United Kingdom: News from Forward-ME Group

I don't think Yvette Cooper's article is super-confused.
Here's some good news. Lots of people get CFS for months or for years, and they get better. And I mean properly better, not just well enough to drag themselves to work four days a week, or well enough to sit quietly in a corner at a party before catching an early bus home. They (or should I say we, for I confess I was once a sufferer) recover enough to be as bouncy and as boisterous as ever we were before we got ill.

The trouble is we rarely get a word in edgeways. To one side of us the long-time persistent sufferers, their friends and their relatives, suggest we didn't really have CFS at all. The other - the "it's all in the mind" lobby - claim our recovery shows the illness was just stress or emotional trauma that passed once we pulled ourselves together.

Desperate to leave all the limpness, and the fuzzy-headedness far behind and get on with our lives we never mention CFS again. After all, people will think we are bonkers, unstable, susceptible to relapse - or just deeply boring. The result is that the cynics and the chronics hog the airways.

So it's time to correct the balance. I was sent to see a specialist in chronic fatigue syndrome, Dr William Weir, a consultant physician at the Royal Free and Coppett's Wood Hospital in north London. According to Dr Weir, 80-90 per cent of people who get chronic fatigue syndrome recover within two years. Even those who remain ill for a long time still have a chance of making a full recovery. As Dr Weir points out, "I've seen people who've recovered after 10, 15 or even in one case 17 years."

She sees what some call post-viral fatigue syndrome and ME/CFS as a continuum - but plenty of us do. I do. I don't think there is enough evidence to dismiss that idea.

I think she is right to point out that most people do recover in those early years. I've said repeatedly that advocates do no favours when they suggest a recovery rate of only 5% applies from onset.

The line about the cynics and the "chronics" hogging the airways is not great, so clearly she could do with some information about just how devastating it is to not get well. Surely she can imagine that. There must surely be a lot of people out there like her who have had a brush with PVFS/ME/CFS and who might be sympathetic with the right approach.

I'm sure the BPS 'recovery is possible' people will be scheduling their coffee meetings with her, so I hope the Forward-ME people are too.

Nor was my illness, as the cynics would like to suggest, merely a temporary mental aberration. If I was bonkers then, I am still bonkers now in my rude good health. Nothing has changed in my emotional state or my outlook on the world. I suffered no trauma, no unusual stress, and I wasn't depressed. At least I wasn't until I'd been ill for several months, when the full horror of incarceration with daytime television became clear. Misery took hold, I swallowed a few Prozac, and misery went away again. But I was still ill.

I don't feel like a victim for having had chronic fatigue syndrome. I never did at the time either. Infuriatingly for others, I actually feel quite proud of the fact that I endured an extremely boring and frustrating few years without going completely crazy.

Nor, sadly, can I say with my hand on my heart that I became a better person because of CFS. For a few months when I first got back to health I rejoiced in silly things like riding a bike, I enjoyed the world, and I felt great empathy with the elderly, the heavily pregnant, the disabled, and anyone who had trouble moving fast. Now I tend to take everything for granted again - just like everyone else.

I feel normal again. We should start treating CFS as a normal illness.
 
She sees what some call post-viral fatigue syndrome and ME/CFS as a continuum - but plenty of us do. I do. I don't think there is enough evidence to dismiss that idea.
I am agnostic. I certainly accept that it's possible but my guess is that it's not in all instances -- not least because I think ME/CFS may be more than one distinct illness. I also suspect that it may be possible to predict which PVFS/ME/CFS patients are more likely to recover if the right questions were asked. Hopefully we may have enough data to know before too long.

Infuriatingly for others, I actually feel quite proud of the fact that I endured an extremely boring and frustrating few years without going completely crazy.
I've had ME/CFS for nearly 35 years but I don't think I've ever been bored. Frustrated? Yes. Anxious? Yes. But never bored. I wish I did but I just don't ever feel comfortable enough to feel bored. This is not a criticism of Cooper or anyone else, but it is so far from my experience that it makes me question whether those who experience extreme boredom have a different illness or a different manifestation of the same illness.
 
Last edited:
I don't think Yvette Cooper's article is super-confused.


She sees what some call post-viral fatigue syndrome and ME/CFS as a continuum - but plenty of us do. I do. I don't think there is enough evidence to dismiss that idea.

I think she is right to point out that most people do recover in those early years. I've said repeatedly that advocates do no favours when they suggest a recovery rate of only 5% applies from onset.

The line about the cynics and the "chronics" hogging the airways is not great, so clearly she could do with some information about just how devastating it is to not get well. Surely she can imagine that. There must surely be a lot of people out there like her who have had a brush with PVFS/ME/CFS and who might be sympathetic with the right approach.

I'm sure the BPS 'recovery is possible' people will be scheduling their coffee meetings with her, so I hope the Forward-ME people are too.

What seems confused to me is that some of what she says is quite sensible (most people recover in a shortish period, and it isn't psychological), but then there's all this stuff about "the long-time persistent sufferers", "the chronics" whose "dismal" stories make people view them with "contempt and boredom". She wants us to think of it as a "normal illness" - yes, sensible - but her definition of a normal illness seems to be one with a good prognosis. So what kind of illness do the unrecovered have? Do people view sufferers of other long-term illnesses with "contempt and boredom" too? Or are those other illnesses "normal" despite being long-term, in a way that long-term ME/CFS isn't? She says "I confess I was once a sufferer" - why is that something one has to "confess", if it's just an ordinary illness?

Through the article she uses "CFS" when talking about this "ordinary illness, from which I would naturally recover", and "ME" when talking about the "gloomy case studies" of prolonged disability put out by support groups for those "dismal", "persistent" sufferers. e.g. "The most dispiriting thing I did when I first fell ill was open a self-help book on ME. Within three pages, I was convinced my illness would last forever. Luckily, I had doctors and family who treated CFS as an ordinary, if unpleasant, illness, from which I would naturally recover." The emotive language builds up an implication that the "CFS" type of the illness is real and "normal" whereas the prolonged, severe "ME" type is an exaggeration hyped up by people trying to gain sympathy and attention. But I can't work out if this is actually the underlying point of her piece or if she just hasn't thought it through.

I do think it's relevant that some years later, as Secretary of State for Work and Pensions, Cooper implemented Labour's welfare reforms which made it harder for disabled people to get income support. And I only hope she's evolved her attitude since then.
 
Back
Top Bottom