UK: Beth Dobbin -- BBC: The Olympic sprinter now bedbound for 22 hours a day

Just watched Parliamentary Prime Minister's Question Time. Towards the end Alison McDonald MP Lib Dem Norwich, I think, asked about Beth's research funding campaign. Andy Burnham confirmed that DHSC Secretary of State, Yvette Cooper would be meeting with Beth shortly. Transcript of session should be available tomorrow.
 
Good spot @Maat It was a good question I thought and great to hear in PMQs. The response was the usual ‘we’re supporting genetic research and a clinical trial’ line so clearly it’s not something he understands nor has he been briefed well.

Can’t imagine how Beth will manage a meeting with the Health Secretary but good on her. Getting attention matters.

Here’s a link to the question and answer (it was at 12:45 if you have problems with the link

A good time to sign the petitions above and get writing to your MP to get them to support SequenceME
 
These petitions have been set up by Michael Kemble. Do we know who he is?

And yes, I think the time for ring fenced funding has come.
That is the best news I’ve heard today. I will add it to the rational hope of treatment thread.
 
I understand the first petition about ringfenced biomed funding for ME/CFS and it seems like a good idea but I don't understand the context or implications of the two others. The second about CQC provider training raises for me the question of what training they'll get and whether it's the wrong training, and I simply don't understand the third one because I don't understand the landscape of equality law.

Any thoughts, anybody?
 
These petitions have been set up by Michael Kemble. Do we know who he is?

He has ME/CFS. Also has this petition running:


I simply don't understand the third one because I don't understand the landscape of equality law.

Any thoughts, anybody?

The Equality Act 2010 basically says you are legally considered disabled if you have a physical or mental impairment that has a substantial and long-term negative effect on your ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities.

Substantial: More than minor or trivial (for example, taking much longer than usual to get dressed or complete basic tasks).

Long-term: Lasting, or likely to last, for 12 months or more (including fluctuating or recurring conditions).

So not qualifying as disabled until that criteria are met even if you have been diagnosed. Only then are the rights and protections under the Act applicable such as reasonable adjustments, freedom from discrimination.

However, there are a few exceptions to this rule known as Automatic Qualifications which give rise to Automatic protection: You automatically meet the definition from the day you are diagnosed if you have cancer, HIV infection, or multiple sclerosis (MS), or if you are registered as blind or partially sighted.

The Petition asks for ME/CFS to be included as an automatic qualification.
 
He has ME/CFS. Also has this petition running:




The Equality Act 2010 basically says you are legally considered disabled if you have a physical or mental impairment that has a substantial and long-term negative effect on your ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities.

Substantial: More than minor or trivial (for example, taking much longer than usual to get dressed or complete basic tasks).

Long-term: Lasting, or likely to last, for 12 months or more (including fluctuating or recurring conditions).

So not qualifying as disabled until that criteria are met even if you have been diagnosed. Only then are the rights and protections under the Act applicable such as reasonable adjustments, freedom from discrimination.

However, there are a few exceptions to this rule known as Automatic Qualifications which give rise to Automatic protection: You automatically meet the definition from the day you are diagnosed if you have cancer, HIV infection, or multiple sclerosis (MS), or if you are registered as blind or partially sighted.

The Petition asks for ME/CFS to be included as an automatic qualification.
Thanks very much for that detailed and very helpful explanation!
 
He has ME/CFS. Also has this petition running:




The Equality Act 2010 basically says you are legally considered disabled if you have a physical or mental impairment that has a substantial and long-term negative effect on your ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities.

Substantial: More than minor or trivial (for example, taking much longer than usual to get dressed or complete basic tasks).

Long-term: Lasting, or likely to last, for 12 months or more (including fluctuating or recurring conditions).

So not qualifying as disabled until that criteria are met even if you have been diagnosed. Only then are the rights and protections under the Act applicable such as reasonable adjustments, freedom from discrimination.

However, there are a few exceptions to this rule known as Automatic Qualifications which give rise to Automatic protection: You automatically meet the definition from the day you are diagnosed if you have cancer, HIV infection, or multiple sclerosis (MS), or if you are registered as blind or partially sighted.

The Petition asks for ME/CFS to be included as an automatic qualification.
I would say that IIRC the history of the act includes the addition of HIV and MS to the history of them being discriminated against, hence their being specified and the very valid reason for asking for ME to be included.

Ok I just checked and I keep getting AI summaries, I think HIV was because of stigma and MS is included so that someone is covered “before” the substantive impacts on day to day activities happens, because we know MS is progressive and at the point of diagnosis you may not be affected much. There was a case where a person with a diagnosis was discriminated against due to diagnosis, but didn’t (yet) meet the test of substantial effect on day to day activities, so they amended to law!

This is very relevant to ME actually, if you think of milder people still working.
 
Last edited:
Andy Burnham confirmed that DHSC Secretary of State, Yvette Cooper would be meeting with Beth shortly.
On reflection, I think this was a fairly disappointing response from Andy Burnham (although it is clearly very positive that the government is engaging with Beth). As it was from one of his own MPs, I assume he would have been given notice of the question so his would have been a prepared answer.

