ChronicallyOverIt
Senior Member (Voting Rights)
You forgot “make no mistakes”
I don't doubt that protocols can be automated. There's already huge incentive to automate lab work, it's nothing biologists haven't been hearing for decades. The main issue is the material infeasibility of creating an automated lab that can actually generate enough relevant data for an AI to correct itself into something useful enough to justify that cost. I'd sincerely hope we get an answer to ME/CFS before the time it takes for entire supply chains to get reorganized to produce enough monoclonal antibodies for 1/20th of the relevant experiments.Where her and I disagree is the largely the automation of laboratory experiments, which in turn would render biologists largely useless, because to me that has always been an entirely automateble task and once it is automated everyone will agree that “oh actually it wasn’t that hard it was always gonna happen” as people now do for Navier Stokes.
And the very important “you are forbidden from hallucinating”You forgot “make no mistakes”
I suspect that arguments built on historical evidence based on things that don't exist anymore, are not a good predictor of the future. The same arguments made above were made by almost all mathematicians just a few months ago and many decades ago by cobblers.it's nothing biologists haven't been hearing for decades. The main issue is the material infeasibility of creating an automated lab that can actually generate enough relevant data for an AI to correct itself into something useful enough to justify that cost.
Perhaps one will have to ask the mathematicians to do something useful for a change, after all they now all have time on their hands.I'd sincerely hope we get an answer to ME/CFS before the time it takes for entire supply chains to get reorganized to produce enough monoclonal antibodies for 1/20th of the relevant experiments.
It's not a historical argument? That's just me saying it's not like biologists are unaware of the concept of automation or think their jobs are forever safe.I suspect that arguments built on historical evidence based on things that don't exist anymore, are not a good predictor of the future. The same arguments made above were made by almost all mathematicians just a few months ago and many decades ago by cobblers.
The only thing useful they could do in a magical automated future where we don't need their hands or minds is start sweating phosphate-buffered saline.Perhaps one will have to ask the mathematicians to do something useful for a change, after all they now all have time on their hands.
The financial cost of compute resources haven’t changed much in six months. The majority were unable to imagine such a sophisticated system in such a short time. The historical difference I see is that the performance of automating something used to be done be humans themselves. But I'll concede the biological reagents argument, even if I think it may be somewhat spurious.It's not a historical argument? That's just me saying it's not like biologists are unaware of the concept of automation or think their jobs are forever safe.
Most definitely, but I see this just as a similar scenario we’re also talking about, where trained workers are replaced. Whether or not you still use some economic slaves is I think not so relevant for the jobs that don’t exist anymore, be it a mathematican, cobbler or lab scientist.As for the cobblers, we do end up outsourcing tasks that could be performed by machines to humans in underdeveloped parts of the world quite regularly.
I'm confused what your ultimate point is here? "Lab automation" isn't fixing the vast majority of the issues that prevent us from having the data necessary to construct a useful and accurate AI biological model. It was never a workforce issue, it doesn't matter if the insufficient data is being produced by biologists or robots or stray cats.Most definitely, but I see this just as a similar scenario we’re also talking about, where trained workers are replaced. Whether or not you still use some economic slaves is I think not so relevant for the jobs that don’t exist anymore, be it a mathematican, cobbler or lab scientist.
The argument is the same as in mathematics. Mathematics will always exist, so will biology. You can never solve all problems, but you can replace the qualified people working on the problems. Whether that is really something worth aiming for is another question.I'm confused what your ultimate point is here? "Lab automation" isn't fixing the vast majority of the issues that prevent us from having the data necessary to construct a useful and accurate AI biological model. It was never a workforce issue, it doesn't matter if the insufficient data is being produced by biologists or robots or stray cats.
I suspect this thread is a little at cross purposes -- I think EndME is mostly focused on how people in these fields should be preparing for major changes/outright loss of work and careers. And on the flip side, many of the rest of us are thinking of it in terms of how much progress AI is going to make on the problems we care about. Which is a closely related question but one where you have slightly different priorities as you weight the evidence.I'm confused what your ultimate point is here?
I haven't been arguing for why biologists will exist in the future? I've been arguing about what it would take to ever get AI to the point where it can solve the problems people are wanting it to solve re: human disease. My point being that it will take unbelievable investment of resources just to get to what a grad student can do now, not because of anything to do with "intelligence" but because of accessibility of the relevant information.What is the argument why human biologists will exist in the future?
