Encyclopedia Britannica website: entry on CFS

Sly Saint

Senior Member (Voting Rights)
in dire need of updating.
Judging by the editing history, a lot of the misinfo comes from the Mayo clinic.
most recently updated in Aug 19, 2021
chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS), also called myalgic encephalomyelitis, disorder characterized by persistent debilitating fatigue. There exist two specific criteria that must be met for a diagnosis of CFS: (1) severe fatigue lasting six months or longer and (2) the coexistence of any four of a number of characteristic symptoms, defined as mild fever, sore throat, tender lymph nodes, muscle pain and weakness, joint pain, headache, sleep disorders, confusion, and memory loss. In addition, a diagnosis of CFS requires that the symptoms experienced cannot have predated the onset of fatigue and that all other illnesses or medical conditions capable of giving rise to these symptoms have been ruled out clinically.

CFS was once routinely dismissed as an imagined rather than a specific physical condition, and even today it remains controversial. Indeed, its validity as a distinct disorder is sometimes questioned, since there is considerable overlap with other so-called functional somatic syndromes such as fibromyalgia and Gulf War syndrome. As with these two conditions, some persons initially diagnosed with CFS are later diagnosed with a mental disorder. However, for the majority of people with CFS, the disability and symptoms are physically real and debilitating.
A number of theories about the cause of the syndrome have been advanced, but none have been proved. Outside of underlying mental disorders, proposed causes include iron deficiency anemia, autoimmunity to parts of the nervous system, viral infection (e.g., infection with Epstein-Barr virus), immune system dysfunction, hypoglycemia (low blood sugar), chronic hypotension (low blood pressure), allergies, and altered hormone production. Some cases of CFS have been associated with a virus known as XMRV (xenotropic murine leukemia virus-related virus). However, the relationship between the syndrome and the virus remains unclear. It has been suggested that CFS itself represents a broad category containing subgroups of diseases, all with unique symptoms but all producing the same ultimate affect—fatigue. Nonetheless, researchers have found that CFS can be distinguished from other conditions according to the way in which the affected individual’s immune cells respond to stress. It may be possible to reliably detect this characteristic response with a blood test, leading to an accurate diagnosis of CFS.
There is no cure for CFS. Patients can be treated with drugs to control their most severe symptoms; for example, some patients are treated with antihistamines to control allergy-like symptoms or with sedatives to treat sleep disorders. Many patients respond positively to a range of nondrug therapeutic approaches, including exercise therapy, counseling, and stress reduction. In addition, studies have shown promising responses to cognitive-behavioral therapy, in which patients learn to develop strategies that help them cope with their disease and that improve the quality of their lives. While some persons with CFS become progressively worse, most improve gradually, and a few eventually achieve full recovery.

The Editors of Encyclopaedia BritannicaThis article was most recently revised and updated by Barbara A. Schreiber.

https://www.britannica.com/science/chronic-fatigue-syndrome
 
The article has been updated. There is still bad info on exercise therapy etc. They have changed the name to ME/CFS though.

myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome
medical condition


myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS), condition characterized by persistent debilitating fatigue that has no identifiable cause. ME/CFS is a remarkably complex illness and remains incompletely understood. These factors complicate its accurate diagnosis and have raised questions regarding its naming and description.


Epidemiology and characteristics
Worldwide, an estimated 0.2 to 2.8 percent of people are affected by ME/CFS. However, prevalence rates likely are much higher because an estimated 90 percent of persons living with ME/CFS may be undiagnosed. There are various reasons for such drastic underdiagnosis; some examples include limited access to health care, a lack of knowledge about ME/CFS among health care providers, a lack of acceptance by some members of the medical community, the absence of tests to detect ME/CFS, and fatigue being a ubiquitous symptom of illness. Indeed, while fatigue can undermine a person’s ability to work and carry out day-to-day tasks, physicians generally consider fatigue to be a nonspecific symptom, causing it to be readily overlooked. Moreover, although anyone can be affected by ME/CFS, it is most common in adults between ages 40 and 60 and tends to affect women more often than men; this age range and gender difference presents significant challenges, particularly in differentiating ME/CFS from symptoms of early menopause.


Some of the first reports of “outbreaks” of fatigue syndrome were made in the 1930s and often involved polio patients. Such clusters of fatigue onset among hospitalized patients instilled the idea that the condition was potentially infectious. In 1970 a review of reported outbreaks led to the conclusion that fatigue syndrome, then known as benign myalgic encephalomyelitis, was a psychosocial phenomenon, rather than a specific physical disorder. In the mid-1980s the term benign was discarded, and diagnosis of myalgic encephalomyelitis (ME) was based on prolonged muscle fatigue following mild physical effort. Shortly thereafter health officials in the United States renamed the condition chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS), leaving ME as a synonym.

Through much of the 1990s and into the early 2000s, the validity of CFS as a distinct disorder was questioned, especially because of the considerable overlap with other functional somatic syndromes, such as fibromyalgia and Gulf War syndrome. In addition, some patients felt stigmatized by use of the term fatigue, and, because symptoms arise in multiple body systems and involve more than fatigue, there was considerable pressure to rename the condition. Additionally, some experts considered ME and CFS to be two distinct conditions. Today, because of the condition’s complexity, it is generally referred to by using the umbrella term ME/CFS, though, in the view of some, this remains inadequate.


Suspected causes, diagnosis, and treatment
Multiple theories about the cause of ME/CFS have been advanced, but none have been proved. Suggested causes include bacterial or viral infections, genetic factors (the condition appears to run in families), physical injury or emotional trauma, metabolic disorders, and altered immune function.


Diagnosis of ME/CFS is based primarily on two criteria: severe fatigue lasting six months or longer and the coexistence of any four other characteristic symptoms, which are mild fever, sore throat, tender lymph nodes, muscle pain and weakness, joint pain, headache, sleep disorders, confusion, and memory loss. Symptoms are often similar in appearance to those of other conditions and tend to come and go or may fluctuate in severity over time. Thus, diagnosis of ME/CFS further requires all other illnesses or medical conditions associated with the same symptoms to be ruled out clinically.


There is no cure for ME/CFS. Patients can be treated with drugs to control their most severe symptoms; for example, some patients are treated with antihistamines to control allergy-like symptoms or with sedatives to treat sleep disorders. Many patients respond positively to a range of nondrug therapeutic approaches, including exercise therapy, counseling, and stress reduction. In addition, studies have shown promising responses to cognitive behavioral therapy, in which patients learn to develop strategies that help them cope with their condition and that improve the quality of their lives. While some persons with ME/CFS become progressively worse, most improve gradually, and some eventually achieve full recovery.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The article has been updated. There is still bad info on exercise therapy etc. They have changed the name to ME/CFS though.

There is still total confusion between the epidemics of 'ME' and ME/CFS, which is something quite different. More and more I see how much this false narrative spreads everywhere. It is extraordinary that ME/CFS should be a condition about which there is so little accepted medical consensus that Britannica can produce such a garbled and misleading entry.
 
There is still total confusion between the epidemics of 'ME' and ME/CFS, which is something quite different.
I hadn't realised that! I'd thought that the epidemics of ME were simply when some bug was prevalent enough to cause mass ME, just as Covid is doing. Is it generally accepted in the ME world now that these are different things? Would you like to expand on this a bit?
 
I hadn't realised that! I'd thought that the epidemics of ME were simply when some bug was prevalent enough to cause mass ME, just as Covid is doing. Is it generally accepted in the ME world now that these are different things? Would you like to expand on this a bit?

What I mean is that when people are describing what we now call ME/CFS they muddle in features of the acute illness that precipitated ME/CFS later in people at the Royal Free. I think the idea that 'ME is a neurological disease' is based on that muddle. It was the acute illness that gave rise to the term ME, not the later problems that Ramsay took an interest in.
 
I think the idea that 'ME is a neurological disease' is based on that muddle
Probably a fringe opinion, it's nothing as convoluted for the most part. From how the patient community talks about it, it's because it features a lot of neurological symptoms. As in about 99%+ of comments don't make any reference to historical artifacts, or the WHO categorization, and rely strictly on the fact that the symptoms cannot be mistaken for anything other than neurological. The same whether it's Long Covid, LC-flavored ME/CFS, or ME/CFS.

Which makes a lot of sense. Is an illness with lots of neurological symptoms a neurological illness? Sounds logical to me. Or should it rather be described as an illness with neurological symptoms? Hence the common framing of a multisystemic illness.

Still the idea is about as simple as people working out that respiratory symptoms probably indicate a respiratory illness and should probably be called a respiratory illness. But there's also things like COVID, which is a respiratory illness, and causes a lot of acute symptoms that aren't respiratory, such as loss of smell and so on.

Neurology does seem to work on the basis that neurological illnesses/diseases can only have neurological symptoms, so that's a bit of a bind but it does not change the facts and that this is a rational perspective.
 
Last edited:
Still the idea is about as simple as people working out that respiratory symptoms probably indicate a respiratory illness and should probably be called a respiratory illness.

Yes but that example shows why your argument doesn't really work. The reality is that the idea that ME is a neurological disease has been picked up by patients from medical gurus who point out it was classified like that fifty years ago.

Diseases with respiratory symptoms are often not respiratory diseases. The main symptom of left ventricular heart failure is breathlessness, which is also common in severe renal failure. Pain on breathing may indicate a pathological rib fracture from myeloma. And so on.

I am not aware of any symptoms of ME/CFS that are neurological in the sense that they point specifically to a lesion in the nervous system. What would they be? Not fatigue, OI, nausea, gut problems, muscle pain.... Maybe sound and light sensitivity but you can get those with flu - is flu a neurological disease? No.
 
I am not aware of any symptoms of ME/CFS that are neurological in the sense that they point specifically to a lesion in the nervous system. What would they be? Not fatigue, OI, nausea, gut problems, muscle pain.... Maybe sound and light sensitivity but you can get those with flu - is flu a neurological disease? No.
Small fiber neuropathy and neuropathic pain is a disease of the the nervous system.
From wikipedia
Neurology (from Greek: νεῦρον (neûron), "string, nerve" and the suffix -logia, "study of") is the branch of medicine dealing with the diagnosis and treatment of all categories of conditions and disease involving the nervous system, which comprises the brain, the spinal cord and the peripheral nerves.[1]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neurology#cite_note-1
 
Diagnosis of ME/CFS is based primarily on two criteria: severe fatigue lasting six months or longer and the coexistence of any four other characteristic symptoms, which are mild fever, sore throat, tender lymph nodes, muscle pain and weakness, joint pain, headache, sleep disorders, confusion, and memory loss.

Where did this criteria come from? Looking at OMF's chart of different criteria, the only one that requires four symptoms from a list is Fukuda. But the bolded symptoms above aren't in Fukuda's list. And the listed criteria is missing PEM. More importantly, the whole page is missing any mention of PEM.
 
Back
Top Bottom