Preprint Hypothesis: Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (ME) as a Mast Cell Activation Disorder (MCAD), 2026, Carroll

There are anecdotal reports of some ME/CFS patients experiencing significant improvements, in some cases even going from being bedridden to being able to function again
The same anecdotal reports exist for CBT and GET, which is you find people that swear by them. What about those that report improvements whilst on a placebo, should we be handing out those as well? I think the answer is provided by clinical trials which show when something is a moot point. When everyone is in the dark, it is hard to know what is what, but once the light gets turned on things become much clearer.

But I also understand patients who seek out doctors because they are desperate to try something that might help, even when the evidence is still limited.
I think everyone understand the patients and their families. They are not to be blamed for anything.

If clinicans hand out drugs like lollipops, they also have a responsibility to supply evidence or look at the available evidence. That is all I'm demanding. You can't hand out something 200 times without even looking at the evidence or trying to build some (and this routinely happens in ME/CFS). The situation in ME/CFS is really quite horrible, where the involved clinicans often don't care about evidence or understand the basics of clinical trial methodology. We are talking about something that will one day give historians a nice hobby, a land of psychobabble vs a land of biobabble, with little land in-between. But it seems that there is also a sane island in-between. I'd like to think that is now the way forward.
 
But why pick out the trigeminal? It is just a convenient bunch of wires at your top end. There are lots of other bunches of wires.
I’m still wondering if it’s the mediator of just about all of the idiosyncratic neuro-sensitivities we see associated with Me/CFS. And because of the mandibular nerves, it involves some very odd brainstem sensory neurons (the only ones inside CNS), which seem to be subjected to special protections, as they can’t regenerate.
 
Personally, I think there is room for both: being transparent about the lack of evidence and the uncertainty involved, while still being open to carefully monitored treatment trials when there is a reasonable rationale and some indication that certain patients might benefit.

I thinkmost of us would agree with that but a carefully monitored treatment trial means a properly conducted controlled trial that is capable of generating reliable data.
 
but there’s interesting trigeminal-vagus communication

Called the nervous system. I really don't understand the motivation for focusing on these randomly separated bundles of wires. It'sa bit like saying the bedroom windows are really important for seeing out. So are the landing windows.
 
Called the nervous system. I really don't understand the motivation for focusing on these randomly separated bundles of wires. It'sa bit like saying the bedroom windows are really important for seeing out. So are the landing windows.
No doubt. We still need people checking every window in this building though. The grades of problems leading up to central sensitization, apparently a core feature of the worst severities of me/cfs, make me think the trigeminal system is worth a special look. The ME5 neurons idea is interesting to me as a potential candidate for filling the gaps in the Idio Sen hypothesis of what causes pem.
 
What are these ME5 neurons?
Last time I asked about this I thought you pointed to my 'ME 5" theory from ten years ago which was just ME theory number 5.
Found it. They're not neurons, ME5 was one of several hypotheses about ME (as in myalgic encephalomyelitis): https://forums.phoenixrising.me/threads/do-mes-cause-cfs.31930/
5. ME5 is a speculation rather than something I have evidence for, but the specific autoimmune types I have given so far will not cover the majority. There is at least one more type needed and this is my guess. ME5 involves a sensitisation of the immune signalling mechanisms triggered by viruses. As part of an immune response to a virus the system produces antibodies that sensitise the ‘virus alarm system’ to the extent that even when there is no virus around it may trigger, just with exercise or stress. Two molecules might be particularly important here: gamma interferon and the immunoglobulin receptor FcRI (CD64) which is used to ‘pre-arm’ phagocytes with antibody even before any foreign pathogens have arrived.
 
We still need people checking every window in this building though.
Except there might be billions of them, some well-hidden, and others misleading. Our map of the brain is pretty primitive, probably with some wrong bits. Our map of brain cell functions and communication pathways is also primitive. Which area of the brain is responsible for brainfog? Ask 100 experts and you might get 100 different answers. It's just too early to decide which window (area of the brain) to focus on.

