UK: Beth Dobbin -- BBC: The Olympic sprinter now bedbound for 22 hours a day

I would say that IIRC the history of the act includes the addition of HIV and MS to the history of them being discriminated against, hence their being specified and the very valid reason for asking for ME to be included.

Ok I just checked and I keep getting AI summaries, I think HIV was because of stigma and MS is included so that someone is covered “before” the substantive impacts on day to day activities happens, because we know MS is progressive and at the point of diagnosis you may not be affected much. There was a case where a person with a diagnosis was discriminated against due to diagnosis, but didn’t (yet) meet the test of substantial effect on day to day activities, so they amended to law!

This is very relevant to ME actually, if you think of milder people still working.
Yes and important because of the sad but true situation of employers finding out someone has x that they won’t recover from (and may mean employer has to be understanding in future or give adjustments and even it ends in early retirement- which might link to increased costs from their insurers having someone with x in their books? I don’t know does anyone know how that works) and ‘manages them out’ whilst they think they can still get away with it. Which I think is extraordinarily common.

Then you’ve businesses and individuals who see it as ‘will end uk being costly to them’ etc

And just basic discrimination and bullying that we get - and I think a lot of bps rhetoric is actually bigotry and harmful and it can be so many times a day not just in words but in getting treated badly with work and things that make life harder vs colleagues.

Double whammy if both not getting the career advancement opportunities because of that disability bigotry most still have if assuming cos someone’s in a wheelchair they aren’t ambitious even tho they are working harder than the ‘young grads’ they say are. But also not even seeing our work because once many hear you are disabled then if the team drops the ball then you get used behind your back as their excuse even tho you might have been the one star performer etc

Add in all the slightly less understood aspects of how ME plays out and affects people and I agree they need incredibly strong protections due to bigotry that is very active and incited (and then all those inciting and doing deny it and claim it was ‘trying to help’ or ‘just accident’ etc but they always seem to know exactly what buttons to push in his to make us iller so..)
 
Last edited:
What do you think is reasonable to expect as treatment? What possible options are there? There don't seem to be any to my mind and if research found anything 'biomedical' tomorrow, you are a least 17-20 years away from them being offered on the NHS and that's if something straightforward was found.
What’s your basis for this estimate? That seems unrealistically pessimistic.
I can't understand the optimism around Sequence ME that means it could lead to different treatment pathways, as much as I know some of you want that funded.
You’re seemingly not aware that drug trials guided by genetic targets have a substantially higher success rate.
I admire Beth's efforts, but if I have you £100 million tomorrow, I don't believe it would change anything practical in terms of symptom relief.
If you hang around here a bit I think you’d be able to spot at least a dozen studies that should be done today as a matter of priority. I don’t think anyone are expecting instant changes from day one of the funding, that seems like a strawman.

What might change quickly, though, is the recognition of ME/CFS as a proper disease and the removal of it from the stranglehold of the charlatans and abusers that are currently trying to starve the most severely affected to death and blame suicides on the patient’s lack of belief in BPS explanations.
 
What’s your basis for this estimate? That seems unrealistically pessimistic.
Remember this is coming from the person who believes that there won't be solid proof that brain training works for another 15-20 years. So they think that in order to prove a treatment works you have to conduct poorly designed unblinded trials over and over and over again for fifty years until you magically get a convincing result.

Again, here we have pessimism about biological researchs chance of uncovering mechanisms and treatments being used as a reason why it's better not to fund biomedical research and to instead focus on brain retraining and the like. Which is precicely what we saw from BPS clinicians after DecodeME. And I'm sure it's what those same clinicans are telling anyone in government or in research funding who will listen.

These are the people who go on about how they are bringing hope...
 
As an anti-recovery activist* (*as certain brain-train straw man enthusiasts call us) or, as I prefer, someone interested in the biomedical solution for ME and disinterested in other arguments, I just use the ignore button.

My energy and patience are limited so that’s my boundary.
 
What’s your basis for this estimate? That seems unrealistically pessimistic.
If you look anywhere, that's the realistic time frame. You're potentially looking at trials establishing efficacy, safety, having larger efficacy trials, showing cost-effectiveness (no point rolling out a treatment that is very expensive and 'only' helps 10% of patients if you're an NHS commissioner), you're thinking of licensing and regulation conversations, NICE assessments, any additional work if there are dangerous side effects for some. I think if there was a drug that is already out there, 5 years seems more realistic. But who knows. You're talking a hypothetical drug, 20 years could well be optimistic. I'm not happy writing that, I think patients are not informed of this process enough. People imagine there would be some drug tomorrow. That isn't reality. It's one of the reasons I turned to brain retraining and decided to try it in detail, because it was the only way I felt I might have some control over my own future. Sit around and wait for 20 more years of hell? No thank you.
Remember this is coming from the person who believes that there won't be solid proof that brain training works for another 15-20 years. So they think that in order to prove a treatment works you have to conduct poorly designed unblinded trials over and over and over again for fifty years until you magically get a convincing result.
It's not about 'solid proof,' it's about building a proper evidence base. Multiple trials, systematic reviews, finessing techniques in response to criticism. It. takes. time.

And money. £2 million for brain retraining to firmly establish itself as mainstream, at a minimum. Probably 10-15 million.
 
It's one of the reasons I turned to brain retraining and decided to try it in detail, because it was the only way I felt I might have some control over my own future
This is exactly my point.

People are told an extremely pessimistic vision of a timescale for a treatment from biomed research (which yours undoubtedly is), and the resulting hopelessness they feel is used to lure people into brain retraining. This is extremely unethical.

Trying to take back control over my future using psychobehavioural methods meant that I am now waiting for a treatment from my bed rather than whilst living a curtailed but still often decent life as a mild person.

But of course I'm sure I said the magic words wrong.
 
It's not about 'solid proof,' it's about building a proper evidence base. Multiple trials, systematic reviews, finessing techniques in response to criticism. It. takes. time.
If you believe in it so much, I think your time would be better served trying to get researchers to run decent trials that are capable of finding a negative result, instead of helping spread propaganda for the researchers who appear to deliberately not be doing that. They're not stupid. It does not take a genius to realize long term tracking of objective metrics is an absolute must in an open label study on a disease like ME/CFS.
 
People are told an extremely pessimistic vision of a timescale for a treatment from biomed research (which yours undoubtedly is), and the resulting hopelessness they feel is used to lure people into brain retraining. This is extremely unethical.
Nobody is doing this. This is not some strategy. This is about realistic timeframes with how the whole global system of research works. Research and treatments within the NHS are extremely slow. I feel (personally) it is more of an ethical concern to not spell this out to patients who believe a treatment might be just around the corner. It isn't. It doesn't mean anyone has to do brain retraining, if they don't want to. It paid off in my case.
 
If you believe in it so much, I think your time would be better served trying to get researchers to run decent trials that are capable of finding a negative result, instead of helping spread propaganda for the researchers who appear to deliberately not be doing that. They're not stupid. It does not take a genius to realize long term tracking of objective metrics is an absolute must in an open label study on a disease like ME/CFS.
That's a fair point. I already try to do this and don't think I'm very successful but I will keep trying.
 
Nobody is doing this. This is not some strategy. This is about realistic timeframes with how the whole global system of research works. Research and treatments within the NHS are extremely slow. I feel (personally) it is more of an ethical concern to not spell this out to patients who believe a treatment might be just around the corner. It isn't. It doesn't mean anyone has to do brain retraining, if they don't want to. It paid off in my case.
I notice that for the second time you have ignored my account of getting much worse from psychobehavioural interventions. Not really surprising but its very telling that you don't think warning people about the countless people who have suffered the fate I've suffered from brain retraining and GET and the like is an ethical concern.

You speak with a lot of confidence for someone who is so categotically wrong on so many counts.
 
If you look anywhere, that's the realistic time frame. You're potentially looking at trials establishing efficacy, safety, having larger efficacy trials, showing cost-effectiveness (no point rolling out a treatment that is very expensive and 'only' helps 10% of patients if you're an NHS commissioner), you're thinking of licensing and regulation conversations, NICE assessments, any additional work if there are dangerous side effects for some. I think if there was a drug that is already out there, 5 years seems more realistic. But who knows. You're talking a hypothetical drug, 20 years could well be optimistic. I'm not happy writing that, I think patients are not informed of this process enough. People imagine there would be some drug tomorrow. That isn't reality. It's one of the reasons I turned to brain retraining and decided to try it in detail, because it was the only way I felt I might have some control over my own future. Sit around and wait for 20 more years of hell? No thank you.
Under normal circumstances getting marketing approval takes about half a year in the UK, and NICE assessments adds another half a year.

You can also get a conditional approval based on non-phase 3 data if the disease «is seriously debilitating and there is currently no satisfactory method of diagnosis, prevention or treatment authorised in the UK, or, if one exists, the medicinal product will offer a major therapeutic advantage to those affected.» This would clearly apply to ME/CFS.

As demonstrated by ResetME, a very thorough phase 2 trial takes about three to four years. Adding more resources could shorten the time by maybe a year. Running the trial as is costs just north of £1M, not including the drug.

Both the Germans and the Americans have demonstrated how quickly trials can be set up if they are prioritised.
It's not about 'solid proof,' it's about building a proper evidence base. Multiple trials, systematic reviews, finessing techniques in response to criticism. It. takes. time.
As I have explained above, this is absolutely not the case. You can get a drug approved for ME/CFS based on a single robust and clearly positive phase two trial.
And money. £2 million for brain retraining to firmly establish itself as mainstream, at a minimum. Probably 10-15 million.
They have already received for more money than that. Wyller’s new trial got more than £2M despite two negative prior trials. As expected, it’s terribly designed. If you have a genuine belief that brain retraining helps this should make you furious because they are wasting time and money.

In case you missed it, here is the thread that was started based on our previous conversation about how to design a good trial of brain retraining. Would you be able to provide your thoughts on the suggestions in a comment on that thread?
 
Back
Top Bottom