Search results

Actually, the journal closed the case itself, it would seem, without acting on COPE's advice to investigate further. The COPE statement from the journal was full of misleading information and actually false information--such as the claim that the study involved anonymous data when in fact...

He's supposed to be having a book about ME published soon. And I had no idea he practiced psychotherapy. Did he have training as a therapist? I mean, are GPs in Canada allowed to provide psychotherapy?

Ah, that's interesting. I'll amend my post I guess.

Hi, I just saw this--yes, I'm interested. I don't remember getting a Facebook message about this but certainly I miss things.

The idea that I was "instrumental" in persuading Cochrane to do anything is ridiculous. I had a meeting with David Tovey in which I pressed the case. Period.

He also tweeted about my original Trial by Error series that it was an "ad hominem attack," if I remember correctly.

anybody have the full study?

This is true of course. But a well-written account of, say, 20 or however many clinic patients interviewed or questioned in a systematic way would be a contribution to the literature. Even if if were randomized, they would find a way to criticize it. Qualitative research can't be used to make...

I think a qualitative study of people's accounts on this would definitely make a good paper.

This might or might not be true. But I see no reason to take their word for it that the change was based on the qualitative findings, especially given a history of not telling the truth about the conduct of the trial. They didn't need to analyze the data to know which way trends were heading and...

About the school attendance records--this was listed in both the protocols for the feasibility trial as well as the full trial protocol. They didn't report it in the feasibility trial report. They presumably already knew they didn't have the "capacity" to gather those data by the time they wrote...

wow! what kind of an insane person would devote that kind of energy on such a piece of garbage??

The journal publisher has previously been accused of publishing so-called "predatory" journals. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MDPI#Controversial_articles

Hi I'm confused how this would work. You got CBT from this private organization rather than NHS? But NHS covers the cost?

I can understand that. They have different goals. It's good for me to try to do a mix of both.

Thanks. I'm sure there are other instances out there as well. I'm sure most don't read the study but just pick up the mistake from previous mis-citations.

Roughly, the calculated cost (and I'm not endorsing Bemingham et al's figures) was about 3 billion pounds in the year examined. The total NHS budget that year was around 100 billion. The cost of services for those of working age was about 30 billion. So the misstatement makes it seem like the...

It's been a while but did anyone notice if "later next year" actually happened? It's a bummer that the document isn't OCRed, makes going through it harder than it should. The issue does not seem to have come up in the rest of the minutes that I could see. Lucibee also mentioned that in her...

Hey Richard--can you tell me where in the trial meeting notes this is? I'm trying to write a post about the actometer issue. I see some of the references in the trial meeting notes but didn't see that point being made. The main issue raised as I saw was that the failure to demonstrate any...

Right. and yet she still let herself get used by the SMC to promote that piece of crap And when I pointed out to her the methodological problems, she misread them and, for a second time, gave the study a clean bill of health. Her actions on this matter have been disgraceful.