Qigong exercise for chronic fatigue syndrome, 2019, Chan et al

Andy

Retired committee member
Not a recommendation.
Chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) is often overlooked, has unclear etiology and no effective cure except some symptomatic treatments. Additionally, most people with CFS do not seek medical attention. Qigong exercise, an ancient Eastern body-mind-spirit practice, has been long practiced in Chinese communities and may powerfully trigger the self-healing process. Using full baseline data (n = 1409), the average Hong Kong CFS respondent was found to be female, married, 42.5yo, highly educated and employed full-time, experiencing sleep disturbance (~ 95%), anxiety (> 80%), and depressive symptoms (68%).

Here, we summarized our previous studies to evaluate the potential of Qigong as a complementary and alternative therapy for CFS. Two randomized controlled trials were conducted (RCT1 n1 = 137, RCT2 n2 = 150). In both trials, extensive online questionnaires allowed individuals with CFS-like illness (i.e., symptoms match CFS, yet without clinical confirmation) to be identified. RCT1 included a 5-week intervention. The intervention in RCT2 was 8 weeks.

In RCT1 Qigong group had reduced fatigue (P < 0.001) and depressive symptoms (P = 0.002), and improved telomerase activity (P = 0.029). An effective practice regimen was identified (≥ 3 days/week, at ≥ 30 min/session). Methods were slightly adjusted for RCT2, which replicated RCT1 findings, and further documented improved subjective sleep quality (P = 0.008) and adiponectin levels (P < 0.05). A significant dose-response relationship was founded.

Thus, Qigong exercise should be recognized as a possible standalone therapy and self-management skill in CFS. Strategies are needed to increase motivation for regular practice and to explore its possibility of self-management skill in brain health. Further clarity would come from studies comparing Qigong with other physical exercises.
Paywall, https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0074774219300674
Not available through Scihub at time of posting.
 
'Powerfully trigger the self-healing process' in people who are 'employed full-time' and who were not screened for PEM etc., huh?

I am fine with studying whatever you want in whomever you want, but what good is it to throw together cohorts with almost random common symptoms and then hijack a terminology that has a reasonably clear defintion (even for the broader psycho-CFS-definitions, 'sleep disturbance' would be such a broad term that I am not convinced it should ever catch less than 95% of any population at any given time). Reminds me of people in exercise science confusing intensity (straight %age of your maximum output) and intensiveness (basically, perceived workload).

Also, the studied population seems to be... representative of who would sign up for Qigong in general. So preselection for people who have no reason to not go through a mild exercise regimen is probably likely.

All in all - not too relevant for us as far as I can see.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps we know by now why these Hong Kong residents experience sleep dysfunction, anxiety, and depression. Political reasons?
 
To paraphrase someone who is not a smart man, yet clearly smarter than these dolts: fool is as fool does.
 
Perhaps we know by now why these Hong Kong residents experience sleep dysfunction, anxiety, and depression. Political reasons?

Hong Kong has long had high-pressure work life (that could lead to those symptoms you mentioned), that is one of the reasons for Hong Kong's economic success compared to the rest of Asia.

But Qigong itself is somewhat political, at least in mainland China. I'm not going to say more, due to forum rules...
 
Qigong itself is somewhat political, at least in mainland China
I didn't know that. Thanks for saying.

no effective cure except some symptomatic treatments. Additionally, most people with CFS do not seek medical attention... the average Hong Kong CFS respondent was found to be... employed full-time, experiencing sleep disturbance (~ 95%), anxiety (> 80%), and depressive symptoms (68%)... In both trials, extensive online questionnaires allowed individuals with CFS-like illness (i.e., symptoms match CFS, yet without clinical confirmation) to be identified.
All we need to know about the trial is in these sentences.

Symptoms are entirely vague, respondants are working full time, and inclusion was done entirely by questionnaire, no differential diagnosis.

Additionally, the authors believe there's an "effective cure" with "symptomatic treatments," which means they have not carefully read the literature.
 
Back
Top Bottom