Caroline Struthers
Senior Member (Voting Rights)
I don't think you're being rude at all. Here's the participant information. So you have more information about what is involved - it's certainly not either "rehab" or torture - but I think I understand your concerns. I only know one person with ME who took part and he said he was consulted on the design in terms of what he could manage. I shared my intervention sessions in the "chamber" with two people with Long Covid one of whom could still work, just about, and one of whom couldn't. They were all about the PEM, so keen to see if this 10 day intervention would help alleviate their symptoms for a while at least. We have been offered the chance to have extra sessions on the evenings after the next cohort have had theirs, and they are both keen to keep going as long as the intervention is available. They are looking at various biomarkers, but mitochondria is a focus.How is that relevant, though, let alone a justification?
Because there's no apparent scientific rationale and a risk of harm.
As they're only trying to address "chronic fatigue conditions", are they also trialling it on people with fatigue from autoimmune disease or previous cancer treatment? If not, shouldn't we ask why? It's hard to understand what's so special about ME/CFS, long Covid or fibromyalgia, when I know the fatigue of active psoriatic arthritis is worse than that of moderate ME/CFS.
Also, the study claims that:
It seems implausible that PEM would only occur in a tiny minority of participants after they've had to find their way to a new location, interact with unfamiliar people in an unfamiliar context, and undergo an extremely challenging procedure unlike anything they've experienced before. PEM isn't something that happens on rare occasions, it's a frequent consequence of normal life across all severities. The minimum we should expect of any PI is to understand that much.
I apologise if this reads as an intention to challenge or be rude to you personally, Caroline. It isn't, the criticism is aimed at a study that sounds like torturing people to see if it helps them forget how bad they felt beforehand. I hope it isn't going to be inflicted on anyone with ME/CFS, because as far as I can see this new flavour of rehab is no more justifiable than any of the old ones. I'm also worried about motivations, if it's true that a non-specific fatigue intervention is only trialled in diseases where patients can't access advice from consultants experienced in treating them.