Jonathan Edwards
Senior Member (Voting Rights)
But there is evidence that skeletal muscle is involved in ME/CFS and in the response to exertion
Nothing substantive that I am aware of.
signs of abnormal muscle sodium handling, impaired recovery after repeated exercise and metabolic abnormalities during PEM.
The sodium observation is very odd and I suspect reflected change in compartment size rather than any membrane abnormality. I am not aware of evidence relating to 'impaired recovery'? The metabolic differences after PEM from Hanson were mostly of less change than normals I thought. None of this seems to me to tell us much. people have been obsessed with there being a muscle problem since the 1980s but the evidence has been pretty pervasively negative and it does not make a lot of clincial sense.
Not if we cannot find any muscle pathology. Competent professional pathologists looked in the 1980s (one of them is someone I know very well, I worked on the same corridor). Some recent studies have suggested pathology but they are hard to square with what we know from previous work.The question is whether muscle pathology is a cause, consequence, or part of a wider systemic feedback loop.