Stories of mis-diagnoses in the media

TODAY Story

In part two of the podcast, Sigler and Applegate welcomed Dr. Marwa Kaisey, a neurologist at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center in Los Angeles. She shared that it’s certainly possible to be misdiagnosed with the disease.

“It’s fairly common,” Kaisey said. “That is not surprising to anyone who works at an MS clinic, but it is always surprising when I talk about it with people in the MS world. And the reason for that is we don’t have one single test for MS. It’s not like we have something like a pregnancy test that says, ‘Yes, you have it, no, you don’t.’ It’s a list of criteria.”

“Some of those criteria are still a little bit subjective, and those criteria change every seven or so years, and so you really have to stay on top of the latest,” she continued. “There’s room for error there.”

Kaisey said common MS symptoms, such as tingling or numbness in your feet, fatigue and brain fog, can be found in many other illnesses or conditions.

“So to distinguish MS from its mimics can be challenging, and doctors, even with the best intentions with the deepest looks at a case, can sometimes still get it wrong,” she said.

Kaisey acknowledged that for Applegate to have her MS diagnosis “taken away” after five years of thinking she had the disease can be “earth-shattering.”

“When I was diagnosed with MS, I’ve gone through a great depression because of it,” Applegate said tearfully in the second episode. “I lost everything. I lost my job. What do you say to someone who’s been living with this for six years? ... I get really emotional because it stopped my life. I still have to use wheelchairs when I go to the doctor’s offices. I can’t walk from the car to the room. I’m still in this. Nothing magical happened when she said, ‘You don’t have MS.’”

“I guess I felt comfort in having a name,” she continued. “I felt comfort in having like an answer and a community.”

The “Anchorman” star publicly revealed she was diagnosed with MS in August 2021. She has repeatedly spoken about how the disease, which disrupts communication between the brain and rest of the body according to Mayo Clinic, affects her day-to-day life.
 
Judging by the comments by the professor, it seems plausible that the clinicians were the ones that messed up.

I have no idea who messed up at what point but Dr Kaisey's comments are pretty much blather. Diagnostic criteria are not the problem. One of the sad things about medicine is that very often neither patient nor doctor really understands the decision-making process in common sense terms.
 
I have no idea who messed up at what point but Dr Kaisey's comments are pretty much blather. Diagnostic criteria are not the problem. One of the sad things about medicine is that very often neither patient nor doctor really understands the decision-making process in common sense terms.
I don’t doubt that, but if a doctor tells you they think you have MS and the put you on ritux(?) for it, you can hardly fault the patient for «misunderstanding» that they have MS. Or if the doctors don’t explain the decision-making process in common sense terms. They got told the wrong thing, and understood it correctly according to what they were told.
 
This is the interview w the doctor. She said they now look for a “central vein sign” in the center of the lesion which is specific for MS lesions. And that the most common disease mixed up with MS was migraine which can cause smaller lesions on brain.

Again, that is an irrelevance. Migraine does not put you in a wheelchair. It is all uninterpretable Chinese whispers. Probably made worse by doctors trying to subtly score points off each other.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The thing that got me was her doctor telling her, "Good news, you don't have MS". I thought it was very unprofessional and insensitive thing to say.

I can't imagine my ME doctor telling me that.
 
Last edited:
The thing that got me was her doctor telling her, "Good news, you don't have MS". I thought it was very an unprofessional and insensitive thing to say.

I can't imagine my ME doctor telling me that.
I can totally relate to that. The amount of times I heard "Good News, your tests are all negative!"... Many Doctors don't seem to understand that for people with unclear health problems negative tests just mean being left alone with those problems and without therapy options.
 
How do we know, third hand, via a news article, what was said, how it was said and what it meant?
Maybe what was said was that the patient appeared no longer to have MS because they had no further relapses despite being off B cell depletion? Having to use a wheelchair might relate to previous damage.

Doctors get lots of things wrong but if our aim here is to base discussion on reliable evidence, this isn't it!!
 
My heart goes out to Christina Applegate. That's a very disconcerting situation to find yourself in.

I don't think it's fair to assume that she misunderstood that she had been diagnosed (leaving the other stuff about B cells etc aside). There is a known non-negligible misdiagnosis rate in MS.

The newer, more effective treatments are more effective the earlier they are started. That might push up the rate of misdiagnosis. When there were fewer options, neurologists might have been happier to leave someone for longer with a suspected MS label or no label.

I wondered whether misdiagnosis rates might differ between the US and elsewhere.

A US study, Kaisey et al. 2019 (first author featured in the Today story in @Mij's post above):
Of the 241 new patients referred with an established diagnosis of MS, 17% at Cedars-Sinai and 19% at UCLA were identified as having been misdiagnosed. The most common alternative diagnoses were migraine (16%), radiologically isolated syndrome (9%), spondylopathy (7%), and neuropathy (7%). Clinical syndromes and radiographic findings atypical for MS were both associated with misdiagnosis. The misdiagnosed group received approximately 110 patient-years of unnecessary MS disease modifying therapy.

Compare that 17-19% rate to the 7-11% rate found in a Spanish study described here:
In this issue of Multiple Sclerosis Journal, Midaglia and colleagues describe the frequency and characteristics of patients with MS misdiagnosis who were referred to the Multiple Sclerosis Centre of Catalonia (Cemcat) from July 2017 to June 2018. This well-designed, prospective study provides the first data on MS misdiagnosis from Europe. Among 112 patients referred with an established diagnosis of MS during the study period, 8 (7.2%) patients were identified as not having MS. The diagnosis of MS was questioned in a further six (5.4%) patients who were left with the awkward but pragmatic label of ‘suspected MS’ after further neurologic evaluation and follow-up over the next 12 months. In total, one in nine patients referred with an established previous diagnosis of MS had definite misdiagnosis, or had insufficient clinical, MRI or laboratory evidence to confirm the diagnosis. While the frequency of MS misdiagnosis was lower compared with recent studies from the United States, potentially reflecting geographical differences in referral patterns and provision of MS services, the numbers are not trivial.

From the Spanish study's abstract:
MRI identified multifocal white matter lesions, deemed non-specific or not suggestive of MS in all misdiagnosed cases. Patients with MS misdiagnosis had more comorbidities in general than patients with MS (p = 0.026) as well as a personal history of autoimmunity (p < 0.001).

I don't now if those two studies are comparing like with like. But it seems plausible that the misdiagnosis rate could be higher in the US. I wonder if the insurance system plays a role. Insurance wouldn't pay out for a treatment if someone "might" have disease X.

Hope they are clarifying what she does have, and that that will help.
 
"My wife was misdiagnosed with MS by the Ottawa Hospital. The consequences were dreadful."


Referring to his wife:
"It's her story to tell, not mine. Just going add that there was MS in her family that we now believe was caused by wartime and postwar environmental factors in Europe. If you have chronic migraines and get diagnosed with MS, you must get a second opinion."
 
Toronto Star:

Christina Applegate's MS misdiagnosis shocked many. If she were in Canada, it might have been different

"The autoimmune disease is difficult to diagnose, but here Canada has an advantage over the U.S., according to experts."

"Fortunately, as medical knowledge and technology continues to progress, diagnostic accuracy is improving. The misdiagnosis rate of MS in Canada has shrunk to just five per cent in recent years, according to Dr. Mark Freedman, a neurologist and leading expert on MS who directs the Multiple Sclerosis Research Unit at Ottawa Hospital."

Why is Canada better than the U.S at diagnosing MS?

In the U.S., most MS patients are diagnosed by general neurologists, according to Freedman. But in Canada, the vast majority of patients are seen by neurologists who specialize in MS diagnosis and management.

“Part of the training is recognizing what is MS and what is not MS,” said Freedman. “That is absolutely not the case in the U.S. There’s just not enough academic centres or MS specialists in the U.S. to manage all their patients. If we have 100,000 patients, they have 10 times that.”

​

 
Last edited:
How do we know, third hand, via a news article, what was said, how it was said and what it meant?
Maybe what was said was that the patient appeared no longer to have MS because they had no further relapses despite being off B cell depletion? Having to use a wheelchair might relate to previous damage.

Doctors get lots of things wrong but if our aim here is to base discussion on reliable evidence, this isn't it!!
Well.. the patient is speaking in her own voice on her podcast. She describes how her MS started and what her current symptoms are and says notning has changed. She says her doctors say her misdiagnosis is bc her MRI imaging doesn’t have the “central vein sign”. That’s all she knows and she finds it confusing. Then she interviews a different doc to who says this central vein sign is key to diagnosing MS and that lesions without it are not MS. Do you think this is probably wrong to say that?
 
Do you think this is probably wrong to say that?

We have no idea what the factual base for any of this is. I have never head of the central vein sign. It may be something neuroradiologists have shown correlates with histology of demyelination but its value will remain a matter of opinion and none of this is likely to be of any great relevance to the claim being made. MS is difficult to categorise in a black and white fashion. A working diagnosis is often important at an early stage when facts are not clear. Things change. Part of making the diagnosis depends on interpreting the patient's account in the context of historic knowledge. That can be very difficult to get right. I do not see why this should be a news story. Diagnosis is often difficult and not infrequently proves wrong.

I am not saying that anyone here is right or wrong. I am simply saying that this sort of story may reflect all sorts of realities. I see no justification for dragging it through public media. What point is being made? If the point is that North American healthcare is very poor value for money, then we all know that. Maybe the answer is to vote differently next time!!!
 
Back
Top Bottom