Review The active inference framework and social cognitive theory: Informing therapeutic approaches for medically unexplained symptoms 2026 Roughead

Andy

Senior Member (Voting rights)

Highlights​

  • Comparing the active inference framework & social cognitive theory to explain learning
  • Showing the place of learning in medically unexplained symptoms
  • The active inference framework and social cognitive theory as a theory for recovery
  • The therapeutic domains model of recovery for medically unexplained symptoms

Abstract​

Persistent physical symptoms for which no medical explanation can be found affects hundreds of millions of people globally. The active inference framework from cognitive neuroscience, which describes the brain’s capacity for adaptive learning, is now providing the explanatory power and evidence to understand the phenomenon of medically unexplained symptoms. The active inference framework calls for a reconsideration of the evidence approach for people with persistent physical symptoms. In this paper, I provide an overview of the active inference framework. I show how combining the active inference framework with learning theories from behavioural psychology, in particular, social cognitive theory, can inform an approach to recovery. I develop a “therapeutic domains approach” embedded within the social cognitive theoretical model of learning and the active inference framework to guide the selection of evidence-based strategies to support recovery. The approach allows for all the sensory inputs that can contribute to the formation of medically unexplained symptoms to be targeted, and would enable patient centred, tailored, multi-strategic therapeutic plans to be developed and adopted. I demonstrate how the therapeutic domains approach is consistent with, but builds on the biopsychosocial model, by articulating and integrating the behavioural underpinnings and explanatory power for how and why a multi-strategic, therapeutic domains based approach would provide a roadmap for recovery for people with medically unexplained symptoms.

Open access
 
Aside from the fact that this is the same old nonsense, that it obviously stems from the conclusion and works its way backwards, it's just terrible reasoning:
The model, however, fails to provide explanatory power for people who experience medically unexplained symptoms (Lowe et al., 2024), because objective markers of pathology are not found on investigation in these individuals.
There are many diseases for which a biomarker or pathology is known but it doesn't provide any explanation, or so little that it makes no difference. All it does is act as a validation process so that the illness goes from unexplained to believed, which is not the same dimension. In fact the explanation is largely irrelevant if the belief is there. And there are many diseases that are believed and lack a biomarker, but have other factors that break the disbelief.

As usual, this is just a misrepresentation of medical science, aka "the biomedical model". It's incomplete, they all know this, and this is all pretend because they work from the conclusion out.
While in rare instances, unexplained symptoms may be related to a rare or unrecognised pathology that is eventually identified
Not rare, in fact it even commonly happens with common diseases. It's widely known that some diseases take years to be diagnosed, so even with recognized diseases the premise is false. It happens a lot. Delayed diagnosis is misdiagnosis. This defines the history of medicine, where every illness is fake until they bless it with their superior knowledge, or whatever.
Historically, medically unexplained symptoms have been viewed as “all in the mind” or psychosomatic, however, findings from cognitive neuroscience are providing the theory and evidence to understand the phenomenon of medically unexplained symptoms. It shows that medically unexplained symptoms are neurally encoded in the same way that medically explainable symptoms are encoded.

In the cognitive neuroscience framework, symptoms arise as a result of the brain’s active inferential learning process that integrates sensory cues from the body and external world with past experience.
Pure speculative assertion. None of this is fact. It's embarrassing that nonsense like this keeps getting published.

They don't actually name the comparison, but this is the same thing as the predictive coding nonsense that is fashionable lately. The paper vaguely refers to an old paper that mentions predictive factors and rules. Same act, different clown.
 
Back
Top Bottom