Why are they testing another anti-cd20 mab (ublituximab) when rituximab didn’t work? @Jonathan Edwards does this make any sense?
A 1000 word article by Martin Rücker on the decision of the german government to invest 500 million euros in the next decade to research post-infectious diseases:
Yes, germany’s neurology association is spouting unfounded BPS stuff:Is there a risk of BPS ideology shaping this new project? I’m not aware of how the situation with BPS is in Germany.
Expert Assessments on ME/CFS Rehabilitation
1. Volker Köllner
Position
- Head of the Research Group for Psychosomatic Rehabilitation at Charité Berlin
- Medical Director of the Rehabilitation Center Seehof in Teltow
Summary of...
They are for sure going to grab and waste a big part of this budget. The only viable goal is to keep this as low as possible, and given the history, even 50% actually spent on useful research would be a big win. Zero chance it can be fully utilized, unfortunately. Germany has a very strong psychosomatic tradition.Is there a risk of BPS ideology shaping this new project? I’m not aware of how the situation with BPS is in Germany.
DecodeME was unique in that everyone on board knew this was important, so this is unlikely to be replicated at such a large scale. But there might be a way to at least have one such group, even if it means essentially two groups being split apart between the real science and the pseudoscience folks. It would probably even be good if it were explicitly so.Any chance the German patient organisations can push for something similar to the DecodeME PPI steering group (with adherents of the psychosomatic faith excluded from membership, ditto ideally those who believe any one of the many hypotheses is fact and the one and only truth)?
Given Germany's current medical system and the researchers involved 50% is the best we can hope for. I would say its more realistic that we get maybe 5 million a year into real research and the rest gets wasted and used against us. That seems to be about the ratio in Europe generally and we shouldn't set hopes higher than that. Just handing out money it will go to the people who did all the harm to begin with, they are after all the experts with research experience. Unless the German government wake up to the reality of the situation and set things up properly we really can't hope for more than about 1 good study out of this a year, if that. There is still every chance this literally ends up funding the best funded PACE 2.0 trials you have ever seen.They are for sure going to grab and waste a big part of this budget. The only viable goal is to keep this as low as possible, and given the history, even 50% actually spent on useful research would be a big win. Zero chance it can be fully utilized, unfortunately. Germany has a very strong psychosomatic tradition.
Well then we are in real trouble because that isn't correct at all. Is this yet another initiative where they just make it all about fatigue, the 1980s on replay again and again.Long Covid is described as prolonged severe exhaustion and reduced performance, and there is currently no specific medication available.
That scares me a bit, what is it they will be offering exactly since they admit rightly they have no drugs and need research to work out what to do?The initiative seeks to strengthen networking between doctors and researchers and to establish more clinics providing rapid, local assistance.
Well indeed, but these are serial things, you understand the disease, then you develop medicines to target it and then that enhances patients care.According to Warken, the government plans a parallel approach: pursuing research, bringing new medicines to market, improving understanding of the illness, and enhancing patient care. She emphasized the need for basic research to develop effective treatments.
There is little point asking medicine what to do, they don't believe the disease even exists. Ask the people who understand the disease what the heck needs to be done! How do you bring medicines quickly to patients if you don't yet understand the disease?!The minister also announced intensified exchange with the medical community and researchers to identify where concrete improvements in diagnosis and care are needed. Regarding the absence of approved medications so far, Warken explained that the disease first needs to be understood, but the moment has now come to bring medicines quickly to patients.
[/SPOILER]
Good points.Well then we are in real trouble
How are outpatient clinics in Germany? Could this lead to some BACME type stuff?more outpatient clinics are to be established so that “help can be provided quickly and close to home,” Warken said.

Here’s the translation of the well written email template from this reddit post:Reddit thread that includes a post by Kleinshnitz, a German Michael Sharpe analogue, saying something about trying to derail this, though not sure of the specifics as it isn't translated. Includes steps to take and a suggestion to write to the government, with a sample text.
Help saved the german funding to not be seen as a waste by society
It's awful to have someone this arrogant and unpleasant to present the wrong side of this story, but in a way this is preferable to someone with good political instincts. Whenever someone like this is a goto spokesperson, you are 100% on the wrong side of history, and he's more likely to turn people away from the old tropes by simply being so damn unpleasant.ProSieben and SAT1 are big and popular TV channels. I guess they are comparable to ITV.
Indeed, there’s even a full length satire show episode on ME/CFS that showcases this guy’s worst Xcretions (he tried to delete some of his posts but pwME have been collecting snapshots systematically over time):It's awful to have someone this arrogant and unpleasant to present the wrong side of this story, but in a way this is preferable to someone with good political instincts.