UK: Beth Dobbin -- BBC: The Olympic sprinter now bedbound for 22 hours a day

I don't think it's the vagus nerve stimulation feasibility trial led by Physios4ME and Liverpool University as the trial was funded by the Chartered Society of Physiotherapy Charitable Trust Physiotherapy Research Foundation Award, nothing to do with the DHSC or MRC.
Yeah only a feasibility study, about to be released but it’s being posted on Long Covid Advocacy socials as the one they “suspect” not great
 
BBC follow-up article had a response from Govt spokesperson:




My bold.

"and a clinical trial trial for new treatments."

Are they referring to this, do you think?

Is he even aware that there isn't just 'no medical care for severe ME/CFS' but that those with severe ME/CFS have no access to the health service in its entireity often. It is harmful and unsafe to go near it. To an extreme extent that is hard to imagine (even tho some close their eyes to it and pretend somehow these are all 'unusual cases')

Not just 'I know everyone ends up stuck waiting in a corridor for too long', or no curative treatment, but being faced with coercion (to get false figures) and the opposite of basic medical care as they are shunted into an altnerative health service that doesn't do 'health' for everythning. That people go into hospital and instead of given medical care to get them home are expensively toyed with for sometimes years in ways that cause harm and they are warned about will harm. And not for good intentions.

That clinics have filled themselves with clinicians who can/will only say they are 'for the public good' (and their own interpretation of that at that) not the hippocratic oath or do no harm that makes them medical and not technicians of what they purvey.

And so if severe ME/CFS has been specified and teh response is 'a clinical trial' that is unspeficied and sadly we have the usual coercive techniques from the same parasites from the same ideology wanting to pretend they can't read as legal cover for trying the same harmful things as if 'these people need to prove it doesn't work by being harmed again, then maybe one day'

I'm not sure they even realise there is no safe clinic any severe or very severe can be part of - as you would expect for any clinic or service for serious illness just happens to exist already somewhere. That it took some effort to ensure it was that way. That this is not by any means the normal state of play you begin from with any other condition.

As far as I'm aware the very concept that would make it 'medical' - the hippocratic oath, informed consent and therefore focusing on 'do no harm' and any treatment or trial focusing primarily on yellow-card and long-term does it make people worse - has been removed for anything bps or rehab, I guess people keep their licenses by being in professions not requiring this and pretending delusions of belief make it OK to be wilfully blind.
 
ThereForME

This is a guide for those who would like to write to their MP to request that they support Olympian Beth Dobbin’s call for greater funding for ME research.
 
I for a number of years had anxiety or even a sense of doom, for no obvious reason, as part of a sort of aura preceding PEM.
Same. Not every time I’m in PEM but there’s a definite element often associated, so much that I just go ‘oh it’s this’ and ride it out.

I made a thread with some papers and possible mechanisms here

 

Has this come from Beth /her team liaised with this? Or is she wanting them to ‘take over from here’ etc ?

From watching the coverage unfold this week it seemed like she had a sensible planned set of communications and it’s not clear if this is part directly of that or ‘inspired by’

I would like to know the context

I can see that the final box of what can MPs do does have ‘fully funding sequenceME’ in it and I haven’t dived into the other bits
 
Has this come from Beth /her team liaised with this? Or is she wanting them to ‘take over from here’ etc ?

From watching the coverage unfold this week it seemed like she had a sensible planned set of communications and it’s not clear if this is part directly of that or ‘inspired by’

I would like to know the context

I can see that the final box of what can MPs do does have ‘fully funding sequenceME’ in it and I haven’t dived into the other bits
I might well be wrong but I don't think much of this was planned in advance. I'm not sure she was prepared for the impact her interview had and then went with the momentum with the letter to Andy Burnham and then charities got involved.

I think if it was planned her interview would have addressed Andy directly and there would have been consistent call to action. It went from general asks to much more specific. Which is good! But ideally it would have been in the interview which had the most impact & reach.

But the interview also did the job brilliantly of being very well informed and gave a much better account of ME than most with platforms do. And all when seriously struggling which has to be commended.
 
What I find interesting is the record we have of someone already ill having times when muscle function is so normal she could run a competitive race at international level. And other times not.
This is a late reply but US soccer (football) player Michelle Akers reported a similar experience.

This Washington Post article from 1999 is behind a paywall but I managed to screenshot the first paragraph

Quote from Wikipedia: "Throughout most of her career, Akers was afflicted by chronic fatigue syndrome, repeatedly considering retirement only to continue playing in some of U.S. Soccer's most significant matches."

I'm actually not a big sports fan but I remember the US women's team winning the world cup in 1999. Another reason I remember her is because she retired in 2000 which was the same year I has to stop working and go on long term disability.
 
I have not read the WP article and I am not doubting the validity of Akers’s lived experience but I find it hard to believe that someone who is able to continue to play international football could have the same illness as me and many other people who are diagnosed with ME/CFS. Football requires extremely high levels of fitness. Players can run up to 12km per match, which can include 50-70 sprints, as well as walking and jogging.

It seems plausible that someone with a different chronic illness could continue to play elite football, but I can’t understand how an international footballer could have ME/CFS with PEM for most of their career. According to Wikipedia, Akers played at international level from 1985–2000 and was named FIFA female player of the century.

I am not being critical of Akers in any way, and I apologise if I am misunderstanding by having not read the WP article. However, assuming that the Wikipedia article is accurate, I can only infer that her symptoms did not include post-exertion malaise in the sense that I understand it.
 
Michele Akers 'struggled with CFS since 1991'. I don't believe anyone would be able to continue training, playing at an international level, and just living life if they experienced delayed PEM.

It's just not possible imo
 
It is difficult talking about individuals’ diagnosis just based on media reports, all part of the fact that anecdotes don’t make for good medicine.

Rather than questioning someone’s diagnosis surely it is better to say the reported symptoms are atypical in relation to current understandings of ME/CFS.
 
"A non-travelling reserve for the 1968 Mexico Olympics, Derek Graham then went to the 1970 Commonwealth Games at Edinburgh. A virus was going around at the Games and against doctor´s advice raced in the 5,000 final, but was so unwell afterwards that he developed chronic fatigue. It later turned into Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (M.E.) and Graham subsequently developed heart problems, and in 1999 was fitted with a pacemaker. Although his athletics career effectively ended at Edinburgh in 1970, Graham made a comeback in 1981 and enjoyed a career as a veteran runner."

So there's that too.

I always say give it 5 years b/c people do recover from PVFS.
 
Is he even aware that there isn't just 'no medical care for severe ME/CFS' but that those with severe ME/CFS have no access to the health service in its entireity often. It is harmful and unsafe to go near it. To an extreme extent that is hard to imagine (even tho some close their eyes to it and pretend somehow these are all 'unusual cases')

Not just 'I know everyone ends up stuck waiting in a corridor for too long', or no curative treatment, but being faced with coercion (to get false figures) and the opposite of basic medical care as they are shunted into an altnerative health service that doesn't do 'health' for everythning. That people go into hospital and instead of given medical care to get them home are expensively toyed with for sometimes years in ways that cause harm and they are warned about will harm. And not for good intentions.

That clinics have filled themselves with clinicians who can/will only say they are 'for the public good' (and their own interpretation of that at that) not the hippocratic oath or do no harm that makes them medical and not technicians of what they purvey.

And so if severe ME/CFS has been specified and teh response is 'a clinical trial' that is unspeficied and sadly we have the usual coercive techniques from the same parasites from the same ideology wanting to pretend they can't read as legal cover for trying the same harmful things as if 'these people need to prove it doesn't work by being harmed again, then maybe one day'

I'm not sure they even realise there is no safe clinic any severe or very severe can be part of - as you would expect for any clinic or service for serious illness just happens to exist already somewhere. That it took some effort to ensure it was that way. That this is not by any means the normal state of play you begin from with any other condition.

As far as I'm aware the very concept that would make it 'medical' - the hippocratic oath, informed consent and therefore focusing on 'do no harm' and any treatment or trial focusing primarily on yellow-card and long-term does it make people worse - has been removed for anything bps or rehab, I guess people keep their licenses by being in professions not requiring this and pretending delusions of belief make it OK to be wilfully blind.
Yeah I would like people to realise how were excluded from most medical care, just by virtue of “well, the recommendation/advice for (regular ailments like surgery recovery, appendicitis whatever) is an operation with hospital stay in a general ward then you need to get up and about and get discharged) ok but I can’t stand up and I need to be in silence and darkness to rest properly.
 
It is difficult talking about individuals’ diagnosis just based on media reports, all part of the fact that anecdotes don’t make for good medicine.

Rather than questioning someone’s diagnosis surely it is better to say the reported symptoms are atypical in relation to current understandings of ME/CFS.
I agree with the first bit. But I don’t know what any of her symptoms are or were. All I know is that Wikipedia currently states that she had CFS for most the years that she was playing international football. It may be that the article is inaccurate and/or that she was diagnosed using criteria for CFS which doesn’t require PEM.

However, I think it is legitimate to question whether, in general, anyone who is capable of performing at the highest level of football for many years could meet any useful definition of PEM. To me such prolonged fitness would not be atypical but inconsistent with a diagnosis of ME/CFS which requires PEM.
 
Back
Top Bottom