UK: Beth Dobbin -- BBC: The Olympic sprinter now bedbound for 22 hours a day

You can read here

This is a summary

Q1. What has made the campaign so successful in gaining national and international attention for ME and Long COVID?

Beth explained that she anticipated her BBC Sport interview would attract attention, particularly within the sporting world, because her story was shocking. However, she had not expected the response from the chronic illness and ME communities to be so significant.

She deliberately wanted to communicate the true severity of ME rather than simply list symptoms. She explained that healthy people might relate to tiredness or headaches, but these experiences are completely different when they occur as part of ME.

She described her worst days as feeling as though she were dying, needing hospital treatment and being close to death. She felt that using language that accurately reflected the severity of her experience was essential.

She also explained why the word fatigue is inadequate. Before becoming ill, she was a professional athlete, working full-time and training for four to five hours a day. Although she experienced considerable tiredness, it was nothing like the illness she experiences now.

Her aim was to make people understand that ME is fundamentally different from ordinary tiredness or the symptoms experienced by otherwise healthy people.

Q2. What has been the response to the campaign?

Beth explained that the campaign began almost spontaneously. While trying to get to sleep one evening, she had the idea of writing an open letter to the Prime Minister. She discussed it with her sister, and they worked on it the following day.

Initially, she had no organisations or charities involved and simply published the letter on Instagram.

Following the considerable support it received, charities became involved and the campaign developed into a second letter, this time calling on athletes to support increased ME research funding.

More than 500 athletes have now signed, including prominent sporting figures.

However, at the time of the interview, she had still not received a response from the Prime Minister.

She expressed concern that ME is a worsening problem, particularly since COVID, with increasing numbers of people developing Long COVID and ME. She believes governments cannot continue to ignore the growing numbers of people affected and that action is urgently needed.

Q3. What would Beth ask for if she had the opportunity to meet the Prime Minister?

Beth said she would like to see the UK follow Germany’s example, where significant funding has been committed to ME research over a ten-year period.

She recognised that this would be a substantial commitment compared with current UK funding.

Her immediate priority would be full funding for the Sequence ME and Long COVID study, which requires approximately £20 million. Although the Government has committed £4.75 million, the study cannot proceed without the remaining funding.

She challenged the Government’s use of this contribution as evidence that it is supporting the research when the money committed is insufficient for the study to go ahead.

Beyond this initial request, she believes ME research deserves funding comparable to that provided for other health conditions.

She also raised serious concerns about NHS provision for people with severe and very severe ME.

She highlighted that there are currently no commissioned NHS services for these patients in the UK, leaving people to seek private care. She described this as fundamentally wrong and particularly inconsistent with the principles of a Labour government.

She argued that the current situation means only a limited number of people can afford to access appropriate private care.

Q4. How has the campaign affected Beth personally, particularly given the toll of advocacy on people with severe ME?

Beth explained that she was conducting the interview from her bed.

She believes her background as an international athlete has helped her manage media appearances. Having previously dealt with media interviews throughout her sporting career, she finds them relatively natural.

She also feels that the pressure of live or recorded interviews brings out the athlete in her, allowing her to perform better than she might in an informal, unrecorded conversation.

However, the volume of messages and correspondence has been considerable.

She estimates that her current level of function is only around 10% of what it was before becoming ill. She has received thousands of messages, including more than 3,000 on Instagram alone.

Managing the campaign, particularly obtaining signatures from athletes she knows personally, has required significant cognitive effort. She described five days of working on signatures as a period when she was really pushing herself.

She is concerned about making her health worse but also feels a responsibility to continue because people have placed hope in the campaign.

She does not want to disappoint those who have supported it, although she recognises that her health must come first.

She emphasised the importance of pacing and acknowledged that she has been unable to respond to many people despite appreciating their support.

Q5. What advice would Beth give other athletes experiencing post-viral illness following COVID or another infection?

Beth’s first recommendation was not to train or exercise during an initial viral infection, even if the person feels relatively well.

She believes athletes may need to rest for considerably longer than they expect and should monitor things such as heart rate.

She argued that missing a month or two of training is preferable to risking the destruction of someone’s health and sporting career.

