Search results

  1. Jonathan Edwards

    What blood tests would you get?

    Could be so, but probably not the cytokines we usually associate with inflammation. People with rheumatoid arthritis used to have sky high cytokines for years and they never got brain fog or PEM or anything. When we blocked the cytokines they were fine.
  2. Jonathan Edwards

    Format of NICE stakeholder meeting?

    I think this is for UK stakeholders. I suspect about 50 will turn up, which may be quite good. I am just wondering if I may need to go incognito. I think I may take a big felt pen so that I can put S4ME in big letters on my badge.
  3. Jonathan Edwards

    High CMV IgG titers. What to do?

    It is always possible that there are peculiar modes of infection used by very unusual viruses but in general none of this impacts a general approach to antibody titres. Chasing wisps of straw in the wind when you have a bale sitting beside you seems to me unproductive.
  4. Jonathan Edwards

    High CMV IgG titers. What to do?

    I don't think there is any serious debate here within the general research community. Dr Lerner came up with this strange theory years ago and when I looked at his explanation of the case he seemed to wander off into irrelevancies. Other than him I doubt you will find a virologist who takes this...
  5. Jonathan Edwards

    Stigma in Myalgic Encephalomyelitis and its association with functioning, 2018, Baken et al

    Yes, that was my thought. But how do we know whether they are reporting a real property of other people (being sniffy) or there sensitivity to sniffiness? And surely we would expect both to correlate with functional disability. To the extent that a p value is a bit silly. You do not sort your...
  6. Jonathan Edwards

    Stigma in Myalgic Encephalomyelitis and its association with functioning, 2018, Baken et al

    This seems to be a misuse of the word stigma: Dictionary: 'If something has a stigma attached to it, people think it is something to be ashamed of.' That is to say a stigma is a perception by onlookers of a class of condition or circumstance. Patients do not have stigmas or degrees of stigma...
  7. Jonathan Edwards

    High CMV IgG titers. What to do?

    You need to take advice from your physician. However, high antibody levels simply show a good level of antibody-based immunity to viruses. They do not in themselves indicate current infection or any need for treatment.
  8. Jonathan Edwards

    Format of NICE stakeholder meeting?

    All I think may be achieved is that the range of opinions may be laid out.
  9. Jonathan Edwards

    Esther Crawley gets 'commendation' at 2017 Maddox Prize awards.

    As indicated previously, I wrote to Colin Blakemore to voice my concerns some time back. I then contacted the chair of the trustees, Paul Hardaker and have also copied in Lord Rees, who was on the panel with Blakemore and Tracey Brown, and Lord and Lady Taverne, who set up SAS. I have had...
  10. Jonathan Edwards

    Nature: A reboot for chronic fatigue syndrome research

    I am afraid it is all much more complicated. The first problem with the cyclophosphamide trials is that they have to be unblinded because cyclophosphamide makes most people very nauseous. So responses may be placebo effects of one sort or another. The sad irony, as I have mentioned before, is...
  11. Jonathan Edwards

    What blood tests would you get?

    Not really, that is a different process again. Lymph nodes are normally stuffed full of white blood cell (lymphocytes) as is the spleen,so 'inflammation' of a lymph node is a rather dubious term. Lymph nodes usually get large and tender when the lymphocytes inside become activated and start...
  12. Jonathan Edwards

    Is COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics) fit for purpose?

    Maybe Shakespeare's Richard III and Steve Bannon/Michael Wolff's book give a clue. When a group of people are driven by a lust for power what tends to destroy them is each other. One of the things that puzzles me about the names that keep popping up in the media groups is that they have...
  13. Jonathan Edwards

    ME Association: Website survey: What do you think should be our research funding priorities for 2018?

    This is not the situaiton. The Biobank samples are collected and stored using the most reliable methods available to lab research, which are fine for most studies. Moreover, the Biobank people are in discussion with groups who have made careful analysis of suitability of these storage methods...
  14. Jonathan Edwards

    Trial By Error: The School Absence Study, Revisited (Crawley/SMILE)

    Interesting reading. Dr Fiona Godlee [2] “the quiet majority of patients must make sure that their reasonable voices are heard" And now they are being heard (By CDC, NICE, Nature, Buzzfeed readers) and they are not saying quite what Dr Godlee seemed to expect.
  15. Jonathan Edwards

    What blood tests would you get?

    When prostaglandins and TNF affect the hypothalamus it alters its thermoregulatory cell activity and your temperature goes up because of autonomic signals to metabolising tissues. When cytokines reach the chemoreceptor trigger zone or nausea centre nerve cells send signals to other parts of the...
  16. Jonathan Edwards

    Nature: A reboot for chronic fatigue syndrome research

    The deduction is a bit strongly worded but I tend to agree it is likely to be correct.
  17. Jonathan Edwards

    What blood tests would you get?

    We don't know but I don't think it has anything to do with inflammation in flu. It is an effect on the brain of circulating factors that may include gamma interferon and prostaglandins. But the brain does not get inflamed as a result. Presumably prostaglandins are not that relevant in ME...
  18. Jonathan Edwards

    Trial By Error: COPE to BMJ Open: More Details, Please!

    I think the editor is the highest up person that matters. Beyond that you have shareholders of faceless companies if anything. I would expect the editor, Fiona Godlee, to be well aware of what is going on.
  19. Jonathan Edwards

    ME Association: Website survey: What do you think should be our research funding priorities for 2018?

    He has also had a hundred and thirty seven relatives staying for Christmas and is bushed out. Give him a break chaps!! He will be back in good time.
  20. Jonathan Edwards

    Trial By Error: The School Absence Study, Revisited (Crawley/SMILE)

    Yes,I would be interested to see the video.
Back
Top Bottom