Post copied from UK News Gerald Coakley runs the Fatigue Clinic in London
The Telegraph: Our series The Expert View brings you specialist health advice from professionals. In this article, we hear from Dr Gerald Coakley, a consultant rheumatologist and founder of The Fatigue Clinic, about the realities of living with ME and the treatments offering hope to sufferers.
Telegraph
'Rheumatologist Dr Gerald Coakley worked as a consultant at Queen Elizabeth Hospital, Woolwich, for more than two decades. Since 2001, he has run The Fatigue Clinic, initially in London Bridge, moving online permanently following the pandemic. He is the author of Living with ME and Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (Penguin). Dr Coakley was chair of the education and training committee at the British Society for Rheumatology from 2019 to 2022.'
The Telegraph: Our series The Expert View brings you specialist health advice from professionals. In this article, we hear from Dr Gerald Coakley, a consultant rheumatologist and founder of The Fatigue Clinic, about the realities of living with ME and the treatments offering hope to sufferers.
The OT co-author is Beverly Knops, who is now Executive Manager and Senior Occupational Therapist at Vitality360 (alongside Vitality 360 Founder, Director, and PACE Trial Therapists' Manual (GET) author, Senior Physiotherapist Jessica Sands (Bavinton)
.
BOOKINGS NOW CLOSED Working with fatigue can be complex. However with a strategy to support assessment and intervention it can feel much clearer. Relevant for professionals already working in specialist services and those working with persistent fatigue in other settings.
www.vitality360.co.uk
Vitality 360. Beverly does appear to be still involved in ME/CFS:
Beverly Knops
Executive Manager and Senior Occupational Therapist at Vitality360.
'Beverly Completed her Occupational Therapy training in 1988. She has spent most of her career working with people experiencing persistent pain and fatigue.
She worked in North Bristol NHS Trust (NBT) for 29 years, starting in the Rheumatology services, then moving into the Specialist Pain and ME/CFS services. Beverly says that her main achievement at NBT was leading the patient volunteer programme.
She trained and supervised patients with lived experience who are now involved in all aspects of the service, including co facilitating self-management courses.
During this time she also spent a period of nine years working one day a week for the Bath Paediatric ME/CFS service, developing her knowledge and expertise in this age group.
In 2012 Beverly started work as an associate therapist with Vitality360. In 2018 she was asked to take on the management of the company and following a difficult decision in 2021 to leave the NHS , she now leads this team full time.
Beverly was a trustee for BACME for a period of 8 years where she was actively involved in the training stream, including supporting 4 conferences. She recently stood down from this position to join the Vocational Rehabilitation Association board where she is keen to bring her expertise in pain and fatigue but also learn more about how we can optimise the chance of people with persistent symptoms returning to and sustaining work.'
Rehabilitation programmes for people with persistent pain and fatigue.
Have you had to stop doing the things that you used to enjoy? Can you barely think straight? Are you having trouble sustaining work? Are you struggling with persistent pain? Are you debilitated by constant tiredness and fatigue? Do you need some help making changes to improve your current career or job situation?
If you answered yes to any of these…
Then you’re in the right place to get some help...
Beverly Knops Dip COT, MRCOT, MBACME is a Specialist Occupational Therapist with more than thirty years' experience. She has spent the majority of her career working with people experiencing persistent pain and fatigue. She worked in North Bristol NHS Trust (NBT) for twenty-nine years, starting in the rheumatology service, then moving into the Specialist Pain and ME/CFS services. She also spent a period of nine years working one day a week for the Bath Paediatric ME/CFS service, developing her knowledge and expertise in this age group. In 2012, Beverly started work as an associate therapist with Vitality360, a private company working exclusively with people experiencing pain and fatigue. She now leads this specialist team full-time. Beverly is a trustee of the British Association of Clinicians working in ME/CFS (BACME) and is passionate about sharing knowledge and skills with other health professionals.
