TheStar.com – Opinion/Contributors
July 2, 2025. By Iris Gorfinkel, Contributor
Icarus had a problem: Desperate to escape from prison, he made wings out of feathers and wax. His father warned him not to fly too close to the sun, but Icarus couldn’t resist the freedom of soaring. His wings melted and he plunged to his death.
Like Icarus, public health is given advanced warning, but struggles between freedom and rules. And as in Greek myths, each failure offers a “moral.”
Here are five examples:
Referring to the pandemic in the past tense
COVID-19 is still spreading in unpredictable waves. Although hospitalizations are currently low, the virus landed over
1,000 Ontarians in hospital and killed nearly 500. New variants keep emerging, including the latest NB. 1.8.1, also known as “Nimbus.” It took just three months to become Canada’s dominant variant. Each time a new variant takes over, it threatens built-up immunity from vaccines and previous infections. Although Nimbus isn’t deadlier than previous variants, there’s no guarantee that future variants won’t cause more severe disease.
Moral: The pandemic isn’t over when hospitalizations have temporarily slowed.
Downplaying the impact of Long COVID
One-in-9 Canadian adults
have experienced Long COVID. Because the virus can invade multiple areas in the body, it causes over 200 symptoms, including extreme fatigue, brain fog and dizziness. But what’s frequently overlooked are its longer-term impacts on blood clotting, heart and brain health. Long COVID more than
doubles the risk of heart attack, stroke and death for up to three years after being infected. These risks rise each time a person gets COVID and
can be reduced by getting immunized.
Moral: Long COVID’s effects have been downplayed despite life-altering and long-lasting health effects.
Lowballing deaths that result from Long COVID
Canada’s federal COVID tracker fails to include excess deaths resulting from long COVID’s delayed effects on blood clots, heart attacks and strokes. There were
an estimated 90,500 excess deaths in Canada since the start of the pandemic to June 2023. That’s nearly 40,000 more deaths than what the Public Health Agency of Canada reported over the same time frame.
Yet government websites limit reporting to deaths resulting from acute disease only and leave out the later deaths that result from SARS CoV-2. Failing to acknowledge these deaths delivers a falsely reassuring and extremely damaging public health message.
Moral: Ignoring uncomfortable truths is not a public health strategy.
Disregarding the advice of Canada’s Public Health Agency
Alberta’s recently announced COVID vaccine policy goes against
Canada’s “strong” recommendations. Instead of providing COVID vaccines at no cost, most Albertans will need to pay $110 starting this fall, putting it out of reach for racialized communities and First Nations.
Both groups were over four times more likely to die from COVID-19 than non-racialized, wealthier Albertans. It’s Canada’s only jurisdiction that will charge high-risk community-dwelling seniors, children, health care workers and pregnant people, even though hospitalizations
and deaths from COVID outnumbered those from influenza and R.S.V. combined.
Moral: Public health should never be weaponized by political agendas.
Refusing to hold an independent COVID inquiry
An inquiry is essential to prevent the same mistakes from being repeated. Had Canada kept its stockpile of N95 masks, fewer health care workers and patients would have become infected. Installing better ventilation and filtration systems in schools and hospitals would have proven a wiser investment than the billions spent on closures. It would also reveal how public health might better respond to mis- and disinformation. Yet calls for a comprehensive inquiry into the federal government’s pandemic response have gone unheeded.
Moral: A transparent, national inquiry is essential to maintaining trust in public health.
Icarus paid with his life, but public health pays with the lives of entire communities. How many more cases, hospitalizations and deaths must there be for Canada to learn from its past mistakes? It’s urgent that political agendas don’t blind policymakers to the harsh realities of COVID-19. If hubris is left to shape public health policy, it ensures the same mistakes will be repeated.