit. I don't think they looked at onset time...
@Jonathan Edwards, thanks to you, Jo Cambridge and Jackie Cliff for putting together such a thoughtful model that, at the very least, shows how a...
I wonder how relevant neural hypervigilance is. (If I’ve understood right, that’s the basic idea of the interception hypothesis, which a few...
That’s pretty depressing, if unsurprising. Thank you for putting your head above the parapet when you know what is flying your way. I don’t know...
which is itself a very helpful step. Up till now, it’s mostly consisted of “ Here is our finding. Here is how it could explain an aspect of the...
C2: Self-report of ME/CFS from the pain questionnaire, 2,720 people. I'm starting with this cohort as it's the most extreme and also has data...
Some comments on the validity of each cohort, adding to what the authors say and what has been posted here to date. General point The cohort...
I saw the other quote—it is confusing! But see Fig 2, whose data implies that Yes, No, No is the right answer.
The paper Says that answering these three questions “yes, no, no” is consistent with PEM– Aren’t you agreeing? I agree that those questions...
Cohort quality assessed by cohort overlap Those in C3 (hospital G93.3 code) come out best, C2 (PQ ME/CFS) worst The simplest way the study...
Thanks – and I just didn’t want you to think that I hadn’t even bothered to read the abstract (where the acronyms are spelt out) before asking a...
Thanks very much for that. I was also struck by the clean separation for biological variables – like you say, that’s pretty rare. Unless there’s a...
Look neat analysis For the benefit of those of us not keeping up with this work, would you be able to explain what we are seeing here that is...
Where is missing data missing from, and why? Summary: All UKB participants have baseline assessment data (with self-reported serious illnesses),...
Sorry, I haven’t been keeping up. Interesting analysis But 28% of that group reported good or excellent health, and they were other issues –,...
Thanks for the responses, @forestglip and @jnmaciuch. My concern about AUC wasn't anything to do with diagnosis (it's too low to be useful), but...
Could you just spell that out, please. My first quote is from the para, which begins with a discussion of simulations and concludes with the data...
Like you, I find the discussion fascinating, especially after 30 years with little happening in research. But maybe this is the time to raise...
Separate names with a comma.