I've learned over the years that one can always tell when a nerve has recently been hit when an expert in this illness rolls up, usually in The Telegraph.
I saw this doctor fairly soon after onset. He prescribed me reading a book by Trudie Chalder and then onward to a psychiatrist, who told me to take two 20 minute walks a day to get over things.
I saw this doctor fairly soon after onset. He prescribed me reading a book by Trudie Chalder and then onward to a psychiatrist, who told me to take two 20 minute walks a day to get over things.
I have seen this word 'Hope' increasingly weaponized in this illness since it was first used in the 'Anomalies' paper in 2023 criticising the NICE Guideline ng206.
People who criticise the premis of specific rehabilitative techniques in ME/CFS clinics or advocate for more biological research funding or refer to harms caused to some by them, are often accused of lacking in, or taking away hope for others, and, increasingly accused of silencing recovery stories
Dr Coakley uses it in this article:
How is it treated?
Just as there is almost certainly no single cause of ME/CFS, there is currently no single cure. The most recent Nice guidance, from 2021, states that there is no treatment or cure, yet the narrative that ME/CFS is untreatable removes any sense of hope in patients and their families and is, in my opinion, actively harmful, as is promoting the unrealistic belief that a pharmacological cure is just around the corner.
So I decided to look into it's various definitions.
Used in psychology, it's use and definition derives from C R Snyder.
C.R. Snyder’s Hope Theory defines hope not as a passive emotion or wishful thinking, but as a positive motivational state rooted in the interactive combination of three cognitive components: Goals, Pathways Thinking, and Agency Thinking.
Hope is dynamic: Pathways and Agency constantly feed into one another. If you have a clear plan (pathway) but doubt yourself, agency drops. If you feel motivated (agency) but hit a brick wall with no alternate route, hope falters. When combined effectively, they create resilience, better problem-solving, and higher well-being across academic, athletic, health, and workplace domains.
Originally introduced by psychologist Rick Snyder in the mid-1990s (The Psychology of Hope: You Can Get There From Here), the model forms one of the foundational pillars of positive psychology.
Link to Positive Psychology explaining in more detail, which I've put in full in the spoiler.
Explore the importance of hope theory in positive psychology.
positivepsychology.com
Watching the news, I sometimes feel hopeless about how humans treat one another and the environment we share.
And yet, when I step into the world, connect with others, and witness everyday acts of kindness, I find myself filled with hope. Ultimately, it’s a choice. We can choose hope over despair, desperation, and despondency (Snyder, 2002).
Rick Snyder’s hope theory (2000) recognizes hope as an ongoing and dynamic process involving goal-directed energy and planning to meet those goals (Colla et al., 2022).
This article explores the importance of hope theory in positive psychology and highlights how pathway thinking can help drive meaningful change.
Understanding Hope Theory: Goals, Agency & Pathways
In the mid-1990s, Rick Snyder (1994), a professor at the University of Kansas, launched his hope theory in his book The Psychology of Hope: You Can Get There From Here.
He continued to refine the theory throughout the 2000s until he died in 2006 (Colla et al., 2022).
Snyder’s hope theory (2000, 2002) is built on the belief that hope is a positive motivational state reliant on the successful combination of two key elements:
Goal-directed agency: the motivation and determination to pursue goals
Pathways (planning to meet goals): the ability to identify the necessary strategies and routes to achieve those goals
Hope theory recognizes the dynamic interplay and positive connection between agency and pathway thinking to deliver a cumulative experience of hope (Colla et al., 2022).
Simply put, hope involves both the willpower to act and the ability to find ways to reach desired outcomes (Snyder, 2000).
Hope theory continues to evolve and is recognized as “one of the key theories underpinning the development of positive psychology” (Colla et al., 2022, p. 3).
However, its critics point out its individualistic focus and failure to consider contextual and emotional factors (Colla et al., 2022).
Hope Fatigue: Why People Get Stuck
Hope is one of the key predictors of well-being throughout our lifespan. As a result, it’s no surprise that poor mental health is often linked to loss of energy and fatigue due to a lack of hope (Snyder, 2000).
