Utsikt
Senior Member (Voting Rights)
First of all: the lack of scientific studies means that you can’t claim that their interventions are effective for pwME/CFS in general. I’m no saying you do that (I honestly can’t remember), but they certainly do.I am repeating myself but not currently. No. And that is a problem, but I don't personally believe a brain retraining study would be allowed to go ahead on M.E. as things stand. I said that in an earlier post and someone responded saying they would be ok with that, which is great. But I don't think most people would be ok with thousands to millions being spent on it instead of biomedical research. There would be uproar. The MEA would speak out against it. Patients would say they feel it would do them harm because it's just like CBT and GET (it isn't). There would be huge pressure on the research team to stop.
Secondly (and related to you point below), these theories have been around for ages. Somatic tracking was created by Levine, but is heavily based on Reich and Gindler which again are inspired by Freud, etc. If the entirety of the community hasn’t been able to produce a single study that can prove their theories in over a century - what makes you believe that future studies will? (Hint: they won’t because their theories can’t be falsified so they can’t be proven)
What do you do with the thousands or even houndreds of thousands of lived anecdotes of harm or no effect from mind body approaches? Do you not have to put at least equal weight on those? Which way does the scale tip?I would like to think in 20 years we will have a large number of studies scrutinising it properly. Until then, what we have is a very comprehensive break down of the theory behind why Schubiner and Gordon's ideas are likely helping people (Lekander's book) and thousands of testimonials from patients documenting how and why it helped them and the objective changes they've seen in their recovery. For me, I was unable to work at all and I now work full time (I had to build up to that by volunteering and then working part time), I couldn't walk far and now I can hike, including in hilly areas. I couldn't cycle at all and now I can, etc etc. I couldn't get out the house more than once or twice a week (and sometimes not at all) and I struggled to talk for long, now I have no limitations on those things. I struggled to concentrate on reading/watching films and again now I have no limitations.
To be clear: I say houndreds of thousands because somatic tracking has been around for ages and the biopsychosocial approach to ME/CFS has dominated the public health sector for decades. Pretty much everyone has tried some version of it.