ME from stress ?

Forbin said:
I think that stress can reactivate some dormant viruses.
Click to expand...

On the subject of viral reactivation, through Solve ME/CFS funding, Dr Bhupesh Prusty is doing some intriguing research on HHV-6 reactivation, where he has found that:
HHV-6 activation can lead to changes to mitochondrial structure and function, potentially even in healthy cells via a mechanism of remote activation. Ref: here.
Click to expand...

I'd really like to know more about that mechanism which remotely causes changes in mitochondria.
 
Last edited:
It may be worth pojnting out that stress has neen blamed for lots of illnesses, i cluding rheumatoid and ms on pretty poor evidence. Trauma was said to set off RA. Now that we know more about the mechanism I think most people have discarded the trauma evidence as too open to bias.

There seems to precious little evidence for stressful psychological stimuli triggering ME. Or traffic accidents. I suspect stress is too vague a generalisation. Viruses seem to be relevant. Maybe other immune insults but even there tbe evidence seems vague.
 
Jonathan Edwards said:
It may be worth pojnting out that stress has neen blamed for lots of illnesses, i cluding rheumatoid and ms on pretty poor evidence. Trauma was said to set off RA. Now that we know more about the mechanism I think most people have discarded the trauma evidence as too open to bias.

There seems to precious little evidence for stressful psychological stimuli triggering ME. Or traffic accidents. I suspect stress is too vague a generalisation. Viruses seem to be relevant. Maybe other immune insults but even there tbe evidence seems vague.
Click to expand...
In the end stress causes everything until its disproven. But it often still sticks around as a secondary cause or trigger because few like completely dismissing their former beliefs.
 
Perrier said:
I am sure severe chronic stress has impact. However, I just want to remind folks that so many people have spent years in the gulag, undernourished, doing hard labour, and they did not develop ME. The same holds for those souls who survived the extermination camps. Or the same holds for folks during wartime. So, I don't know, perhaps it has something to do with an already weakened immune system. I really don't know....but it might need several problems all coming together.
Click to expand...
I completely agree.
It will be interesting when we figure out what causes ME but until then i will settle for having a treatment.
 
Until then I'd grudgingly accept $1,000,000,000 a month.

Not as compensation, just to provide motivation to the gits to find a solution.

It seems smaller amounts of lost income, to governments, don't provide enough incentive to get them to actually do anything.
 
My friends with MS feel that stress, physical and emotional brings on episodes. They all think they had minor symptoms for years but a serious stress episode brought on the major attack which lead to them deteriorating so badly they were finally diagnosed. (With MRIs diagnosing patients much earlier so they do not go through the "nothing much going on, stop worrying" phase it may be different now)
 
The problem is "stress" is very nonspecific and tells us almost nothing about disease initiation or progression. Similarly, psychological "stress" is neither necessary, nor sufficient to trigger ME or CFS.

Hence while "stress" may be a risk factor, it cannot be blamed as a cause.
 
Andy said:
If it is this video,

Ron refers to stressors, "..like an auto accident, surgery, childbirth, anything that is a major body stressor can cause this disease [ME/CFS]", watch from 6:05 mins for that section.
Click to expand...

Yes, Ron is clearly referring to major physical stress events here.

Maybe there are some people for whom major emotional stresses also correlate with physical stresses ... who knows? If you took two identical people, and one was subjected to much more emotional stress than the other, would they then also become prone to greater physical stress? e.g. Some people deal with emotional stress by "throwing themselves into their work", and thereby working much longer hours and/or higher levels of persistent physical activity. Or maybe in some people there really will be an internal mechanism that leads to greater physical stress if under great emotional stress. I think the aetiology of ME, once it is better understood, will be fascinating. But the key is that it is the physical stress that kicks off the ME.
 
Following on from my previous post, but preferring to not edit it:

We know that ME afflicts more women than men, but do we know if this statistic is still true for non-parent populations? Just wondering, because it is invariably the mum who becomes the full-time parent, and as long working hours "jobs" go, parenting must be very near the top of the list in terms of physical stress.

Also the much-detested "yuppie flu" label comes from it being observed in those working in the London money markets (presumably yuppies so-named from saying "yup" all the time). But a key facet of working in those industries, is the very long and unrelenting hours they work. Yes, it is a mentally stressful working environment, but even bigger Yes, it is also very physically demanding work, especially in terms of long hours.
 
chrisb said:
You probably know this, but it was thought to stand for "young upwardly-mobile professional" or "young urban professional". There may be some too young to remember.
Click to expand...
No I didn't. But "yup" is also how some such folk tend to pronounce "yep", the common English corruption of "yes".
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom