Looks like the VADYS-ME study found something similar:
https://s4me.info/threads/investigations-of-vascular-dysfunction-and-hypoperfusion-in-patients-diagnosed-with-me-cfs-vadys-me-2027-d%C3%B6hner-et-al.51494/post-716581
I wrote a brief blog article on the buspirone findings to help highlight the findings. It links to this S4ME discussion and the excellent overview by forestglip.
https://mecfsscience.org/increased-prolactin-response-to-buspirone/
Excellent work!
The group tags probably aren't that important. The main thing to note is that several studies were students from working under Behan as your review already does.
I calculated an effect size (Hedges g) using the data in the thesis.
Males
Using prolactin values after 1 hour
-1.38 [-2.42, -0.30]
Using prolactin difference between baseline and 1 hour
- 1.45 [-2.51, -0.36]
Females
Using prolactin values after 1 hour
-1.71 [-2.96, -0.40]
Using prolactin...
Yes that might be the more conservative option. The plot does show 15-minute intervals before the administration of buspirone. And as ScoutB says, the growth hormone plot also shows the same intervals up unto 240 so perhaps it's simply a bad description in the methods section.
I've been extracting the data from the graphs in the buspirone studies, it looks something like this. For Bakheit 1992 I took males only, Sharpe 1996 is also males only, the other studies have both sexes combined.
EDIT: there might be an error in the Sharpe 1996 original data plot, see the...
I think the Sharpe 1996 (Cowen group) study had a pretty good view on the problem saying it was likely the dopamine instead of serotonin pathway that was abnormal. They wrote:
Increased prolactin response to buspirone in chronic fatigue syndrome - PubMed
My guess is that buspirone was seen as...
I have the CIBA symposium book from 1993 but it doesn't have much discussion on the buspirone tests. Doesn't work to upload the doc but here are some screenshot of the places where buspirone or prolactin is mentioned, the discussion moves to other topic afterwards.
First section:
Then a bit...
Yeah maybe the dopamine system in ME/CFS is less responsive so that those natural stimuli that reduce it centrally have less impact and thus we see a blunted prolactin response.
But when you don't impact the dopamine system itself but simply block the dopamine that's already there, we see an...
There are a couple of studies that tried to block the serotonin route of buspirone and measure what effect it had on its prolactin effect. This 2001 study found that approximately 50% of its effect on prolactin disappeared when participants are first given the 5-HT1A antagonist pindolol.
So...
Thanks, updated. There may be other errors because I didn't double-check.
The 'effect size' are based on simply eyeballing the graphs and dividing the peak by the baseline value regardless at which hour the peak was. If the plan is to publish in a journal, one could perhaps use software to...
Some thoughts about the cause and mechanism
The normal prolactin response after mCPP (and some dl-fenfluramine studies), and attenuated response after exercise and the insulin stress test suggests that there isn't some mechanism at play that simply shows increased prolactin responses in ME/CFS...
Limitations
After reading the studies, one big limitation is that they were all quite small: almost all studies have less than 30 ME/CFS patients.
The prolactine results also show a lot of variability in the results and there are multiple factors that might influence it (sex, menstruation...
Am re-reading the studies anyway, so here's an example of the table I had in mind:
StudyPatients - controlsStimulantEffect on prolactinNotes
Bakheit 1992
(Behan group)15 post-viral fatigue syndrome patients
40% female
13 healthy controls
13 depressed controls60 mg
buspironeSimilar...
Thanks for highlighting this.
ECP = eosinophil cationic protein
EDN = eosinophil-derived neurotoxin
So these are eosinophil proteins that they assume would also be increased in case of chronic mast cell activation.
Impressive work @forestglip, thanks for digging into this!
Small suggestion for your summary: it would be useful to have a table of the ME/CFS studies with the number of participants they used (male/female), the type stimulant and dosage used and possibly info about the effect size.
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.