Hope fatigue, in particular, can be found in clients experiencing poor psychological and physical wellness, along with those mentally exhausted or recovering from trauma (Steffen et al., 2019; Grigoras & Ciubara, 2024).
However, anyone can become stuck in a bad situation. As a result, they may become tired of maintaining hope and believe that only something miraculous can help them transform their lives and create a flourishing future (Seligman, 2019).
Understanding the factors that enable hope to emerge and sustain itself, particularly when faced with challenging environments and events, can help clients mitigate hope fatigue (Colla et al., 2022).
Hope fatigue and feelings of being stuck need not be forever. Hope theory and positive psychology have many ways of helping clients move forward and transform their lives with hope. Helpful strategies can include fostering social support, focusing on meaningful goals and how to achieve them, and building resilience to unforeseen difficulties (Snyder, 2000; Seligman, 2011).
A Closer Look at Pathways in Hope Theory
Losing hope can lead to apathy. When things go wrong, clients often progress through stages of hopelessness (Snyder, 2000):
Stages of hopelessness
Hope
↓
Rage
↓
Despair
↓
Apathy
Clients can avoid or reverse the downward spiral by finding multiple, alternative pathways to their desired outcomes (Snyder, 2000).
Multiple “routes to the desired goals are absolutely essential for successful hopeful thought” (Snyder, 2000, p. 9).
In Snyder’s (2000, p. 10) hope theory, agency (the motivational component) combined with pathway thinking “taps the perceived ability to produce plausible routes to goals,” creating the mental willpower for hopeful thinking.
It can be captured in the following simple equation:
Hope = Agency + Pathways
When both elements are present, the person perceives that they can move from their current situation to their desired one via a chosen route (Snyder, 2000).
A client’s hopeful, goal-focused thinking works as motivation (agency), igniting their ability to plan pathways to achieve their goals (Snyder, 2000).
Ultimately, success may involve more than one route. The client will likely generate multiple strategies to achieve goals and overcome obstacles in their path. Hope generates both preventive and restorative actions that help clients create and sustain positive outcomes (Colla et al., 2022).
Hopeful Adaptation & Pathways Thinking
Hope adaptation refers to our ability to adjust and thrive when confronted with challenges. “Hopeful thinking not only should facilitate success during unimpeded goal pursuits, but it should be especially helpful in the face of impediments” (Snyder, 2000, p. 11).
Pathways thinking remains a vital element of flourishing lives, involving our cognitive ability to identify multiple flexible routes to achieve our goals and overcome difficulties along the way (Colla et al., 2022).
Hope adaptation and pathways thinking highlight the dynamic relationship between motivation and planning and clients’ ability to maintain resilience and goal-directed behavior (Colla et al., 2022).
Together, hope adaptation and pathways thinking enable individuals to perceive barriers as temporary obstacles to be overcome and create contingency plans when they can’t proceed. The process allows them to thrive despite adversity and uncertainty, for example, when progressing to higher education, managing a divorce, or taking on a new role in the workplace (Colla et al., 2022).
Paired with agency (motivation or energy to push forward) in a reciprocal relationship, pathway thinking can drive hope and adaptive functioning.
Recent research suggests expanding Snyder’s original hope theory to include two additional factors that further facilitate hopeful adaptation (Colla et al., 2022):
“Why power” is intrapersonal and refers to our sense of meaning. It builds on the idea that hope is fueled by long-term goals that align with our personal identity beyond self-interest.
“We power” is interpersonal and connects with our social resources. It relies on social connectedness, the sharing of resources, and the dynamic interplay between social systems and pathway thinking.
Together, they contribute to both the emergence and sustainability of hopeful adaptation (Colla et al., 2022).
10 Practical Strategies Based on Hope Theory
Hope theory offers our clients many strategies for building and maintaining hope. They can apply them individually or combined (Snyder, 2000; Colla et al., 2022).