How much of the brain could reasonably be ruled out for ME's core symptoms? I think the visual and hearing areas could be ruled out (are there blind or deaf PWME?).
 
Ask 100 experts and you might get 100 different answers
Which means we still have to be curious and chase our curiosities — until one day someone lands on the thing that gives us the answer. I’m not just randomly interested in the peculiarities of the trigeminal system btw; I’m working off a hypothesis (which Jonathan has labeled “plausible” - and this is Jonathan we are talking about) that proposes the idiosyncratic neuro-sensitivities of pwME/CFS are routed into a common pathway of neural-immune signaling that leads to PEM, which leads to signals to the hypothalamus, causing a helter skelter of symptoms due to homeostasis disruption (so the hypothesis proposes looking at the mid-part of that story as it would be the only truly common feature - with everything else idiosyncratic). The trigeminal system looks to me like a reasonable candidate for being part of that common pathway, so I’m diving more into evidence of its oddities. I keep looking at alternatives candidates for this common pathway, but I then keep stumbling back onto trigeminal related processes. Unique neuron clusters in MesV (distinct from any others in the CNS and which require special protections from insults) add to the intrigue. I’m going to keep following my curiosity. Someone’s going to stumble on the answer one day and it will probably be because they pushed an awkward question based on curiosity.
 
I have no objection to people following their curiosity into hypotheses that otherwise aren't being considered. I just checked the wiki for trigemal, and at first glance I'd put it in the "reasonably be ruled out" category. I haven't noticed any correlation between my face/jaw and my ME symptoms. However, there's always the possibility that evolution tucked a special function in there. Maybe we still have some gene sequences for finding hydrothermal vents.
 
I have heard of me/CFS and PEM being "cured" by removing mast cell laden scar tissue. So I suspect a subset may have this
 
Can you elaborate on this? I've never heard of this.
Surgical induced scar tissue or implant with biofilm scar tissue. The tissue is laden with activated mast cells. Once the tissue is removed then the patient symptoms disappear.

This has been described to me by a clinician, whether their understanding of ME/CFS and PEM is what we know is not something I could confirm. They aren't an ME/CFS clinician.

My interest in this has been around identifying surgeons that can get tissue samples of activated mast cells. Speaking to a few of them has been of interest to me and Michelle James. We're keen to create a PET tracer of activated mast cells, none exists but the utility to map the full body to find pockets of activated mast cells would be revolutionary for the Mast cell field we think.

I genuinely think mast cell laden scar tissue could be a chronic stressor that creates an ME phenotype in some people. It's an interesting lead. And so the OP paper has some insights that are worth thinking about.
 
Last edited:
Can you elaborate on this? I've never heard of this.

Hypertrophic or thickened scars tend to be full of new blood vessels and those tend to be lined with lots of mast cells. But the mast cells in the scar will still only be a tiny fraction of a percentage of the total in the body.
Once the tissue is removed then the patient symptoms disappear. This has been described to me by a clinician,

This sounds pretty implausible as a reliable causal attribution. Is it really credible? Why should removing a tiny proportion of somebody's mast cells have a general effect. (Which would seem to be irrelevant to most people with ME/CFS who do not have hypertrophic scars anyway.)
 
Hypertrophic or thickened scars tend to be full of new blood vessels and those tend to be lined with lots of mast cells. But the mast cells in the scar will still only be a tiny fraction of a percentage of the total in the body.


This sounds pretty implausible as a reliable causal attribution. Is it really credible? Why should removing a tiny proportion of somebody's mast cells have a general effect. (Which would seem to be irrelevant to most people with ME/CFS who do not have hypertrophic scars anyway.)

I guess the hypothesis is that scar tissue of mast cells may be the source of a propagating chronic inflammatory signal. Not all patients with scar tissue have this so it's not like it creates it on its own. But if you have a proclivity to experience ME or MCAS, then perhaps this is the initiating chronic stressor that perpetuates the condition. Which then shuts down the symptom experience when removed.
 
Back
Top Bottom