Dolphin
Senior Member (Voting Rights)
Free fulltext:
https://www.cfp.ca/content/69/12/853
Medical assistance in dying when natural death is not reasonably foreseeable
Survey of providers’ experiences with patients making track 2 requests
Ellen Wiebe and Michaela Kelly
Canadian Family Physician December 2023, 69 (12) 853-858; DOI: https://doi.org/10.46747/cfp.6912853
Abstract
Objective To describe clinicians’ experiences with assessing patients making track 2 requests for medical assistance in dying (MAID) and providing MAID to such patients in the first 6 months after Canada amended relevant legislation in March 2021 to expand access to MAID.
Design Online survey with closed and open-ended questions about clinicians’ experiences with individual patients making track 2 MAID requests.
Setting Canada.
Participants Doctors and nurse practitioners who were members of the Canadian Association of MAID Assessors and Providers.
Main outcome measures The most common reasons patients gave for making track 2 MAID requests and the challenges providers identified in doing these assessments.
Results Twenty-three MAID providers submitted information about 54 patients who had made track 2 requests between March 17, 2021 and September 17, 2021. The most common diagnoses were chronic pain syndromes, affecting 28 patients (51.9%), and complex chronic conditions such as myalgic encephalomyelitis or chronic fatigue syndrome, affecting 8 patients (14.8%). The most common challenges providers reported were related to patients having concurrent mental illness, noted in 37 assessments (68.5%). In 8 cases (14.8%), providers faced challenges in finding experts to help with assessments. In 19 cases (35.2%), providers felt patients had not been offered all appropriate and available treatments, and in 9 cases (16.7%) providers encountered difficulties in finding such treatments for patients.
Conclusion Providers of MAID described many challenges in their experiences with patients making track 2 requests, including assessing individuals with concurrent mental illnesses, being uncertain that patients had been offered appropriate treatments prior to seeking MAID, and being unsure whether patients had seriously considered available treatments. Many providers experienced moral distress in attempting to balance patients’ rights with what might be in patients’ best interests. This is different from experiences providers have had with patients making track 1 requests, as most of these patients have end-stage malignancy or organ failure and seldom have unmet health care needs. This information could be used to enhance education and support for clinicians as they help patients with track 2 requests access their right to peaceful deaths.
https://www.cfp.ca/content/69/12/853
Medical assistance in dying when natural death is not reasonably foreseeable
Survey of providers’ experiences with patients making track 2 requests
Ellen Wiebe and Michaela Kelly
Canadian Family Physician December 2023, 69 (12) 853-858; DOI: https://doi.org/10.46747/cfp.6912853
Abstract
Objective To describe clinicians’ experiences with assessing patients making track 2 requests for medical assistance in dying (MAID) and providing MAID to such patients in the first 6 months after Canada amended relevant legislation in March 2021 to expand access to MAID.
Design Online survey with closed and open-ended questions about clinicians’ experiences with individual patients making track 2 MAID requests.
Setting Canada.
Participants Doctors and nurse practitioners who were members of the Canadian Association of MAID Assessors and Providers.
Main outcome measures The most common reasons patients gave for making track 2 MAID requests and the challenges providers identified in doing these assessments.
Results Twenty-three MAID providers submitted information about 54 patients who had made track 2 requests between March 17, 2021 and September 17, 2021. The most common diagnoses were chronic pain syndromes, affecting 28 patients (51.9%), and complex chronic conditions such as myalgic encephalomyelitis or chronic fatigue syndrome, affecting 8 patients (14.8%). The most common challenges providers reported were related to patients having concurrent mental illness, noted in 37 assessments (68.5%). In 8 cases (14.8%), providers faced challenges in finding experts to help with assessments. In 19 cases (35.2%), providers felt patients had not been offered all appropriate and available treatments, and in 9 cases (16.7%) providers encountered difficulties in finding such treatments for patients.
Conclusion Providers of MAID described many challenges in their experiences with patients making track 2 requests, including assessing individuals with concurrent mental illnesses, being uncertain that patients had been offered appropriate treatments prior to seeking MAID, and being unsure whether patients had seriously considered available treatments. Many providers experienced moral distress in attempting to balance patients’ rights with what might be in patients’ best interests. This is different from experiences providers have had with patients making track 1 requests, as most of these patients have end-stage malignancy or organ failure and seldom have unmet health care needs. This information could be used to enhance education and support for clinicians as they help patients with track 2 requests access their right to peaceful deaths.
Last edited:
