The Recovery Channel, Rachel Whitfield and Paul Garner

A side matter, the CIPD went all-in on neuroscience and neuroplasticity a decade or so ago, I mean they are the Chartered Institute for Personnel and Development but it seemed a bit high-level, how many training and HR people need to learn about neurons to deliver training on GDPR or Appraisals really?
 

Attachments

  • IMG_6058.webp
    IMG_6058.webp
    267.6 KB · Views: 10
  • IMG_6057.webp
    IMG_6057.webp
    383.4 KB · Views: 10
"It wasn’t all horrendous. I discovered a wonderful yoga group for recovery from Covid, bought a hot tub, read a lot and meditated. One of the things that I am convinced helped my recovery right from the beginning was realising that the mind and body are connected. I celebrated every success, looked at what I could do and told myself daily that I would recover. I read success stories and avoided too much social media. I found things to enjoy about the down time."

So she only read success stories.

So now she has "Influencer brain" which refers to both the psychological toll content creation takes on the creator and neurological brain rewiring of audiences who consume endless feeds.
 
As mentioned earlier, here is a plain text type-up of the relevant part of The Recovery Channel CIC’s incorporation statement, which is publicly available information available from Companies House here https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/16946031/filing-history

N.B. This is from a standard CIC template which includes standard wording which every CIC will have in its statement.

SECTION A: COMMUNITY INTEREST STATEMENT – beneficiaries

We/I, the undersigned, declare that the company will carry on its activities for the benefit of the community, or a section of the community.

The company’s activities will primarily benefit people in the United Kingdom living with chronic fatigue and associated persistent symptoms.

By providing accessible, reliable, and evidence-informed information, the company will help individuals better understand their symptoms, explore potential pathways to recovery, and reduce social isolation.

While the primary focus is on the UK, the resources produced may also be relevant to people internationally experiencing similar conditions.

All resources will be freely accessible online or provided at minimal cost to ensure equitable access and broad public benefit.

The company will not provide medical diagnosis, medical advice, or treatment, but will complement existing NHS and healthcare services through education, information, and awareness-raising.


Activities

Project 1. Develop the “recovery channel”: a website to show people can recover, and to develop a portfolio of information to help inform people with chronic fatigue and other mind-body disorders.


Recovery narratives and supportive information are currently dispersed across multiple websites, blogs, and forums. The platform will create a central “recovery wall” bringing these stories together in one accessible place to inspire hope, reduce isolation, and strengthen community connection.

The website will also host educational material to help individuals understand their symptoms and explore approaches that may support symptom relief and recovery.

All content will be supportive and educational in nature and will not constitute medical advice or treatment.


Project 2. Develop a YouTube video channel called “Fatigue Science Channel”. This includes dialogue between patients, doctors and researchers in chronic fatigue conditions.

Video content enables people affected by fatigue, cognitive difficulties, or social isolation to engage more easily than with written materials alone.

This builds on pilot work through the Collaborative on Fatigue and Related Symptoms Following Infection (COFFI) and the Consumer Advisory Group and helps ensure content is credible, balanced, and patient-centred.

The channel will improve understanding, foster connection, and increase access to trustworthy educational content.


Project 3. Behind the headlines. The company will pilot a resource providing plain-English summaries and critical appraisals of emerging research relevant to chronic fatigue and associated conditions.

This will address confusing or misleading information found online and empower individuals to engage more critically with current evidence.

Community input will guide content, including priority topics and a myth-busting series.

All materials will be educational and supportive and will not offer medical diagnosis, medical advice, or treatment.


Any surplus generated by the company will be reinvested solely to further the company’s community purpose, including developing new resources, improving accessibility, and extending outreach.

No profits will be distributed to members or directors, and all assets and income will be used for the benefit of the community.
They have big ambitions. Rachel and Paul already had their role at COFFI where they have done some videos etc, and both have told their own story of recovery from brief post covid illness multiple times. But it seems that's not enough. They now want to create what is described as a major resource to compliment what the NHS provides. I assume thie idea is Rachel will do the recovery stories side and Paul will do the information side, though I note, as with LP and other 'training' they repeatedly say they aren't offering medical advice, they are providing materials that are 'educational' and 'supportive'.

I note also that they intend to take payment for some of their material.
All resources will be freely accessible online or provided at minimal cost to ensure equitable access and broad public benefit.

