Medscape: A 36-Year-Old Woman in Undetermined Pain: Osmosis USMLE Study Question of the Week

It clearly illustrates that students are taught a logical fallacy: "If the problem cannot be identified, it means that it's some variant of psychogenic illness."

This is the polite version of what I wanted to say. The original version included the term mass delusion.
 
Last edited:
Just saw this on twitter and must say I agree..


Here is link to the test on Medscape:
A 36-Year-Old Woman in Undetermined Pain: Osmosis USMLE Study Question of the Week

It has gotten some comments and criticism.


I am hugely disappointed in how few comments there are (on Medscape) to this "study question". Just 7 comments at time of writing. And one of those is "Excelent (sic)". Another one refers to "it's just pain". And yet another "It's just a woman trying to get help for a condition that's unlikely to be found in an ER setting." Not important, naturally. Nothing to see here. Move along.
 
@Arnie Pye maybe they meant "It's just pain" as in: "For heaven's sake it's just pain! Get this indulgent Munchausen diagnosis melodrama out of here!"
___________

I'm sure it's been said before, but what bugs me about this stuff is that it is conspiracy theory thinking. Listening attentively is suspect. Knowledge of treatments is suspect. Not seeking worker's compensation? ALL PART OF THE RUSE (I guess?)!
But...
Not listening? Very suspect! No knowledge of treatments? Also part of the ruse! Seeking benefits? GAAAAAAH!

So once they can't explain your symptoms, everything about you and everything you do is used as evidence to convict you of some psychological problem... and would be even if it were the opposite!
 
Yes, the organisation who published the question has now retracted it and apologised, which is very good of them. But one wonders how something that blatantly bad made it past their content reviewers in the first place!


And on Medscape:
Editor's Note: Osmosis has removed this content from their database and requested it be retired on Medscape as of July 26, 2018. For more Osmosis USMLE Study Questions, read here.

It is great that this was addressed so quickly!
 
Thread merged

It is no secret that Grey’s writer Elisabeth Finch drew on her own experience with misdiagnosis for Bailey’s storyline. Both incidents, though, point to a persistent, often overlooked problem in medicine: women’s symptoms are often diminished and dismissed by doctors.

And, earlier this week, this issue was underlined when Karina Wagenpfeil tweeted photos of a practice exam question from Medscape.

In the multiple choice question, medical students are asked to choose a diagnosis for a woman who goes to the hospital for physical pain not detected by various lab tests.

The “correct” answer to the question is Munchausen syndrome, a mental disorder characterised by deliberate acts to seem ill to receive attention. Other options are somatisation disorder, conversion disorder, hypochondriasis, and malingering — none of which, Wagenpfeil points out, are physical disorders.
https://www.stylist.co.uk/life/meds...sis-fibroids-diagnosis-serena-williams/219755
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Back
Top Bottom