She was surprised by the lack of expertise around post-viral illness, explaining that even when she had access to the best care through British Athletics, there was limited understanding of these conditions.

She believes this is particularly concerning because athletes regularly push their bodies to their limits and may be vulnerable to developing problems following infections.

For those who have already developed post-viral illness, she advised against rushing back into training and stressed the importance of resting until symptoms have settled.

Looking back at her own experience, she believes that her illness was initially mild before becoming severe. She wonders whether resting for several months at that earlier stage might have prevented the progression to severe ME.

She also highlighted that infections are not always obvious. In her own case, she had glandular fever without initially realising it.

She recommended treating illness in the same way as a physical injury. An athlete would not risk a full-intensity training session with a potentially serious hamstring injury, and she believes the same caution should apply to illness.

Finally, she recommended monitoring symptoms and physiological changes, including resting heart rate and heart rate variability.

She explained that these were early indicators in her own experience which she had not recognised at the time because she did not know enough about them.

She also mentioned POTS, which she has experienced, and suggested that unusual changes in heart rate can be an important early warning sign.

Q6. Was there anything else Beth wanted to discuss?

Beth said she appreciated the opportunity to take part in an interview that approached the subject differently from mainstream media coverage.

She felt the questions had allowed her to discuss aspects of the illness beyond the usual focus on symptoms and the personal impact of ME.

Q7. What does Beth think mainstream media misses about ME and her story?

Beth believes mainstream media tends to focus on headlines and shocking details, such as the fact that she spends 22 hours a day in bed.

She understands why this attracts attention, particularly given the dramatic contrast between her previous life as an athlete, when she was active for around five hours a day, and her current circumstances.

However, she feels this approach does not communicate the complexity of the illness or what living with ME actually involves.

She explained that people who have not experienced these illnesses themselves cannot fully understand how horrifying they are.

She did acknowledge some excellent journalism, particularly her original BBC Sport interview, where the journalist had clearly undertaken considerable research and produced what Beth described as a phenomenal article.

She also spoke positively about subsequent radio interviews, where journalists had asked a broader range of questions and given her sufficient time to explain her experiences.

She felt these opportunities had been worthwhile because they allowed her to communicate more than just the headline-grabbing aspects of her illness.
 
Last edited:
It’s encouraging to see the clear focus:
  1. Fund SequenceME&LC
  2. Care for the more severe
  3. Fund research on an equal level to other diseases
If she’s working with the associations now I can only hope that they take notice and learn from it.

I hope she manages to avoid overdoing thing, even though she says she’s used to the media she is taking on a lot of responsibility.
 
It’s encouraging to see the clear focus:
  1. Fund SequenceME&LC
  2. Care for the more severe
  3. Fund research on an equal level to other diseases
If she’s working with the associations now I can only hope that they take notice and learn from it.

I hope she manages to avoid overdoing thing, even though she says she’s used to the media she is taking on a lot of responsibility.
Agree it will be taking a huge toll on her. On the other hand one thing I’ve sadly witnessed is that as soon as the severe get told to ‘step back and let us handle it’ then it turns out too often that things shift back to the same old (which sadly ends up being really disappointing / harmful for severe people often and most - whether layperson, general me/cfs org, pwme who aren’t severe - don’t seem to hear of really get that they put that bigger picture together wrongly in a way that ‘uses’ then feeds to the wolves the more severe in the way things end up, plus they get the old ‘should be grateful’ comeback when the real work is knowing what it’s like which comes from someone living it and others then doing the active listening to get the message or reply right that gets cut out when they get busy etc).

So it takes that impossible catch 22 of the person too ill to do it without it ending up making them too ill to do it anymore not only staying involved but staying firmly in charge (and being the public face makes that more possible to stay in charge of the message and knock down any side messages that mission creep it as distracting from this getting somewhere).