I’m not sure if I’d be pleased they are no longer stray and have jobs and homes or disappointed they’d be too busy to talk to strangers in the street or sit down for a chat and a tickle behind the ears.it doesn't matter if the insufficient data is being produced by biologists or robots or stray cats.
These companies all have hired Lean experts, many of which used to be mathematics professors at universities, so I would think they would have all been formalized if they are relevant. Fermats last theorem only took Claude some days to formalise. There have been instances were there were some problems with Lean, as in the Collatz Conjecture, but I suspect things might be different now and these proofs are anyways more reliable than human proofs (even if completely unreadable), which is why Lean exists in the first place.Hodge conjecture is apparently not fully formalized (Github) (maybe there are other repos?). Navier-Strokes seems to be complete though, so that might be settled.
That already exists for a handful of protocols that are commonly done and somewhat repetitive (like next generation sequencing or mass spec). If we got to a point where robots/AI could effectively troubleshoot themselves and their upkeep was cheaper than paying humans, this would be the first place automation would happen (and it’s already been attempted).Regarding the automation of labwork, might it evolve like machining has? One person invests in an automated machining unit (or many), and accepts orders for whatever the machines are capable of. So, if you need some experiment run, you search for a lab that has the capabilities you need, and you get your results. Actually, you wouldn't need to search; you'd just set up the experiment on your computer, tell the AI how much you are willing to pay, and it will either tell you it isn't possible at that price, or you'd get your results shortly.
Oh as far as the public is concerned without a doubt. I was always shocked at how trusting people were with Facebook. But business accounts and data is different I think. They need business customers and businesses do care about their data, do care about legal agreements and big teams of lawyers. The situation there has and will remain very different to how wider user data is concerned I suspect, which is why I’m interested in what sort of account and licenses were used here. Academia may nit have big lawyers but if businesses see business agreements being ignored they’ll go elsewhere. Hen again I wouldn’t put it past OpenAI to ignore business too, but a Google or Microsoft wouldn’t.company. Just look at the BS Meta is doing with user data.
I agree there’s a bubble, things are unsustainable. There seems to be a lot of wishful thinking that a crash means the technology goes away. Not a chance. I don’t know what will happen but it’s not that.Quite likely to me since there appears to be a bubble, but a crash does in most practical instances not have the implications most people think.
I’ve noticed that consumer (free) LLMs have started to enshittify. Less inference, routed to worse models. I assume it’s a push towards profitability.I’ve talked about cost quite a bit because the basic economics matter and looking at the way some companies dismiss it is telling (to me much of he story and evolution of OpenAI is one rooted in economics more then technology). There are better economists than me here though!
One thing I have heard is that in rough terms the spend on AI buildout is USD 1 trillion per year while the optimistic figures they have revenue of 200 billion per year. They’re no longer doing this on cash reserves. It’s debt. Debt that they cannot pay back without extraordinary growth for them (which they are claiming) and the wider economy (which they are also claiming). But unless we”re at like 10% GDP growth within a couple of years there are problems. Interest costs are not falling and quite recently are rising again so you get to a point that this doesn’t add up at the scale they are trying. Capital markets won’t buy it.
This is where the motivations are, to talk about insane things and costs not mattering or massive growth for all and the importance of your product to governments in the hope someone buys it. All jjust to keep your head above water in an arms race. Big companies like Google, Microsoft, Amazon will be fine, their debt to overall revenue is ok. Smaller ones will not.
I think the technology is really interesting, useful and promising but there are risks. The business side just sucks. We should find ways to manage the risks of both blowing up and also ways of benefitting the most from that too. It would be great if it was like some other booms where some investors lost out but humanity gained something longer term. We will see I guess.
The long term rates have increased by a lot very quickly. The 10 year US rate is at 4.95 %, which is almost at the peak before the finance crisis in 2008. The same is going on in other countries. In short, debt is getting very expensive and it’s probably going to stay that way for a long time.Interest costs are not falling and quite recently are rising again so you get to a point that this doesn’t add up at the scale they are trying. Capital markets won’t buy it.
The so-called AI winters of the past coincided with AI failing to deliver on the hype, but also with the technology failing to find broad use cases. I think the latter was most important. This time it will be different, because there are already so many use cases. But it’s impossible to predict the cost per capability, which will be the main limitation for what it’s used for as it is for any technology.There seems to be a lot of wishful thinking that a crash means the technology goes away. Not a chance. I don’t know what will happen but it’s not that.