Norway: Røysumtunet, a centre for severe ME patients

I wonder if it would be possible to use severe cases treated by home healthcare services as a control group on some metrics.
I think RT is meant for people that don’t get sufficient care at home, so the cases might not be comparable. The existence of RT is probably justified because of that. It’s the protocol that I’m worried about.

I also think it makes it harder to get RT taken seriously by outsiders when they see that the head doctor is pushing questionable treatments. That makes it easier to say that the shielding is over the top as well.
 
I think RT is meant for people that don’t get sufficient care at home, so the cases might not be comparable. The existence of RT is probably justified because of that. It’s the protocol that I’m worried about.

I also think it makes it harder to get RT taken seriously by outsiders when they see that the head doctor is pushing questionable treatments. That makes it easier to say that the shielding is over the top as well.
There are more people who don't get sufficient care than the patients at Røysumtunet, although how to identify them in a good way when there are no diagnostic codes for ME/CFS severity could be an issue (although I think a solveable one with enough time).

I'm not so sure, Wyller and Reme are taken seriously while (one of the) methods they promote is standing on a piece of paper manifesting onesself healthy. I don't think most even look closely at the methods. The lack of seriousness is just as much about the lack of acknowledgement of ME/CFS.
 
There are more people who don't get sufficient care than the patients at Røysumtunet, although how to identify them in a good way when there are no diagnostic codes for ME/CFS severity could be an issue (although I think a solveable one with enough time).
You’d probably need a high quality cohort. Although I’m not sure how you’d assess if someone gets adequate care, so it might just have to be a baseline for home based care.

The cost of RT might introduce some bias, though. It’s difficult to get the municipalities to pay for it, so the patients that get to go to RT might be the ones with more support in general.

And 3 months is a short time in terms of ME/CFS. There can be large fluctuations in that time frame.
I'm not so sure, Wyller and Reme are taken seriously while (one of the) methods they promote is standing on a piece of paper manifesting onesself healthy. I don't think most even look closely at the methods. The lack of seriousness is just as much about the lack of acknowledgement of ME/CFS.
My GP is both against off-label treatments and for pacing up. So there are definitively double standards. But we can’t expect to win with poor arguments, because the reason the other side’s poor arguments are accepted is bias in favour of that side.

It’s deeply unjust that we have to do so much better, but I don’t see any realistic way around it.
 
You’d probably need a high quality cohort. Although I’m not sure how you’d assess if someone gets adequate care, so it might just have to be a baseline for home based care.

The cost of RT might introduce some bias, though. It’s difficult to get the municipalities to pay for it, so the patients that get to go to RT might be the ones with more support in general.

And 3 months is a short time in terms of ME/CFS. There can be large fluctuations in that time frame.
I was thinking a control of "standard care", as much as that exists. I would like to know how patients are managed at home, and electronic journal systems should make that possible without too much hassle. Given the service is able to use them adequately and they are set up in a decent way for data collection, which is not always the case. Many municipalities in Norway now use Aidn, which show promise to create structured data that can be collected for quality control and/or studies.

My GP is both against off-label treatments and for pacing up. So there are definitively double standards. But we can’t expect to win with poor arguments, because the reason the other side’s poor arguments are accepted is bias in favour of that side.

It’s deeply unjust that we have to do so much better, but I don’t see any realistic way around it.
I'm not arguing for us using poor arguments, I'm just saying we can have the best though out arguments and bullet proof evidence, and people can still choose to go "I just don't believe that".
 
I was thinking a control of "standard care", as much as that exists. I would like to know how patients are managed at home, and electronic journal systems should make that possible without too much hassle. Given the service is able to use them adequately and they are set up in a decent way for data collection, which is not always the case. Many municipalities in Norway now use Aidn, which show promise to create structured data that can be collected for quality control and/or studies.
That sounds like an interesting project to set up. No idea who could do it, though. It would probably need a few iterations to work out kind of questions to ask and what else to track.
I'm not arguing for us using poor arguments, I'm just saying we can have the best though out arguments and bullet proof evidence, and people can still choose to go "I just don't believe that".
Ah, my bad. I agree.
 
It’s probably difficult as I’m not sure its home vs a place like this that is the discriminating factor, but the approach, attitude of carers and environment provided. Not sure how you can control for that.

Well put @Utsikt
Also ethically difficult because if it is taking ‘the illest who most suit/need this type of care’

(just like id bet the Leeds place being a psych centre first probably gets many for whom cfs is not the primary condition going by the sample mostly having it as a secondary condition in the ‘report’ that was in that dodgy propaganda article by miller, garner, Pederson, symington: https://s4me.info/threads/patients-...ltidisciplinary-care-2025-miller-et-al.44129/ )

Then to have a control that was matched they’d have to be assigning those identified as needing that care to the placebo / control

- whether that’s not changing their situation or placing them in alternatives that’s aren’t as considerate unless they explicitly made that (same approach but with no supplements or whatever)

And they’d be as desperately ill as those assigned to this place that someone referred them to as that’s what they needed or asked for?
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom