Growth hormone response in ME/CFS

forestglip

Administrator
Staff member
This is a bit of a spin-off of the thread for abnormal prolactin response in ME/CFS, to take a look at the studies relating to growth hormone response.

Here are the studies that I've found so far that have tested how much growth hormone changes after participants got some sort of neuroendocrine challenge, such as buspirone or insulin. I only included the growth hormone findings. At least two of the studies (Allain 1997 and Berwaerts 1998) say they found lower IGF-1 , so that may be worth looking at.

YearTitleAuthorsCohortNeuroendocrine probeFindingsLinks
1995Neuroendocrine responses to d-fenfluramine and insulin-induced hypoglycemia in chronic fatigue syndromeJenny Bearn, Theresa Allain, Patsy Coskeran, Neil Munro, Joan Butler, Alan McGregor, Simon Wessely4 females and 5 males with ME/CFS (Sharpe 1991) and without depression.

8 healthy controls

Females tested in days 3-5 of menstrual cycle.
Insulin (0.15 u or 0.10 u per kg, i.v.)Nonsignificantly smaller GH response to insulin.Article
1996Neuroendocrine Alterations in Chronic Fatigue Syndrome [Thesis]Tahir MajeedNondepressed ME/CFS (Fukuda 1994) - Males and females.

Healthy controls.

Sample size differed per test.
Dexamethasone (4 mg, orally)

Desipramine (75 mg, orally)

Pyridostigmine (120 mg, orally)

Bromocriptine (2 mg, orally)

Baclofen (20 mg, orally)
Smaller GH response to dexamethasone.

Smaller GH response to desipramine.

Larger GH response to pyridostigmine.

Normal GH response to bromocriptine.

Normal GH response to baclofen.
Article
1996Chronic Fatigue Syndrome as a Delayed Reaction to Chronic Low-dose Organophosphate ExposurePeter O. Behan10 males with CFS-like illness following flu-like illness (except for one patient where it followed cholecystitis). All had also had documented exposure to organophosphates before illness.1

15 male and 15 female healthy controls (based on news story about study. This differs from text.)
Pyridostigmine (120 mg, orally)

Dexamethasone (4 mg, orally)
Larger GH response to pyridostigmine.

Smaller GH response to dexamethasone.
Article
1996Increased prolactin response to buspirone in chronic fatigue syndromeM. Sharpe, A. Clements, K. Hawton, A.H. Young, P. Sargent, P.J. Cowen11 male with ME/CFS (Sharpe 1991) and neurasthenia (WHO 1992) but not major depression, generalized anxiety disorder, or panic disorder.

11 age-, sex-, and weight-matched healthy controls.
Buspirone (0.5 mg/kg up to a maximum of 45 mg, orally)Normal GH response to buspirone.Article
1997Changes in growth hormone, insulin, insulinlike growth factors (IGFs), and IGF-binding protein-1 in chronic fatigue syndromeTeresa J. Allain, Jenny A. Beam, Patsy Coskeran, Jennifer Jones, Anna Checkley,
Joan Butler, Simon Wessely, and John P. Miell
5 males and 3 females with ME/CFS (Sharpe 1991 and Fukuda 1994), without current depression

3 male and 6 female healthy controls

Females tested during follicular phase.

Controls significantly younger.
Insulin (0.15 U/kg, i.v.)Normal baseline GH.

Smaller GH increase after insulin.
Article
1998Secretion of growth hormone in patients with chronic fatigue syndromeJ. Berwaerts, G. Moorkens, R. Abs7 males and 13 females with ME/CFS (Fukuda 1994) without current depression.

Number of controls differed per test.
Insulin (0.15 U/kg, i.v.)

L-arginine (30 g, i.v.)
Normal GH response to insulin.

Normal GH response to L-arginine.

Nonsignificantly reduced nocturnal secretion of GH.
Article
2000Integrity of the Growth Hormone/Insulin-Like Growth Factor System Is Maintained in Patients with Chronic Fatigue SyndromeAnthony J. Cleare, Samantha S. Sookdeo, Jennifer Jones,
Veronica O’Keane, John P. Miell
37 ME/CFS (Sharpe 1991 and Fukuda 1994)

37 healthy controls
Insulin (0.15 U/kg, i.v.)

GHRH (100 ug, i.v.)
Normal GH response to insulin.

Normal GH response to GHRH.
Article
2000Characterization of pituitary function with emphasis on GH secretion in the chronic fatigue syndromeGreta Moorkens, Joris Berwaerts,
Herlindis Wynants, Roger Abs
73 ME/CFS (Fukuda 1994)

21 healthy controls

Early follicular phase for females.
Insulin (0.15 U/kg, i.v.)Smaller GH increase after insulin.

Reduced GH nocturnal secretion.
Article
2001Hormonal Responses to Exercise in Chronic Fatigue SyndromeJohn E. Ottenweller, Sue A. Sisto, Richard C. McCarty, Benjamin H. Natelson17 females with ME/CFS (Oxford and Fukuda criteria)

14 sedentary healthy controls.
Maximal exercise on treadmillLarger GH response to exercise (only achieved significance when analyzing subset who achieved maximal exertion)Article, S4ME
GH: Growth hormone, GHRH: Growth hormone-releasing hormone

Edit: Fixed minor typos.
 
Last edited:
To summarize:

Insulin
2 studies with significantly smaller GH response

1 study where the response was smaller but not quite significant

2 studies where the GH response was normal.

Dexamethasone
2 studies with smaller GH response

Desipramine
1 study with smaller GH response

Pyridostigmine
2 studies with larger GH response

Bromocriptine
1 study with normal GH response

Baclofen
1 study with normal GH response

Buspirone
1 study with normal GH response

L-Arginine
1 study with normal GH response

GHRH
1 study with normal response

Exercise
1 study with larger GH response

(For the 2 studies on dexamethasone and pyridostigmine, the same individual, Behan, was a thesis supervisor for one and an author for the other.)

----

To summarize more: maybe there's something here, but it's not consistent for insulin, and there are only 1 or 2 studies for each of the other tests.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom