Orthostatic hypotension with tachycardia

MinIreland

Senior Member (Voting Rights)
Yesterday, I went to a long COVID clinic. They did an active standing test to for POTS. Within 2 minutes my heart rate increased from 65 to 170 and my blood pressure dropped significantly.

The doctor was being very dramatic about this result. She said she had never seen anything like this and that something is seriously wrong with me and that I probably don't have ME/CFS. She said it's not POTS because with POTS your blood pressure remains stable She has referred me to a cardiologist.

Although I think it's good that she has referred me, I don't believe that my test result is very rare for MECFS and LC patients? Especially if, like me, you had a monster crash (term stolen from @Chandelier) two months ago, which brought me from moderate to severe and I'm still bedbound all day (apart from going to the bathroom).

I just wanted to check here who has experienced a similar pattern? Or if you know of any good research around this pattern, please post links if you can.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I have certainly heard of other patients with this presentation. I haven't got any data to hand about how common this is in LC and ME/CFS but classical OH is less common than PoTS in ME/CFS. But I see no reason why your doctor should be suggesting you don't have ME/CFS based on these results. Also, it's possible that the cardiologist will be of little help but it is good to rule out any other issues.

If you're able to, I would repeat the test at home and get several readings to make sure the significant rise in HR and reduction in BP is fully reproducible.

Some clinicians would probably diagnose you with PoTS but, as your doctor rightly stated, the PoTS criteria actually exclude orthostatic hypotension.
 
Last edited:
I have certainly heard of other patients with this presentation. I haven't got any data to hand about how common this is in LC and ME/CFS but classical OH is less common than PoTS in ME/CFS. But I see no reason why your doctor should be suggesting you don't have ME/CFS based on these results. Also, it's possible that the cardiologist will be of little help but it is good to rule out any other issues.

If you're able to, I would repeat the test at home and get several readings to make sure the significant rise in HR and reduction in BP is fully reproducible.

Some clinicians would probably diagnose you with PoTS but, as your clinician stated, the PoTS criteria actually exclude orthostatic hypotension.
I am wondering if your doctor thinks prolonged bed-rest or deconditioning from your severe crash might be causing such significant tachycardia on standing...?
 
Last edited:
I am wondering if your clinician thinks prolonged bed-rest or deconditioning from your severe crash might be causing such significant tachycardia on standing...?
No. She thinks I have some kind of 'serious illness' (as if ME/CFS isn't serious enough) that got worse over time. I think the reason she said that I probably don't have ME/CFS is that she hasn't seen patients as severe as I currently am. She's been running the clinic for 5 years, but she said I was the first one coming in in a wheelchair. I will ask her next time what she knows about ME/CFS.
 
No. She thinks I have some kind of 'serious illness' (as if ME/CFS isn't serious enough) that got worse over time. I think the reason she said that I probably don't have ME/CFS is that she hasn't seen patients as severe as I currently am. She's been running the clinic for 5 years, but she said I was the first one coming in in a wheelchair. I will ask her next time what she knows about ME/CFS.
Ah ok, that makes sense now. Yup, they really don't have a clue about the severe end of the spectrum. Many severe patients will relate to your story.
 
She's been running the clinic for 5 years, but she said I was the first one coming in in a wheelchair. I will ask her next time what she knows about ME/CFS.
A sign that clinics are only seeing the milder cases and pwME are yet again neglected. Maybe offer her our fact sheets. Someone running a Long Covid clinic really should know more about ME/CFS.

Good luck with the cardiology appointment, I hope you get some answers and help
 
A sign that clinics are only seeing the milder cases and pwME are yet again neglected. Maybe offer her our fact sheets. Someone running a Long Covid clinic really should know more about ME/CFS.

Good luck with the cardiology appointment, I hope you get some answers and help
Great idea, @Trish. I've given them to my GP and my so-called 'ME/CFS specialist' (ahem) but didn't think of bringing them for her. I'll email them to her.
 
No. She thinks I have some kind of 'serious illness' (as if ME/CFS isn't serious enough) that got worse over time. I think the reason she said that I probably don't have ME/CFS is that she hasn't seen patients as severe as I currently am. She's been running the clinic for 5 years, but she said I was the first one coming in in a wheelchair. I will ask her next time what she knows about ME/CFS.
Many clinicians just are not exposed to the reality of severe ME/CFS. And when they are they either deny the patient is actually that sick or react with horror and decide the patient has something 'much worse' like yours has.

Sorry about that, it must have been a frustrating experience. And sorry you're still stuck mostly in bed.

It really is a damning indictment of these services that they are this sheltered from the reality of severe ME/LC
 
When I was first ill and just about managed to get too and from appointments and hospital I had some similar experiences of medics freaking out about some of my physical symptoms but ignoring others. It does show how little they see or understand of me/cfs. I was also in a wheelchair, went through cardiology at points, etc.

A person with a high heart rate on the floor in their surgery they respond to albeit often in unhelpful ways. One they never see because they’re too ill to get out of bed they don’t see or believe exists. Out of sight out of mind I guess..

Good idea on the fact sheets. Beyond that look after yourself as best you can @MinIreland and hope you can get some help or support.
 
I think that the prevalence of OH is unknown because such patients may be at the severe end of the disease spectrum and may therefore be underrepresented in studies.

Certainly, ruling out other conditions makes sense. In addition, I suggest reviewing your medications and, if any of them can lower blood pressure, discussing this with your doctor. For example, I have heard of a bad experience with mirtazapine in my local community.

I developed low blood pressure with orthostatic tachycardia myself and met the criteria for POTS during a tilt-table test. I am keeping my head above water because I have regained the ability to walk to some extent. Of course, I am not advising walking or any other exercise. I mean that, in my experience, being bedbound dramatically amplifies orthostatic symptoms.
 
@MinIreland

My close friend who had ME/CFS for 18yrs experienced the same symptoms as you describe, he was severe, but didn't need a wheelchair. I don't think the doctor should have judged you b/c you arrived in a wheelchair. My friend was referred to a Cardiologist by his doctor who had specialties in infectious diseases, and treated many pwME/CFS. His own son recovered from CFS.

It was the right decision to refer you to a Cardiologist, try not to get too stressed. I hope they find answers. Best of luck.
 
[Edit: I have edited this post as it sounded like I was giving medical advice. I am not a doctor and am only commenting based on having paid attention to studies on orthostatic hypotension and POTS in ME/CFS over the years.]

Really glad to hear you had this assessment, @MinIreland. It is very good to have that documented.

Although I think it's good that she has referred me, I don't believe that my test result is very rare for MECFS and LC patients? Especially if, like me, you had a monster crash (term stolen from @Chandelier) two months ago, which brought me from moderate to severe and I'm still bedbound all day (apart from going to the bathroom).

I just wanted to check here who has experienced a similar pattern? Or if you know of any good research around this pattern, please post links if you can.
I follow the research in this area pretty closely, and the short answer is, we don't have definitive data on this. Part of the problem is that people with such severe difficulty being upright don't participate in studies, because they're bedbound.

The cardiologist will be the one to figure out what is happening for you. My understanding is that it depends on which happens first - does the blood pressure drop and then heart rate goes up? Or does heart rate go up and then blood pressure drops?

In the first case, when blood pressure drops within 3 minutes of standing, it's called classical orthostatic hypotension (as opposed to delayed). When that happens, some people's heart rate goes up to compensate, i.e. to try to make sure your brain and other organs continue to get blood.

The opposite scenario, where heart rate goes up first, and then blood pressure tanks, would be something different that the cardiologist would investigate.

The fact that this occurred in an active stand rather than a tilt is more impressive/convincing, as an active stand is less sensitive than a tilt, because you can use your leg muscles to compensate.

We don't have good data on how common classical orthostatic hypotension is in ME/CFS, but anedotally, it's commonly described in very severe ME/CFS, and probably to a lesser extent, severe ME/CFS, and temporary crashes into those severities. Classical OH is likely to be rare in mild and moderate ME/CFS, because by definition, it prevents you being upright.

It also occurs in lots of other scenarios, so it's very good that you've been referred to a cardiologist.

I have seen at least one study suggesting that the clinical reality is a bit messier than the definitions of POTS etc suggest, with some meeting criteria for POTS also, sometimes, having a drop in blood pressure. I have tried and failed this morning to find the study I'm thinking of.

I have not seen studies of other cardiac issues in ME/CFS.

I think the reason she said that I probably don't have ME/CFS is that she hasn't seen patients as severe as I currently am. She's been running the clinic for 5 years, but she said I was the first one coming in in a wheelchair.
So she has not seen people with severe and very severe ME/CFS, who are the ones with more OI. But she is right to get you tested further.

For what it's worth, I have severe ME/CFS and delayed orthostatic hypotension. On active stand testing, I had classical orthostatic hypotension once (when mild), and a normal test the other time (when severe). On tilt, I have delayed orthostatic hypotension. My heart rate does not go up enough to compensate, so I faint/nearly faint. I occasionally have pre-syncopal episodes soon after standing, so there is some intermittent classical orthostatic hypotension there too.

It's always possible that you have something other than ME/CFS, or something else on top of ME/CFS. Certain medications can also cause classical OH. And if the tachycardia is happening first, then that needs to be examined. So being investigated further is a good idea, if you can tolerate it.

Fingers crossed for you that you might get some answers and/or help.
 
Last edited:
Hi Min, my heart rate goes from 80 seated to 120 after 4 mins standing and 135 after 6 mins and have to terminate at 8 mins bc feeling weak, but hr back at 126. My BP remains normal. So not as dramatic as you. The person who said it’s not ME/CFS doesn’t know what severe ME/CFs looks like probably. Orthostatic intolerance and POT is part of the syndrome.

When I did a tilt table test, within two minutes, I passed out and my heart stopped for 55 seconds. I came to just as they were readying paddles. Cardiologist said this was “impaired vasomotor reserve.”
 
I would stick with the cardiologist you have been referred to and let them work out what's going on.

Dysautonomia International does not list anyone in Ireland.

I saw Prof Rose Anne Kenny, who developed the head-up tilt test, at the Falls and Blackout Clinic in St James's. A very promising first appointment. In the second appointment, when my active stand was normal, she recommended CBT. When blood pressure dropped on tilt, I got a lecture on exercise from a specialist nurse. Prof Kenny said she had not seen someone with ME/CFS as severe as mine before. (Mine is only severe, not very severe.) She saw me as severely deconditioned. Those suggestions where made even though I had already done extensive CBT and GET when milder.

Based on what I saw, she would take your active stand results seriously, if they were replicated in her office. I do not know whether she would recommend CBT and exercise to someone like you, with a positive active stand. But if a cardiologist helps you, there's no need to seek her out.
 
Last edited:
@MinIreland hi! Perhaps you could see a doctor from the UCLH autonomic unit? Or any other autonomic neurologist. Dysautonomia international has a list of such specialists depending on your location.
It seems the drop was only a once off. I have repeated the active standing test at home a couple of times, and my BP remained steady and normal.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I would stick with the cardiologist you have been referred to and let them work out what's going on.

Dysautonomia International does not list anyone in Ireland.

I saw Prof Rose Anne Kenny, who developed the head-up tilt test, at the Falls and Blackout Clinic in St James's. A very promising first appointment. In the second appointment, when my active stand was normal, she recommended CBT. When blood pressure dropped on tilt, I got a lecture on exercise from a specialist nurse. Prof Kenny said she had not seen someone with ME/CFS as severe as mine before. (Mine is only severe, not very severe.) She saw me as severely deconditioned. Those suggestions where made even though I had already done extensive CBT and GET when milder.

Based on what I saw, she would take your active stand results seriously, if they were replicated in her office. I do not know whether she would recommend CBT and exercise to someone like you, with a positive active stand. But if a cardiologist helps you, there's no need to seek her out.
Thank you for this information, @Evergreen. I have Dr Kenny in my list of potential doctors, but I think the knowledge on ME/CFS in Ireland is generally very poor. I'll stick to the cardiologist for now (haven't had the appointment yet) and I'm trying to get the long COVID clinic doctor to reconsider my case. She discharged me based on misunderstandings and misinterpretations. She doesn't seem to know that ME/CFS and long COVID have many overlapping symptoms and can both be severe. It's all very frustrating and upsetting.
 
Hi Min, my heart rate goes from 80 seated to 120 after 4 mins standing and 135 after 6 mins and have to terminate at 8 mins bc feeling weak, but hr back at 126. My BP remains normal. So not as dramatic as you. The person who said it’s not ME/CFS doesn’t know what severe ME/CFs looks like probably. Orthostatic intolerance and POT is part of the syndrome.

When I did a tilt table test, within two minutes, I passed out and my heart stopped for 55 seconds. I came to just as they were readying paddles. Cardiologist said this was “impaired vasomotor reserve.”
Wow, @Braganca, I'm so sorry this happened to you.
 
Back
Top Bottom