Beth’s request was to meet the PM. As far as I’m aware he hasn’t contacted her directly yet.

When the swimmer Archie Goodburn made a similar plea to Burnham for more funding for brain cancer research (which had already been ring-fenced by previous governments), the PM replied promptly and directly on TikTok, saying:

"Archie, thank you for this. I know how hard it must have been.​

"What you're doing for other people while you're going through all this yourself shows the best of us.​

"I'd really like to meet you and hear from you directly and I've asked my team to get in touch."​


Burnham is very PR and social media savvy. He has also never hesitated to throw his predecessors under the bus, so it was notable that his response was partly a defence of government action to date rather than an apology and/or acknowledgment of the institutional failures of the past 40 years.

Whether or not Burnham replies to or meets Beth himself, the most important thing will be the outcomes of any discussions. My guess is that Beth will not be fobbed off but my feeling is that, perhaps understandably, the PM doesn’t really get it yet – or perhaps he’s just calculated that it’s not a vote winner at this juncture, so he’s not bothered about being associated with it even if the government agrees to Beth’s requests.

I would be surprised if he didn’t also have some unhelpful voices whispering in his ear, perhaps telling him that “nobody likes them” or “there is a way”.

I hope that the government will do the right thing but the early indications, along with Yvette Cooper’s historic comments about ME/CFS and some of the unhelpful messaging coming from some of the ME/CFS charities, suggest that Beth will have her work cut out to get the sort of commitments we need from the government.

I also sincerely hope that Beth is getting the help she needs to mitigate the risk of her advocacy having an adverse effect on her health.
 
Last edited:
On reflection, I think this was a fairly disappointing response from Andy Burnham (although it is clearly very positive that the government is engaging with Beth). As it was from one of his own MPs, I assume he would have been given notice of the question so his would have been a prepared answer.

Beth’s request was to meet the PM. As far as I’m aware he hasn’t contacted her directly yet.

When the swimmer Archie Goodburn made a similar plea to Burnham for more funding for brain cancer research (which had already been ring-fenced by previous governments), the PM replied promptly and directly on TikTok, saying:

"Archie, thank you for this. I know how hard it must have been.​

"What you're doing for other people while you're going through all this yourself shows the best of us.​

"I'd really like to meet you and hear from you directly and I've asked my team to get in touch."​


Burnham is very PR and social media savvy. He has also never hesitated to throw his predecessors under the bus, so it was notable that his response was partly a defence of government action to date rather than an apology and/or acknowledgment of the institutional failures of the past 40 years.

Whether or not Burnham replies to or meets Beth himself, the most important thing will be the outcomes of any discussions. My guess is that Beth will not be fobbed off but my feeling is that, perhaps understandably, the PM doesn’t really get it yet – or perhaps he’s just calculated that it’s not a vote winner at this juncture, so he’s not bothered about being associated with it even if the government agrees to Beth’s requests.

I would be surprised if he didn’t also have some unhelpful voices whispering in his ear, perhaps telling him that “nobody likes them” or “there is a way”.

I hope that the government will do the right thing but the early indications, along with Yvette Cooper’s historic comments about ME/CFS and some of the unhelpful messaging coming from some of the ME/CFS charities, suggest that Beth will have her work cut out to get the sort of commitments we need from the government.

I also sincerely hope that Beth is getting the help she needs to mitigate the risk of her advocacy having an adverse effect on her health.
Agreed.
 
I would say that IIRC the history of the act includes the addition of HIV and MS to the history of them being discriminated against, hence their being specified and the very valid reason for asking for ME to be included.

Ok I just checked and I keep getting AI summaries, I think HIV was because of stigma and MS is included so that someone is covered “before” the substantive impacts on day to day activities happens, because we know MS is progressive and at the point of diagnosis you may not be affected much. There was a case where a person with a diagnosis was discriminated against due to diagnosis, but didn’t (yet) meet the test of substantial effect on day to day activities, so they amended to law!

This is very relevant to ME actually, if you think of milder people still working.
Per section 180 of the explanatory notes for the DDA for any law geeks like myself. Obviously carried forward to the later Equalities Act 2010

 
There was a case where a person with a diagnosis was discriminated against due to diagnosis, but didn’t (yet) meet the test of substantial effect on day to day activities, so they amended to law!

This is very relevant to ME actually, if you think of milder people still working.

Extremely relevant, although there will be a substantial amount of case law since 2010 on this subject
 
Last edited:
This looks like a seriously intelligent approach, picking the right opportunities with nuanced presentation.


And yes, I think the time for ring fenced funding has come.
What do you think is reasonable to expect as treatment? What possible options are there? There don't seem to be any to my mind and if research found anything 'biomedical' tomorrow, you are a least 17-20 years away from them being offered on the NHS and that's if something straightforward was found.

I can't understand the optimism around Sequence ME that means it could lead to different treatment pathways, as much as I know some of you want that funded.

I admire Beth's efforts, but if I have you £100 million tomorrow, I don't believe it would change anything practical in terms of symptom relief.
 
Back
Top Bottom