How can promoting unevidenced 'training' like LP and Gupta be equated with 'public benefit'.

Maybe they should be asked if they are willing to provide a section on their website for people to share their experiences of harm from brain retraining etc, and their 'evidence' section to ensure they give honest appraisal of trials such as MAGENTA that showed GET harmed some children with ME/CFS.
 
Would it be useful for us to have a section on S4 on CICs?

One perhaps looking into the 'what they/the regs are' and understanding a bit more about them, and then maybe people who know more could contribute and there might case studies type pages for ones that are specifically likely to be pertinent to pwme or 'news' on things that crop up with a CIC that sounds interesting to be aware of?

I don't know the details of how the charity commission work or the laws around getting any kind of charity or related ie CIC status. OK it seems there is an Office for CICs and it is about 'someone upholding their community mission'.

but this claim that we keep seeing used with a wink wink of 'for public benefit' seems to be something that perhaps there is a definition without specificity (or something similar) currently being tested - it seems rather close to the marketing plan/target market idea just being written down in slightly different wording (which well might include wanted to seek out and develop pages of 'advocates who just love to stay at our hotel chain/use our hair product etc', as part of the marketing rather than originating with said fans) and I'd be interested how things have to be different eg from a group that just loves a certain type of lego toy or film trilogy (and then limits it to a certain geographic area)

There is also the issue of literal responsibility and accountability - hence I'm noticing them giving advice whilst trying their best to underline that they aren't in the official documents. eg if harm should come or I don't know with CIC regarding things like mis-selling or advertising etc.

I'm intrigued by that for eg a CIC - it seems like it means liability would be corporate rather than person if its a company thing. And limited? There is a bit looking around at these about how directors often might get insurance too to protect themselves, so I guess not everything etc?
 
Would it be useful for us to have a section on S4 on CICs?

One perhaps looking into the 'what they/the regs are' and understanding a bit more about them, and then maybe people who know more could contribute and there might case studies type pages for ones that are specifically likely to be pertinent to pwme or 'news' on things that crop up with a CIC that sounds interesting to be aware of?

I don't know the details of how the charity commission work or the laws around getting any kind of charity or related ie CIC status. OK it seems there is an Office for CICs and it is about 'someone upholding their community mission'.

but this claim that we keep seeing used with a wink wink of 'for public benefit' seems to be something that perhaps there is a definition without specificity (or something similar) currently being tested - it seems rather close to the marketing plan/target market idea just being written down in slightly different wording (which well might include wanted to seek out and develop pages of 'advocates who just love to stay at our hotel chain/use our hair product etc', as part of the marketing rather than originating with said fans) and I'd be interested how things have to be different eg from a group that just loves a certain type of lego toy or film trilogy (and then limits it to a certain geographic area)

There is also the issue of literal responsibility and accountability - hence I'm noticing them giving advice whilst trying their best to underline that they aren't in the official documents. eg if harm should come or I don't know with CIC regarding things like mis-selling or advertising etc.

I'm intrigued by that for eg a CIC - it seems like it means liability would be corporate rather than person if its a company thing. And limited? There is a bit looking around at these about how directors often might get insurance too to protect themselves, so I guess not everything etc?
They are not charities.

It is a new type of limited company, which ploughs its profits back into the company (rather than paying dividends to shareholders, for example).

They are a bugbear of mine because people think they are basically charities, when they are basically companies.

The “community interest” can be anything, it could be a local foodbank, it could be nail technician training for out-of-work young people, an animal rescue, mindfulness for mums, homeless football team, burlesque dancers over age 50 Rugby team, anything really, it’s very loose.

Whilst it’s a nice idea that someone might start a properly-documented zero waste food bank, equally there are all kinds of less worthy training companies, mentoring, business upskilling, which appear and disappear, and whilst there are no “profits” there do seem to be people taking rather large salaries from the income, in some cases leaving the CIC with barely any funds.

From my limited knowledge there’s nothing at all wrong with the proposed CIC nor would there be any issue with the directors claiming business expenses or even eventually being employed by the CIC and taking a salary.

I’d say the biggest “keep your eyes peeled” is that they don’t give medical advice.
 
On a Millions Missing post quoting singer Sinead O’Connor (presumably talking about Fibromyalgia or chronic pain which she suffered with) she said “ it is made worse obviously by stress, so you have to try to keep life quiet and peaceful”

Rachel Whitfield has commented “ or you can try and react differently to stressful events”

Is this part of the volunteering for hours through the goodness of her heart?
Arguing with or criticising a dead woman about how she managed her health? Who also had bipolar? Whose son took his own life?
Very, very poor taste.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_6065.webp
    IMG_6065.webp
    89.9 KB · Views: 17
Last edited:
On a Millions Missing post quoting singer Sinead O’Connor (presumably talking about Fibromyalgia or chronic pain which she suffered with) she said “ it is made worse obviously by stress, so you have to try to keep life quiet and peaceful”

Rachel Whitfield has commented “ or you can try and react differently to stressful events”

Is this part of the volunteering for hours through the goodness of her heart?
Arguing with or criticising a dead woman about how she managed her health? Who also had bipolar? Whose son took his own life?
Very, very poor taste.
The comment was removed for violating community standards
 
On a Millions Missing post quoting singer Sinead O’Connor (presumably talking about Fibromyalgia or chronic pain which she suffered with) she said “ it is made worse obviously by stress, so you have to try to keep life quiet and peaceful”

Rachel Whitfield has commented “ or you can try and react differently to stressful events”
That is in very poor taste.
 
So let me get this straight. These people recovered from long covid (presumably not long covid type ME/CFS -- otherwise they would state that) in a few months, as happens with many LC patients, and are now selling something based on their "lived experience?"

They actually think their 6 months lived experience with long covid has any relevance to people disabled from ME/CFS for decades?

That is truly depraved.

Edit to add: I read Rachel's blog post. She had post viral symptoms for about 5 months. Started recovering only 6 weeks into the whole thing.

I can't imagine starting to get better after 6 weeks and thinking that experience applies to everyone else who've been sick for years.
 
Last edited:
So let me get this straight. These people recovered from long covid (presumably not long covid type ME/CFS -- otherwise they would state that) in a few months, as happens with many LC patients, and are now selling something based on their "lived experience?"

They actually think their 6 months lived experience with long covid has any relevance to people disabled from ME/CFS for decades?

That is truly depraved.
That’s about right for Garner and Whitfield, I’d say.
Garner Isnt even a reliable narrator of his own story, he’s actively destroying any credibility brain training “could” have had.
 
Posts moved from: UK: Beth Dobbin -- BBC: The Olympic sprinter now bedbound for 22 hours a day


Rachel Whitfield and Paul Garner are doing so much harm. They have no evidence any of their Recovery Channel people either had ME/CFS or recovered from ME/CFS. They both had symptoms for a few months after Covid and recovered. They are using their irrelevant stories to promote unevidenced brain retraining. This gaslights sick people. They should be ashamed of themselves.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Rachel Whitfield and Paul Garner are doing so much harm. They have no evidence any of their Recovery Channel people either had ME/CFS or recovered from ME/CFS. They both had symptoms for a few months after Covid and recovered. They are using their irrelevant stories to promote unevidenced brain retraining. This gaslights sick people. They should be ashamed of themselves.


The Recovery Channel does Advertising via it's links to the Stories which contain links to commercial businesses selling 'recovery courses or programs' (a prominent link is to Raelan Agle's You Tube channel).
But The Recovery Channel absolves itself of any responsibility for harm, loss, damage, resulting from desperate ME/CFS or LC or other patients who do not recover, or become even more sick from following those links and paying out to do commercial 'recovery courses'.

Is this a new admission from Garner and Whitfield?
'We acknowledge that for some people, mind-body approaches did not lead to improvement.'


'The Recovery Channel' Legal Notice -

''Where our site contains links to other sites and resources provided by third parties, these links are provided for your information only.
We are not responsible for and have no control over the contents of those sites or resources and accept no responsibility for them or for any loss or damage that may arise from your use of them.'



On the Recovery Wall (Of stories):

'Important note​

The Recovery Wall is a curated collection of websites that contain patient narratives, particularly those that describe how people recovered. Some of these stories are published on websites created by service providers related to these conditions. Their inclusion does not imply endorsement of these providers by the Recovery Channel®. We acknowledge that for some people, mind-body approaches did not lead to improvement. You should always consult a healthcare professional before making decisions about your health.'
(My Underlining)

.
 
Last edited:
The «providers» that publish those recovery stories might be in breach of the marketing rules with regards to alternative treatments. I don’t know where specific countries draw the line.
 
Back
Top Bottom