Goal setting Identify and set meaningful goals that are attainable within the time available. Goals should be specific, actionable, and offer clear direction. Clients can ask themselves, “What is important to me? How does this goal contribute to my long-term vision of success?”
Develop pathways thinking Focus on multiple plans or paths to achieve the goal. Alternative solutions and strategies are helpful for overcoming expected and unexpected obstacles.
Enhance agency thinking Build and maintain the motivation needed to reach the goal. Intrinsic motivation is long-lasting and relies upon meeting basic psychological needs, including engaging with our sense of connection, control, and mastery (Ryan & Deci, 2018).
Anticipate barriers Anticipate what could get in the way of successful outcomes. High-hope clients typically embrace alternative pathways when faced with impediments.
Revisit pathways and agency Continuously assess and revise (where necessary) plans and motivations on the journey toward goal attainment to ensure adaptability and sustained effort.
Focus on positive emotions Goal-directed thinking supports and relies upon positive emotions. Break the larger goal into smaller milestones. Track progress and recognize and reward success along the way. This will help clients avoid being overwhelmed while encouraging them to manage their emotions and maintain motivation.
Learn from past experiences Prior successes and failures can be helpful and should not be ignored. Reflect on them to refine goal-directed strategies and create a future-oriented mindset.
Collaborate and welcome support Promote teamwork. Success needn’t be an individual activity. High-hope individuals typically thrive in collaborative environments, tackling problems together and sharing their wins.
Visualize positive outcomes Take time out to reflect on what success looks like and how it will feel. Doing so will reinforce purpose and direction.
Encourage storytelling and narrative sharing Sharing stories of hope, resilience, and success can foster a sense of community and mutual inspiration. That encourages goal-directed and value-led actions.
Each strategy supports the cognitive, emotional, and social resources that build hope, flexible thinking, and thriving across multiple life domains (Colla et al., 2022).
The Benefits of Cultivating Multiple Hopes
Having several important goals across work, relationships, health and beyond serve as a powerful resource for sustained well-being, maintaining positive outcomes in multiple life domains (Colla et al., 2022).
Cultivating multiple hopes and practicing flexible hopeful adaptation has the following benefits:
Helps manage stress and trauma
Hope supports psychological adjustment, particularly in the face of unexpected ordeals and adversity. As a result, hope can enhance resilience and buffer against the adverse effects of collective trauma and stressful situations (Liu et al., 2017).
Improves academic and life success
Hope is linked to heightened academic and work achievement and enhanced persistence and coping strategies. High-hope individuals perceive obstacles as challenges while developing contingency plans to overcome them (Snyder et al., 2002; Dixson et al., 2017).
Levels social status
Hope has the potential to mediate the relationship between socioeconomic status and academic achievement by providing the motivation and energy required for goal achievement (Snyder, 2000; Colla et al.,
[*]2022).
[*]Creates more meaning
[*]Hope is closely linked to our sense of meaning and purpose. It is a valuable source of motivation and structure and can help us create value-led positive outcomes (Colla et al., 2022).
[*]Improves social connectedness
[*]High-hope individuals seek connections. They provide support for others in achieving their goals and welcome their help in their personal pursuits (Colla et al., 2022).
[*]Boosts resilience
[*]Boosting hope supports generating alternative pathways that help clients identify and implement workarounds when their initial routes are blocked (Snyder, 2000).
[*]Supports mental
[*]Hope is a protective factor for mental health, reducing the impact of loneliness, poor family functioning, and challenging times outside of the individual’s control (Pan et al., 2021).
[*]In summary, the dynamic nature of hope supports resilience, goal-directed behavior, and psychological well-being, even in the most challenging circumstances (Colla et al., 2022).
I think where I find the "you are destroying hope" argument so egregious is in regards to a lot of the controlled failed studies where many fellow sufferers are then claiming a subset got better. I don't really know how to handle it because their understanding of bias, placebo and analysis of the data is clearly not there so its just impossible to properly address it. But hope is not generated by people taking a medication that doesn't work and has shown not to work. Its generated by good studies and trials being conducted that move our understanding on and the funding of those studies. More stuff that doesn't help builds hopelessness not hope.
"Just as there is almost certainly no single cause of ME/CFS, there is currently no single cure. The most recent Nice guidance, from 2021, states that there is no treatment or cure, yet the narrative that ME/CFS is untreatable removes any sense of hope in patients and their families and is, in my opinion, actively harmful, as is promoting the unrealistic belief that a pharmacological cure is just around the corner."
This is a terrible muddle of manipulation and straw man argument from my dear friend and colleague Gerald. But of course it is also lifted straight from the received BPS dogma.
C.R. Snyder’s Hope Theory defines hope not as a passive emotion or wishful thinking, but as a positive motivational state rooted in the interactive combination of three cognitive components: Goals, Pathways Thinking, and Agency Thinking.
Hope is dynamic: Pathways and Agency constantly feed into one another. If you have a clear plan (pathway) but doubt yourself, agency drops. If you feel motivated (agency) but hit a brick wall with no alternate route, hope falters. When combined effectively, they create resilience, better problem-solving, and higher well-being across academic, athletic, health, and workplace domains.
I look forward to a new law making it illegal to sell false hope to ill people. Like the law against selling cancer cures. Once upon a time most disabled people were still in residential institutions, there were very few homeless people, people were broken by drugs, alcohol, mental illness, social rejection and personal failure, but on the whole ill people got better, but there were a lot of people apparently active being newly treated for diseased organs and asthma etc who would not have been out and about otherwise.
ME/CFS remains one of medicine’s most misunderstood illnesses. Here’s what we know about its causes, symptoms and treatments
www.telegraph.co.uk
This is the fb post:
cut and pasted the text from it for those not on fb
"ME/CFS can, in its most severe form, leave patients bedbound, struggling to feed themselves, wash or tolerate light and sound, though symptoms can ebb and flow"
Dr Gerald Coakley realised "that conventional medicine had largely abandoned this large group of often severely disabled people"
Here’s what we know about its causes, symptoms and treatments
I think where I find the "you are destroying hope" argument so egregious is in regards to a lot of the controlled failed studies where many fellow sufferers are then claiming a subset got better. I don't really know how to handle it because their understanding of bias, placebo and analysis of the data is clearly not there so its just impossible to properly address it. But hope is not generated by people taking a medication that doesn't work and has shown not to work. Its generated by good studies and trials being conducted that move our understanding on and the funding of those studies. More stuff that doesn't help builds hopelessness not hope.
Bottom line is I don't think they even started using it because of any reading of any real hope theories on their behalf
It was simply a way of sugar-coating a decision by the bps to incite undermining informed consent (maybe based on their 'old' beliefs that its something that goes away if you don't think about it) - this time by lying instead of fraudy research being cited, lying that it was accurate and was a reference as if it hadn't been reanalysed with the correct data. And so on.
Decades they had to do what every other condition expects which is proper medical care which collects basic prognosis information and doesn't make going near a GP so risky patients can't go for any other health concerns and certainly don't mention their condition, and GPs aren't told false ideas that it just disappears after a few years so for it to disappear from records.
They are supposed to be honest and have integrity with the information they provide to patients, and indeed to those in the systems paying for and commissioning things and probably taxpayers about whether something is actually harmful and whether it helps too. But mainly for planning purposes, which I thought was one of the main things CCGs back in the day were about - to work on accurate information and data about how many patients had x and how long it was likely to last etc.
That data has all been debunked since 2021 so there is no excuse - like pretending its OK cos its hope when they mislead people into not being able to plan their lives or how to manage their health better - particularly not 'hope' given the nasty labels that they insisted on dousing patients with suggesting it was 'false beliefs' and still do. Even sometimes it seems mental health related powers being weaponised potentially under that untruth.
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.