ScoutB
Senior Member (Voting Rights)
This table is based off the Cortisol levels in ME/CFS thread.
I have been picking away at this over the past couple days (I am skimming each paper as well as Hutan's great notes, so going is slow). I figured it would be good to share the tiny bit I've done so far in case anyone has important feedback before I get too deep.
I am desperately trying to keep each row compact, so you can quickly scroll through and get a sense of the overall trend of the results. Probably if/when I add more studies I'll want to order them by relevance or maybe put a second table below the first for studies that don't technically check cortisol (e.g. Scott, 1999).
This is basically a rough draft (some notes on what I'm planning to change/do below). Feedback welcome, the only caveat being I probably don't want to add too much info to each line.
My to do list with this at the moment:
I have been picking away at this over the past couple days (I am skimming each paper as well as Hutan's great notes, so going is slow). I figured it would be good to share the tiny bit I've done so far in case anyone has important feedback before I get too deep.
I am desperately trying to keep each row compact, so you can quickly scroll through and get a sense of the overall trend of the results. Probably if/when I add more studies I'll want to order them by relevance or maybe put a second table below the first for studies that don't technically check cortisol (e.g. Scott, 1999).
This is basically a rough draft (some notes on what I'm planning to change/do below). Feedback welcome, the only caveat being I probably don't want to add too much info to each line.
| Author, Year | Findings related to Cortisol level | Participants | Notes |
| Korszun, 1999 | No difference between patients and controls in the secretory pattern of cortisol in blood over 24 hours. | All women. FM (n = 9), CFS (n = 8), age and menstrual cycle phase matched controls. | Tracked blood cortisol levels every 10 minutes over a 24 hour period. |
| Scott, 1999 | Patients selected on the basis of having a subnormal response to an ACTH test, had (50%) smaller adrenal glands than controls as measured by a CT scan. | 8 patients (Fukuda CDC criteria), 55 heathy controls. | The authors put it well: “by selecting subjects with abnormally low cortisol responses, is one simply selecting a group with the smallest adrenal glands?” |
| Roberts, 2008 | Cortisol levels in CFS patients appear to be within normal reference ranges, both before and after CBT. | 41 patients (Fukuda CDC criteria). No controls. | Authors do not comment on the cortisol levels found, but they appear to be within the normal range, e.g. morning cortisol averaged ~11 nmol/L. |
| Roerink, 2018 | No reduction in hair cortisol, nor total saliva cortisol output during the day. CFS patients showed a decreased cortisol awakening response. | 107 CFS patients (Fukuda CDC criteria), 59 controls. | The awakening response is a rise in cortisol after awakening that occurs in some people and is reduced by naps, a schedule of waking later, pain and fatigue. |
| And so many more! |
My to do list with this at the moment:
- Finish going through Hutan's thead.
- A new literature search, to double check we have everything.
- Standardize terms and define shorthand (e.g. FM = Fibromyalgia).
- Perhaps include a blurb on what we know about normal cortisol levels, e.g. reference ranges, issues like wake up time confounding results.