MEdoctors.org — a website which recommends doctors - international coverage

Merged
Today, Twitter user @liamsLCjourney announced the launch of ME Doctors, whose purpose is briefly summarized on its homepage:
ME Doctors is the most comprehensive source of recommended doctors for ME, counting 655 doctors and clinics in 20 countries.
Liam elaborates on the rationale behind this project in his Twitter post:
Many people with ME bounce around between dismissive medical appointments for years before a word-of-mouth reference or a one-off review in a patient community finally leads them to a doctor who truly gets it. That's not acceptable. We believe everyone deserves access to information about competent doctors, no matter if they're newly suspecting an ME diagnosis or have been disbelieved for years. ME Doctors shows patients only information that actually matters: how helpful each doctor is, what they tend to prescribe, whether they offer telemedicine, their cost per visit, and how long their waitlist is.
To be blunt: I am worried this website will cause some people serious harm. Given Liam’s extensive use of AI in previous long covid and ME/CFS-related projects, it seems safe to assume it was deployed here to scrape the internet for discussion of doctors who treat ME/CFS. How much vetting do we think was done of the 655 doctors the site recommends?

For an example of why I’m worried, the site lists two doctors local to me who work at the same alternative medicine clinic. This clinic currently employs the “Lyme-literate” quack who victimized me as a child and charged my mother a fortune for the privilege. The site describes these two naturopathic doctors as “compassionate and knowledgeable” and “thorough and brilliant” respectively.

A Twitter user pointed out to Liam that the site currently recommends doctors and a hospital in their home country who they know to be incompetent. His response:
Please submit anonymous feedback via the edit button so other patients can know!
In the meantime, let’s hope no one gets hurt too badly.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
In theory, I think a database of doctors could be helpful for a disease like ME/CFS where so many doctors know nothing about the illness, or worse, are dismissive and recommend harmful treatments.

While there are no proven treatments, patients still need to find someone to provide an accurate diagnosis, validate the illness, document their disability for insurance purposes, etc.

That being said, the way this information seems to have been compiled without scrutiny is quite concerning.

In addition to what @jonathan_h points out, I notice that Dr. Jose Montoya is recommended though he got fired from his previous post at Stanford, which raises some flags. And a lot of the comments listed under the doctors seem like they got lifted directly from their sources (which are???) without any editing even. For example, this:

“Dr […] has to be nudged to try new medications and often starts doses too high”

What??
 
Back in the 1990s the UK MEA used to have a list of doctors with a special interest in ME. My only interaction with it was to contact a private neurologist who provided a report for my ill health retirement request, which was very helpful.

However, I agree with others above that any such list is potentially very problematic. Even if carefully monitored, how do you decide who to include and who to exclude?
 
Back in the 1990s the UK MEA used to have a list of doctors with a special interest in ME. My only interaction with it was to contact a private neurologist who provided a report for my ill health retirement request, which was very helpful.

Yes, I remember that. Many of them were NHS GPs who didn't automatically view ME/CFS as a psychogenic illness. I recommended one of mine, who never tried to suggest I was depressed and thought the local ME clinic's use of dance therapy inappropriate.

But a list of doctors who don't present a risk to people with ME/CFS is very different to a list of so-called experts, some of whom probably charge money for handing out untested treatments.
 
Back
Top Bottom