Relationship btwn CFS, burnout, job satisfaction, social support & age among academics at a tertiary institution (2019) Coetzee et al

JohnTheJack

Moderator
Staff member
Available here:
http://ijomeh.eu/The-relationship-b...urnout-job-satisfaction-social,91021,0,2.html

Not a recommendation. I have only read the Abstract:

Objectives:
Over the last 20 years, tertiary institutions have been subjected to several changes. This has resulted in increased workloads for academics. Some academics have started to experience symptoms that are related to chronic fatigue syndrome and burnout. Researchers, however, cannot agree whether the 2 syndromes are two sides of the same coin or actually 2 separate constructs. This study that was conducted at a tertiary institution in South Africa therefore aimed to determine if these constructs accounted for the evidence of the same syndrome within an academic setting or if they were 2 separate, distinguishable constructs. However, since job satisfaction and social support play a role in the poor physical and psychological health experienced by individuals with chronic fatigue syndrome or burnout, it was decided to also include these 2 constructs into the investigation. Age was also incorporated because it had dissimilar relationships with burnout and chronic fatigue syndrome.

Material and Methods:
The participants completed the following questionnaires via an online survey: The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Chronic Fatigue Syndrome Symptom Inventory, the Oldenburg Burnout Inventory, the Overall Job Satisfaction Scale and the Social Support Scale. The data was used for constructing a structural equation model.

Results:
Job satisfaction was found to be a strong predictor of burnout. The number of symptoms indicative of chronic fatigue syndrome reported by the participants proved to be a relatively strong significant predictor of burnout. Age did not yield any significant relationship with any of the constructs.

Conclusions:
The results indicated that chronic fatigue and burnout should be perceived as 2 distinguishable constructs in the academic context. It should be noted, however, that some overlap exists between them.

What I find interesting there is that there is no correlation between CFS and anything.

Also it appears that some symptoms of CFS predict burnout, but that is data-trawling and shows importance of using proper criteria for diagnosing ME.
 
Last edited:
From the introduction:

Although Hyland has suggested that chronic fatigue syndrome develops because of immunological challenges and lifestyle pressures associated with being an academic, some researchers still confuse it with burnout [3]. Leoneet al.’s [7] findings contribute to this confusion becausethey have pointed out that chronic fatigue syndrome has at least 3 characteristics in common with burnout. These are:

– at the heart of both syndromes lies the issue of serious exhaustion or fatigue;
– people who suffer from these syndromes often share the same personality traits (active, hardworking, pas- sionate and dedicated);
– both syndromes are related to work overload.

Burnout also mimics chronic fatigue syndrome in that it is associated with poor health issues such as headaches, fa- tigue, sleep disturbances and exhaustion [11,12]. Another common factor between academics suffering from chronic fatigue syndrome and burnout is that they struggle to be productive in creative ways [3,13].
As a result of these contradictory findings, it is necessary to determine whether chronic fatigue and burnout experienced by academics are the same syndrome or if they are 2 separate, distinguishable constructs.
 
If you offer a questionnaire to 69 persons who work at an academic institution, none of them probably has CFS. The term should not have been used in this study. This is basically a study of fatigue and burn-out like symptoms in the workforce.

The references for previously claimed similarities between burnout and CFS are revealing: a study of chronic fatigue and an unpublished dissertation by the senior author...
 
The number of symptoms indicative of chronic fatigue syndrome reported by the participants proved to be a relatively strong significant predictor of burnout.

This doesn't prove that the conditions are similar, it proves that the questionnaire lacks specificity. Which is something that patients frequently mention when filling out such questionnaires (and often ignored by researchers).
 
This doesn't prove that the conditions are similar, it proves that the questionnaire lacks specificity.
Yes. I don't think the CDC symptom inventory (Found here: https://www.cdc.gov/me-cfs/pdfs/symptom-inventory-questionnaire-508.pdf) has much to do with ME/CFS as it is currently defined.

It asks about all types of symptoms like fever, diarrhea, chills, sleeping problems nausea, sinus or nasal problems etc. Even what the paper describes as core symptoms aren't very specific: joint pain, headache, muscle pain, and tender lymph nodes are not seen as characteristic of ME/CFS. And instead of PEM, it asks about "fatigue after exertion." Anyone with health problems might say they have more fatigue after exertion...
 
This study that was conducted at a tertiary institution in South Africa

CORRESPONDING AUTHOR:
Nicoleen Coetzee
University of Pretoria, Department of Psychology, Lynnwood Road, Pretoria, 0002, South Africa

Doesn't get much lazier than this. Nicoleen Coetzee, trying to think up an idea for a new paper, has a brilliant idea - "I know, I'll ask my colleagues to fill in a questionnaire or two, that way I won't even have to leave the building! If 5% of them respond, I can write something up and publish it!"
 
Strange, I didn't really get a notification it was published, so you knew it before me.

I would like to thank @Andy and @Trish for helping me with proofreading and finetuning the letter. Very helpful and very much appreciated.

I'm glad that the authors (Coetzee et al.) turn out to be good sports and that they "appreciate the critical comments" and that these will "surely be taken into account in future research."
 
Back
Top Bottom