[UK] Whole-Body Cryotherapy for Chronic Fatigue Conditions: A Feasibility Study

How is that relevant, though, let alone a justification?


Because there's no apparent scientific rationale and a risk of harm.

As they're only trying to address "chronic fatigue conditions", are they also trialling it on people with fatigue from autoimmune disease or previous cancer treatment? If not, shouldn't we ask why? It's hard to understand what's so special about ME/CFS, long Covid or fibromyalgia, when I know the fatigue of active psoriatic arthritis is worse than that of moderate ME/CFS.

Also, the study claims that:


It seems implausible that PEM would only occur in a tiny minority of participants after they've had to find their way to a new location, interact with unfamiliar people in an unfamiliar context, and undergo an extremely challenging procedure unlike anything they've experienced before. PEM isn't something that happens on rare occasions, it's a frequent consequence of normal life across all severities. The minimum we should expect of any PI is to understand that much.

I apologise if this reads as an intention to challenge or be rude to you personally, Caroline. It isn't, the criticism is aimed at a study that sounds like torturing people to see if it helps them forget how bad they felt beforehand. I hope it isn't going to be inflicted on anyone with ME/CFS, because as far as I can see this new flavour of rehab is no more justifiable than any of the old ones. I'm also worried about motivations, if it's true that a non-specific fatigue intervention is only trialled in diseases where patients can't access advice from consultants experienced in treating them.
I don't think you're being rude at all. Here's the participant information. So you have more information about what is involved - it's certainly not either "rehab" or torture - but I think I understand your concerns. I only know one person with ME who took part and he said he was consulted on the design in terms of what he could manage. I shared my intervention sessions in the "chamber" with two people with Long Covid one of whom could still work, just about, and one of whom couldn't. They were all about the PEM, so keen to see if this 10 day intervention would help alleviate their symptoms for a while at least. We have been offered the chance to have extra sessions on the evenings after the next cohort have had theirs, and they are both keen to keep going as long as the intervention is available. They are looking at various biomarkers, but mitochondria is a focus.
 

Attachments

I still do not understand, Caroline.
If it is a therapy used in sports clinics it is known to be feasible in principle.
If it has been tried on people with ME/CFS, apparently with a report of low percentage of problems then it is known to be feasible in that context, surely.

And I still see no need for healthy controls.

There will be no useful indicative information as far as I can see. This sort of procedure can be expected to have a strong 'placebo' efect in a keen population.

I cannot think of any reason why shifts in things like mitochondrial markers after this should be of interest if they are normal to start with - which they are.

I will have a look at Kujawki.
Isn't it useful to have a healthy control arm? Won't it be useful to compare the effect on a healthy person of this treatment with three sets of differently unhealthy people?
 
How is this supposed to be feasible for severe patients? Mild patients should be excluded from trials altogether at this point. The PDF mentions improvement in fatigue and calls ME/CFS a fatigue related condition. Fatigue isn't even a universal symptom.

We don't need trials just for the sake of having them - we need interventions that move the needle. We don't need uninformed patients supporting "research" out of desperation. There are better ways to spend your time and energy.
It's not supposed to be feasible for severe patients
 
Isn't it useful to have a healthy control arm? Won't it be useful to compare the effect on a healthy person of this treatment with three sets of differently unhealthy people?

Why?
The idea of a treatment is to restore abnormality to normality. What it does to normal people isn't of interest. Moreover, since in ME/CFS and LC we do not have any abnormalities to measure other than symptoms there is nothing else to normalise even in patients.

I have done a number of treatment trials. It never entered my head to recruit healthy people as well. You do that to test for safety initially, but even that I would question. If I had a new treatment I would test it for safety on people who I thought might benefit. When monoclonal antibodies were introduced as therapies I am not aware that they were given to healthy people much. You wouldn't want to deplete B or T cells in normal people.

I cannot see any reason to expose normal people to cryotherapy.
 
I am intrigued to know what the cryotherapy consists of. Do you lie in a box and have cold air blown over you?

It seems that you stand a box?

I don't see the need for very cold air since you cannot cool skin below -2°C without danger of frostbite. A good balst of air at fridge temperature ought to do as well and be less risky.

Google says the NIH have noted no proof of efficacy or safety.
 
Last edited:
Here's the participant information
This is from the potential negative effects section:
This intervention could trigger post-exercise malaise symptoms in some rare occasions, although the research evidence states that this only occurs in 1-4% of all cases, and that in approx. 60-68% of exposures, there can be measured therapeutic benefits such as reduction in brainfog, increased energy and reduced pain leading to increased mobility and quality of life.
There is no mention of possible adverse cardiovascular events, and this is clearly not a neutral description of the risks. They also do not provide any sources for the claims about therapeutic benefit, which is clearly unfounded if all they have is an uncontrolled trial!
I am intrigued to know what the cryotherapy consists of. Do you lie in a box and have cold air blown over you?
There are large upright chambers that you step into through a door. Some are enclosed while others have an open top for your head to stick out of. They are cooled with liquid nitrogen or just electricity.
 
I’m less interested in it being a feasability study or having a healthy group. In scientific terms, what’s the theory behind it? Why are we making people really cold, what will that affect/impact/alter?

Why do they think cryotherapy would treat ME LC and FM ?

My concerns would be that PwME famously have problems with temperature regulation and extremes of hot and cold, it’s known to be unusually uncomfortable and demanding. Also recent science stuff I saw in passing is that doing cold water things after exercise is not helpful at all and possibly harmful (seen in magazines, can’t quote sources)


I see no reasons to do this, and lots of reasons not to.
 
Last edited:
This seems to be partly a feasibility trial, which, as others have said, is testing whether it is acceptable for pwme, whether it's safe for pwme, and whether many people drop out or have adverse events. It's not a trial of efficacy as far as i can see.
It seems also to be a biomedical study of whether there are different biological changes between pwme and healthy people from the cold, hence the healthy control group.
 
It seems also to be a biomedical study of whether there are different biological changes between pwme and healthy people from the cold, hence the healthy control group.

But how would any biological changes tell us anything useful, @Trish, if there are no abnormal findings in ME/CFS that you might want to normalise? If it put lipids up a bit, what would that tell us? Or if it put blood pressure up a bit? You wouldn't want to see the measures go abnormal.

I can see that it might begin to get interesting if we knew that the treatment had a beneficial effect in ME/CFS but we don't have any reason to think that so far. An uncontrolled trial of going in a magic box full of freezing gas is bound to be followed by reports of being a bit better, just like infusions of rituximab. And even then, why would a shift in some measure within the normal range a bit differently in people with ME/CFS than normals tell us anything relevant to that benefit?

As you know, I spent much of my working life designing and carrying out treatment trials. I cannot make any real sense of this one. All the individual bits might seem to make sense on their own terms but I don't see how they make sense together.
 
Cryotherapy isn't a new idea. I remember a study in China or Japan being featured on TV, maybe in the early 80s? I only remember because it was for RA, which my auntie suffered with horribly.
 
But how would any biological changes tell us anything useful, @Trish, if there are no abnormal findings in ME/CFS that you might want to normalise? If it put lipids up a bit, what would that tell us? Or if it put blood pressure up a bit? You wouldn't want to see the measures go abnormal.

I can see that it might begin to get interesting if we knew that the treatment had a beneficial effect in ME/CFS but we don't have any reason to think that so far. An uncontrolled trial of going in a magic box full of freezing gas is bound to be followed by reports of being a bit better, just like infusions of rituximab. And even then, why would a shift in some measure within the normal range a bit differently in people with ME/CFS than normals tell us anything relevant to that benefit?

As you know, I spent much of my working life designing and carrying out treatment trials. I cannot make any real sense of this one. All the individual bits might seem to make sense on their own terms but I don't see how they make sense together.
I didn't say doing such a study is useful. Simply that it seems to be the justification they use for including healthy controls.
 
They should take this opportunity to carry out a full set of ‘cold reaction’ hormone tests on the patients and control if such a thing doesn’t exist.
At the same time, if the doses are designed not to cause PEM, there’s a risk we won’t observe anything in that regard either.
Personally, a few minutes’ exposure to a cold bath caused hypothermia or something similar, meaning I couldn’t feel my limbs for nearly three-quarters of an hour (wich didn't occurred before), but a three-second blast of cold water doesn’t cause any reaction.
 
Is there anything that might have the effect on the body (or maybe even the hypothalamus specifically) that cold does but without the risk of cardiovascular events?

Cold could be applied more gradually I suppose. I am not sure what to expect from cold but the general idea is that it probably sets off a hypothalamic response a bit like exercise, food or low blood sugar. There is a lot to discover. I think the problem with making use of this study is that hormone responses need to be monitored serially over an exact time frame under otherwise controlled conditions.
 
Back
Top Bottom