The science of craniocervical instability and other spinal issues and their possible connection with ME/CFS - discussion thread

Found this old 2001 paper on Chiari malformation surgery in fibromyalgia and CFS
During the past year neurosurgeons Michael J. Rosner and Dan S. Heffez caused a great deal of excitement in the mass media and on the Internet by suggesting that they found a surgical treatment for fibromyalgia and chronic fatigue syndrome.
In a Wall Street Journal article1 and on a subsequent television broadcast on ABC's 20/20 Friday program, Rosner and Heffez presented preliminary data linking these conditions to the Chiari malformations (protrusion of the brainstem downward against the spinal cord) and cervical myelopathy. In an Internet interview, responding to a question about the extent of symptom relief after surgery in patients with fibromyalgia or chronic fatigue syndrome, Heffez replied that "every symptom can be improved to a greater or lesser degree,"2 implying that the surgery was very successful. Unfortunately, no peer-reviewed manuscripts have yet been published that confirm any relationship of Chiari malformation or cervical myelopathy to fibromyalgia or chronic fatigue syndrome, nor has anyone yet published any data about the outcomes of patients after surgery.
Can fibromyalgia and chronic fatigue syndrome be cured by surgery?
 
I was communicating with woman who had been given a diagnosis of CFS for 10 years around that time period, she had surgery (she didn't mention the name of her surgeon), and all her CFS symptoms went away. She complained of a lot dizziness. She was dx with Chiari malformation and concluded she never had CFS. She didn't go on for years writing blogs about her recovery from CFS. She moved on.
 
Another paper on this for those interested:

Chiari I malformation as a cause of orthostatic intolerance symptoms: a media myth?​


Abstract​

There is much interest in a putative relationship between Chiari I malformation and symptoms of orthostatic intolerance. It has been reported at scientific meetings that a number of patients with chronic fatigue syndrome or fibromyalgia have Chiari I malformation, or hindbrain compression in the absence of Chiari, and that they experience improvement after decompression surgery. Many of these patients have symptoms of orthostatic intolerance. A connection between Chiari I malformation and these conditions has been discussed in newspaper articles and on national television programs. Patients have also had access to much information on this topic via the Internet. Unfortunately, the Chiari I malformation and orthostatic intolerance connection is almost entirely unsupported by peer-reviewed literature. The purpose of this article is to provide an objective review of the available information.
Link: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11705431/
 
Years ago surgeon Dr. Paolo Zamboni was promoting his "liberation procedure" for pwMS, based on his theory that chronic cerebrospinal venous insufficiency (CCSVI) caused MS. It was later discredited. There were several news stories. here in Canada about MS patients travelling to Italy for the surgery.
 
I'm not sure if the CCI patients were also ME patients? If so, comparing them to HC doesn't say much about ME patients in general.

"4:20 pm ET—Mario Murakami shared preliminary data showing altered cerebrospinal fluid drainage from the brain in Craniocervical Instability patients when compared to healthy controls. This dysfunction of CSF flow is a likely driver of neuroinflammation, brain fog, fatigue & dysautonomia due to impaired removal of brain waste products, as per the lab team’s model of disease."

 


"At the Harvard/MIT Martinos Center, Dr. Mario Murakami and the VanElzakker lab are using ultrahigh-resolution 7T fMRI to understand how changes to cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) flow in people with Craniocervical Instability can produce a phenotype similar to that seen in ME/CFS and other neuroimmune conditions.

The brain relies on cerebrospinal fluid to carry out metabolic waste that builds up during normal physiological processes, acting as a “garbage disposal,” as explained by Murakami. Changes to healthy CSF flow may result in the buildup of these metabolites in the brain.

Said Murakami, “There is a compromised structure of CSF flow in CCI [patients] compared with healthy controls, which means that maybe this is part of the mechanisms which drive the symptoms—the brain fog, the pain, the fatigue, the autonomic dysfunction.”

PolyBio is actively supporting this project using 7-Tesla fMRI in patients with infection-associated chronic disease (e.g. LongCovid and ME/CFS) to determine evidence of structural abnormalities in the dorsal brainstem and craniocervical junction; as well as cerebrospinal fluid flow problems, brain blood flow issues, intracranial pressure changes, and dysregulation of vagus nerve signaling.


This study builds on growing evidence that a portion of patients with IACI, including Long COVID and ME/CFS, possess functional and structural brainstem abnormalities. The brainstem itself is additionally susceptible to CSF flow changes, and contains dorsal nuclei that control autonomic function, pain, sleep, and sickness behavior—which, if dysfunctional, could have implications for these functions.

Early findings presented by Dr. Murakami providing evidence for these structural and functional differences in the IACI patient population may reflect a pre-existing vulnerability factor, or a consequence of pathology related to acute illness effects on cerebrospinal fluid pressure, infection, or inflammatory effects on the elasticity of the meninges or laxity of craniocervical structural ligaments."
 
Just stumbled on this technique. At least it doesn't involve a fusion surgery. I guess that's an improvement.

 


"At the Harvard/MIT Martinos Center, Dr. Mario Murakami and the VanElzakker lab are using ultrahigh-resolution 7T fMRI to understand how changes to cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) flow in people with Craniocervical Instability can produce a phenotype similar to that seen in ME/CFS and other neuroimmune conditions.


Do people think 7T fMRI imaging may reveal relevant information, even if people aren't onboard with these researchers hypotheses?

Or

Do people think that this stuff is chemical rather than structural, and not the type of chemical alterations that leave visible traces to be found in images?
 
All you need to diagnose craniocervical instability is a plain neck X-ray in flexion. I have not seen a single case with an abnormal x-ray claimed to have 'a phenotype similar to ME/CFS' whatever that is. Until I see that I shall assume that all of this is a complete waste of time.

I have no idea why & tesla fMRI should be useful here.
 
Dr. Mario Murakami and the VanElzakker lab are using ultrahigh-resolution 7T fMRI to understand how changes to cerebrospinal fluid flow [in CCI] can produce a phenotype...

PolyBio is actively supporting this project using 7-Tesla fMRI in (LongCovid and ME/CFS) .. to determine evidence of structural abnormalities.. cerebrospinal fluid flow... blood flow.. intracranial pressure.. dysregulation of vagus nerve signal..

This study builds on growing evidence that.. Long COVID and ME/CFS, possess.. brainstem abnormalities.. Early findings.. providing evidence.. may reflect

- a consequence of pathology related to acute illness effects on cerebrospinal fluid pressure

- infection

- inflammatory effects on the elasticity of the meninges

- laxity of cranio-cervical structural ligaments

- a pre-existing vulnerability factor

Built on this multiplied "growing" evidence for a whole bunch of maybe's, maybe some actual differentials may emerge, maybe.

Then VanElzakker can stop the endorsing of CCI intervention in any associated similarity.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom