ME Association- What Causes ME/CFS? A 3 stage hypothesis infographic

MrMagoo

Senior Member (Voting Rights)
Just released


What causes ME/CFS?
Predisposing, precipitating and perpetuating factors

This is a three-stage disease-causing hypothesis that is based on predisposing, precipitating and perpetuating factors.

The explanation covers key facts on what we already know about these three aspects of causation and the many uncertainties that still exist.

1. Predisposing factors

There appears to be a genetic predisposition to developing ME/CFS – as occurs in some other serious medical conditions.

2. Precipitating factors

Viral infections

Other infections

Other immune-system stressors such as vaccinations

Sometimes no obvious trigger

Physical or mental stress at the time of a triggering event may act as a co-factor.

3. Perpetuating factors

Research evidence indicates that this could involve a complex interaction involving the nervous and immune-systems and the way in which the body creates energy.

Involvement of the microbiome is also possible.

On-going immune-system activation
Is there an on-going production of cytokines – immune-system chemicals that produce flu-like symptoms in response to an infection?
Can this cause low-level inflammation in parts of the central nervous system?
Symptoms
Sore throats
Enlarged glands
Flu-like feelings
Immune system response

Does the body’s normal immune system response to an infection fail to settle down?
Microbiome and the gut-brain axis
Disturbances to the composition of organisms that inhabit the gut and their effect on immune-system responses could also play a role.

Muscle and mitochondrial dysfunction

Mitochondria are important cellular structures that are involved in energy production and there is evidence of mitochondrial dysfunction
Symptoms
Activity induced fatigue
Pain
Post-exertional malaise
Brain and nervous system
Autonomic nervous system control centres
Possible involvement of:
Brain stem
Basal ganglia
Neurotransmitters such as dopamine
Brain stem hyperperfusion/decreased blood flow
Ion channel dysfunction

Cardiovascular symptoms
Orthostatic intolerance
PoTS (Postural Orthostatic Tachycardia Syndrome)
Postural hypotension
Cold hands and feet
Gastrointestinal symptoms
Abdominal pain
Change in bowel habit
Problems with chewing, swallowing and digesting food in severe ME/CFS
Irritable bladder symptoms
Cognitive dysfunction
Problems with short term memory, concentration, attention span
Problems with balance
Alcohol intolerance
Sensitivity to light and sound
Hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis
An important brain-hormone (adrenal glands) pathway that appears to be affected in ME/CFS.
Symptoms
Problems with temperature control
Disturbed sleep
Appetite changes
Mild hypocortisolaemia symptoms
Fatigue
Muscle and joint pain
Bowel symptoms
Low blood pressure
Important to exclude Addison’s disease
 

Attachments

  • IMG_6802.webp
    IMG_6802.webp
    310.2 KB · Views: 36
Last edited:

Attachments

  • IMG_6803.webp
    IMG_6803.webp
    118.6 KB · Views: 11
Thought you’d be pleased they’ve cracked it!
:laugh:
You can feed back to them on this page
That’s really useful thanks! Just the one question to answer ‘how useful is this?’

Although the optional ‘how could this resource be improved?’ may yield some interesting answers!

I hope everyone gets their thinking hats on to help.
 
:laugh:

That’s really useful thanks! Just the one question to answer ‘how useful is this?’

Although the optional ‘how could this resource be improved?’ may yield some interesting answers!

I hope everyone gets their thinking hats on to help.
You are a close second at winning the internet. Unfortunately I don’t think Ralph Wiggum was the creator of the download, although we can’t be certain…
 

Attachments

  • IMG_6805.webp
    IMG_6805.webp
    20.9 KB · Views: 7
Although the optional ‘how could this resource be improved?’ may yield some interesting answers!

A poem instead, mebbe?

'The Pobble Who Has No Toes' is a medical mystery and avoids pretend explanations:

And nobody ever knew​
From that dark day to the present,​
Whoso had taken the Pobble's toes,​
In a manner so far from pleasant.​
Whether the shrimps or crawfish gray,​
Or crafty Mermaids stole them away –​
Nobody knew; and nobody knows​
How the Pobble was robbed of his twice five toes.​
​

 
The psychobehaviouralists also believe in a model of "predisposing, precipitating and perpetuating factors"; these are just biobabbling, rather than psychobabbling, ones.

The sad thing is that we now have real leads from the genetics. If MEA wanted to help, they could be reviewing the literature, trying to track down every possible expert on butyrophilins & neuroligins & dopaminergic & glutamatergic neurons and doing whatever they can to get them interested in ME/CFS research. We have hard data; every lead from it needs to be chased down and every angle explored.

And not only that; they could actually be funding additional genetic research. Family studies, rare-variant work, some of the more novel genetic techniques. Neuroimaging studies. Just funding a few PhD students could go a long way.

And not only that, but they could be trying to get sensible physicians to take an interest in the clinical side so that we can have genuine services rather than these loathsome psychobehavioural clinics by which we have been fettered & burdened for so very long.

What have MEA done about any of those things? I'd honestly love to know.
 
Last edited:
The sad thing is that we now have real leads from the genetics. If MEA wanted to help, they could be performing extensive literature reviews, trying to track down every possible expert on butyrophilins & neuroligins & dopaminergic & glutamatergic neurons and doing whatever they can to get them interested in ME/CFS research. We have hard data; every lead from it needs to be chased down and every angle explored.

And not only that; they could actually be funding additional genetic research. Family studies, rare-variant work, some of the more novel genetic techniques. Neuroimaging studies. Just funding a few PhD students could go a long way.

And not only that, but they could be trying to get sensible physicians to take an interest in the clinical side so that we can have genuine services rather than these loathsome psychobehavioural clinics by which we have been fettered & burdened for so very long.
This is what makes me so angry. Why are they not at the head of the charge into the new scientific frontier? Instead they seem to have got lost on the way to the battlefield.
 
MEA have gone rogue .
Over the past couple of years an increasing number of initiatives and communications have simply been amateurish and embarrassing .

I have every respect for Charles, however it looks as though BACMEism is becoming well esconsed as he reaches possible retirement .

It dosnt auger well .
 
Yes, sadly Charles seems to be losing the internal battle to keep MEA sane and on track, and I feel for him watching his life's work and the prior good name of MEA being so brazenly hijacked and perverted and wasted.

–––––––

Very unhappy that MEA have chosen to use the 'predisposing, precipitating, perpetuating' framing. That was no accident.
 
Predisposing, precipitating and perpetuating factors
to me they need to throw this wording out of the window as a model to describe anything.

they should find better terms to distinguish even if they had moved onto a better level than before if only to not be traumatising people and to rerepresent those most ill.

As it is it comes across as: ten years on we picked out the old presentation from last year, as we have done for the last ten years, and ....
 
Last edited:
It bothers me that the MEA is paying someone to create such hideously useless infographics.

Who do they expect to read and learn from it, even if the information were accurate? No GP is going to pick their way around those arrows and small print gobbets of half digested misinformation. No patient is going to learn anything useful to their care.
 
The above poster is presented on the MEA website in their free literature section under ME Essentials as an adjunct to a leaflet of the same name:

What causes ME/CFS?

This leaflet looks at the history of ME/CFS, research into causation and Long Covid overlaps with ME/CFS. It looks at predisposing, precipitating and perpetuating factors and what we currently know and do not know about this multisystem illness, reviewing current and future research.

This leaflet is written by Dr Charles Shepherd, Trustee and Hon. Medical Adviser to The ME Association.

If you would like to print the poster included in the booklet, you can download it separately here:

Poster

I have not read the leaflet in detail but is seems that Charles Shepherd is happy to have his name associated with this poster and the fuller text of the leaflet that this summarises. It seems to be a central part of the MEA’s presentation of the nature and circumstances of our condition.

[edited to delete section of duplicated text]
 
Last edited:
It bothers me that the MEA is paying someone to create such hideously useless infographics.

Who do they expect to read and learn from it, even if the information were accurate? No GP is going to pick their way around those arrows and small print gobbets of half digested misinformation. No patient is going to learn anything useful to their care.
I agree. I think the main problem with this infographic is that I can't answer the questions 'who is this for?' and 'why is this useful?'. And I don't think it's particularly well executed — for example the infographic seems colour-coded but in a strange, illogical way, and half the space is devoted to listing symptoms despite this not answering the question 'What causes ME/CFS?'.

The content is OK. It is clear where statements are hypotheses. I don't really understand the criticism of the "predisposing, precipitating and perpetuating factors" model. Sure, this language is also used by BPS-types, but can't any acquired illness be thought of in this way? We now have reasonable evidence for some predisposing factors, and we of course know about the precipitating factors. The perpetuating factors is where it gets a little messy.
 
Back
Top Bottom