I hope she has a team of her own people giving her huge support and acting as a stalwart help to remind her what/how to reply/deal with other help etc for when she’s so exhausted she is vulnerable to being asked a question and persuaded to say yes to something she’d think better of if she wasn’t under this continual exertion. Ie they understand what ‘the aim’ is intricately enough that she’s sacrificing herself for so can protect her and her mission/nuance (as sadly happens when we get vulnerable people come in and try and put words in mouth or agree fast deals etc)

It needs to stay this clear and that’s been a difficult feat before to get different entities in me community to stand behind one thing and look clearly agreed on what the alternative should be (to show up what’s being done instead we always needed to have ‘one clear snswer’ and the lack of people doing that gave bps the free pass on ‘well if you can’t agree we’ll quietly leave status quo’) without starting to get tempted to warp it with add ons complicating the picture because of internal community type politics (comments of ‘but the mild suffer too’ are valid but missing the point and need a different internal response rather than warping the order things need to be done etc)
 
Last edited:
Regarding care and research funding historical evidence, Beth might not be aware of this evidence given to the Health Select Committee in March 2007 by Professor Malcolm Hooper, before the 2007 NICE Guidance was published.


For example:

16. The evidence about "CFS/ME" upon which NICE relies has been proven to be biased in favour of current Government policy to create nationwide centres for psychotherapy: It is well-known that, on the advice of Lord Layard, in order to remove people from Incapacity Benefit, Government favours cognitive behavioural therapy for all chronic ills. This is borne out by the negative stance taken by the MRC when considering research applications into the organic aetiology of ME/CFS—documentary evidence exists showing that the MRC internally classifies "CFS/ME" as a mental (behavioural) disorder; by NHS Plus in its published Policy Document of October 2006 ("Occupational Aspects of the Management of CFS: a National Guideline" [DH publication 2735539], whose external advisors were psychiatrists Professors Michael Sharpe and Peter White), and by NICE's own entrenched position about its preferred management regime, namely behavioural therapy, which has already been promoted and disseminated throughout the NHS as "effective treatment for CFS" in its "Effective Health Care" Bulletin of 23 May 2002 by the York Centre for Reviews and Dissemination. Given the existing extensive implementation of this policy and the relentless dissemination of its alleged efficacy by its proponents (for example, the assiduous advertising of a lecture at the Institute of Psychiatry on 28 February 2007 by Professor Trudie Chalder—a staunch advocate of the behavioural model of ME/CFS who works with Simon Wessely—promoting NICE's advocacy of behavioural and exercise "therapy" for ME/CFS), unless legally compelled to change direction in line with the international evidence that has been so effectively downplayed by its advisors, NICE is unlikely to do so. This would be to the serious detriment of between 120,000 and 240,000 very sick people in the UK (figures given in the Chief Medical Officer's Report of 2002), which is a prevalence five times that of HIV/AIDS. For comparison, there are about 83,000 people in the UK who suffer from multiple sclerosis. According to the US Centres for Disease Control, four million Americans have ME/CFS (see http://listserv.nodak.edu/cgi-bin/wa.exe?A2=ind0701d&L=co-cure&T=0&P=5201), which is more than those who suffer from multiple sclerosis, lupus, lung cancer and ovarian cancer combined. In the US, lung cancer alone has a prevalence of 350,000 (ie about half that of ME/CFS).
The first NHS treatment centre was created in 1998 in Wareham, 12 more were set up in 2004.


A Department of Health spokeswoman said the two-year delay [since publication of the 2002 Chief Medical Officer's working group] had occurred because it was important to "get things right".

"A considered approach has been taken. The report recommended that more research was needed and to this end we engaged the Medical Research Council to produce a research strategy for CFS/ME which was published in May last year."

Funding application for the PACE trial first began in 1998 and was unsuccessful before going through two iterations, eventually awarded in 2003.

White PD, Chalder T, Sharpe M. The planning, implementation and publication of a complex intervention trial for chronic fatigue syndrome: the PACE trial. BJPsych Bull. 2015 Feb;39(1):24-7. doi: 10.1192/pb.bp.113.045005. PMID: 26191420; PMCID: PMC4495840.


Afterall, it was important to "get things right".

Edited to add information on first clinics and PACE funding for historical context. Clinics have always been based on psychological rehabilitation addressing causation. See citation 3 in the above paper.

Putting the rest cure to rest—again
Sharpe and Wessely 1998.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom