Article: How having a disability became cool — The Telegraph

I had to look O'Sullivan up.
The forum have previously noted the work of this lady:

 
we have this one started in 2018
 
It’s the Telegraph, they have an agenda and have shown they will push it regardless of evidence. I see no reason to give them any credibility or clicks.
This is complete trash. Imagine being gullible enough to believe this.
They neither believe nor disbelieve it.

What they do believe is that it is useful for their self-righteous ideological crusade.

You can never be too cynical about people like this.
 
OBR (Office for Budget Responsibility) report on: The rise in incapacity benefits after 2013-14 coincided with a rise in the state pension age.').

I mentioned this to someone I know who immediately told me that "Government statistics are all biased and fudged"

This is what happens when people in power are allowed to claim "alternative facts" and "fake news" when being held to account.
 
I mentioned this to someone I know who immediately told me that "Government statistics are all biased and fudged"

This is what happens when people in power are allowed to claim "alternative facts" and "fake news" when being held to account.
Yes. As Ben (who I mentioned earlier) and others have reported it also coincides with changes to benefits following austerity which meant people basically had to claim some form of incapacity to get enough money to live on. Combined with changes in how some statistics are reported there has been massive distortions and the ability for some to pick and choose a narrative they want.

From what I understand there does look to have been a real increase for some younger NEETs but that seems to be a problem elsewhere and perhaps also policy based (it’s now more expensive for an individual to stay in education, less vocational colleges and places are available following local cuts but it is also more expensive to employ young people).
 
O'Sullivan's book on mass hysteria, which I read recently, has a chapter on POTS. In it, she tells the patient who was hooked up to a monitor that her BP didn't drop when she stood up, therefore she doesn't have POTS and just thinks she does. It's clear that O'Sullivan knows nothing about POTS. The whole issue is that HR is rising in the absence of a drop in BP. If BP were dropping, then tachycardia would be an appropriate physiological response to maintain perfusion. The whole chapter was a muddle of her muddled thoughts and half-baked anecdotes about a patient who was convinced she had absence seizures, i.e. epilepsy. It is true that some people in our community have beliefs that they have diseases they don't have but this is not the norm. BPS people like O'Sullivan use cases like this to make us all look bad, though.
 
The real question is why it became cool to bash disabled people.
Good question.

Possible sub text in view of
The Telegraph article ('How disability became cool') states:

This 'one in four is now disabled' figure is frequently repeated in UK media articles calling for 'a crackdown' on disability benefits. BUT the one in four figure is NOT the number of people in the UK in receipt of sickness/disability benefits, and also includes the elderly population

The UK general public have taken the One in Four figure as 'evidence' that 'UK benefit claims are spiraling'. They are not 'spiraling'. I have given references that challenge the 'spiraling' myth in previous posts, which include the Financial Times, and the OBR (Office for Budget Responsibility) report on:

The UK government's drive to reduce and deny sickness/disability benefits appears to position the UK as uniquely having a 'spiraling' disability benefits budget when compared with other countries. Though as a percentage of GDP the entire UK benefits bill has remained stable for 40 years, and is currently a lower percentage of UK GDP than when Cameron was PM (2010 - 2016).


The UNCRPD have been investigating the UK for the last 10 years for what it refers to as "grave and systemic violations of the rights of persons with disabilities".

One of the first things I looked up on the internet after a long absence a couple of weeks ago was the current status.

July 2025


It's why the Timms review is taking place.

I also discovered that the UNCRPD has now issued a similar report concerning the Mental Health Bill currently making it's way through Parliament.

May 2025

Mental health law and the UN Convention on the rights of persons with disabilities

Authors:
Institute of Psychiatry, King's College London De Crespigny Park, London, UK
Legal Consultant; formerly Royal College of Psychiatrists, London, UK
Durham University, Durham, UK


We argue that a form of mental health law, such as the Fusion Law proposal, is consistent with the principles of the CRPD. Such law is aimed at eliminating discrimination against persons with a mental illness. It covers all persons regardless of whether they have a ‘mental’ or a ‘physical’ illness, and only allows involuntary treatment when a person's decision-making capability (DMC) for a specific treatment decision is impaired — whatever the health setting or cause of the impairment — and where supported decision making has failed. In addition to impaired DMC, involuntary treatment would require an assessment that such treatment gives the person's values and perspective paramount importance.
My bold. Think liaison psychiatry in hospital settings. Overreach of the laws on informed consent when a patient with very severe ME is in hospital? Maeve Boothby O'Neill and others.

Also in May 2025

A report from the Joint Committee on human rights.


The UNCRPD is an international human rights treaty whose purpose is “to promote, protect and ensure the full and equal enjoyment of all human rights and fundamental freedoms by all persons with disabilities, and to promote respect for their inherent dignity.” It was adopted by the UN in 2006 and has been ratified by 192 parties, including the UK in 2009.23 Unlike the ECHR, the UNCRPD has not been incorporated into domestic law. It does, however, bind the UK as a matter of international law.

Like all media outlets, The Telegraph knows this.

As regards the social media side of this article I can't comment as I don't have the cognitive bandwidth to be on it.
 
An article from a wheelchair user that has lived through the changes in public perceptions of disability in the UK in the last 50 years.
It’s shocking to me how much physical violence he had to endure, starting in the late 90‘s:
 
Evidently many complaints to the Telegraph. Their response was posted on Reddit.

Thank you for contacting The Telegraph regarding Poppy Coburn’s column published on 5 September 2026. Given the volume of detailed correspondence received, we have prepared a response addressing the main themes raised by our readers. No discourtesy is intended by this single reply.

Complainants have primarily challenged the piece under Clause 1 (Accuracy) and Clause 12 (Discrimination) of the IPSO Editors' Code of Practice, arguing that the column:

Offends readers living with medically confirmed, debilitating physical conditions by framing them as social media trends, lifestyle choices, or self-diagnoses;

Misrepresents POTS diagnostic criteria by focusing on a heart rate change "compared to sitting"; fails to reflect the full diagnostic criteria and wrongly describes this single criterion as "arbitrary";

Dismisses real comorbidities as psychosomatic / identity-driven diagnosis, ignoring real links between conditions like POTS, ME/CFS, Long COVID, and Ehlers-Danlos syndrome;

Mischaracterises NHS waiting list systems by linking pediatric care to adult mental health referrals;

Conflates individuals who self-diagnose via social media and those with formal medical diagnosis to question official disability statistics;

Makes causal links between rising welfare costs / economic inactivity and social media subcultures / overdiagnosis without reference to evidence;

Ignores the impact of Long COVID in explaining rising disability numbers; and

Uses pejorative language like "sickfluencers" and describes mobility aids, compression garments or walking aids as "accessories" or "props.

Our Response Under the Editors' Code of Practice
The article in question is an opinion column written by our Associate Comment Editor. Under Clause 1 (Accuracy) and Clause 12 (Discrimination) of the IPSO Editors’ Code, commentators are granted wide latitude to express strong views, challenge social trends, and debate sensitive matters of public interest.

The vast majority of the objections received focus on the central premise of the article and express dismay and offence at the rhetoric used in the article. Complainants argue that the author's viewpoint that online subcultures influence diagnostic trends - is fundamentally flawed, offensive, or medically unsound.

While we acknowledge that many readers strongly reject the columnist’s premise and rhetoric, a fundamental disagreement with an author's editorial stance does not constitute a breach of the Code. The Code specifically protects the right of newspapers to publish provocative, challenging, and controversial commentary on public policy and cultural trends.

We acknowledge that many readers who wrote in hold formal medical diagnoses for conditions such as POTS, ME/CFS, Long COVID, or hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome. We recognise that living with invisible or chronic physical illness presents significant daily challenges, and we understand why readers felt offended by the suggestion that these conditions might be linked to social media trends or self-diagnosis.

However, a columnist examining online subcultures or debating a phenomenon observed in society is not passing judgment on individual patients or denying the reality of living with diagnosed medical conditions. While we regret the distress caused to readers living with these conditions, expressing skepticism about cultural trends does not breach the Code.

Clause 12 (Discrimination)
Multiple complainants have raised concerns regarding pejorative language, describing the column as "ableist", criticising the term "sickfluencers", and objecting to the characterisation of mobility aids or garments as "accessories" or "props."

While we appreciate that many readers found this framing offensive or dismissive, under the Editors' Code, Clause 12 is designed exclusively to protect named, identifiable individuals from pejorative reference. It does not apply to generalised groups. Because the column does not target or identify any specific individual, Clause 12 is not engaged.

Clause 1

Under Clause 1(iv) of the Editors’ Code, publications must distinguish clearly between comment, conjecture, and fact. A central theme across many complaints is that the author mixes conjecture with factual reporting, presenting theories about online subcultures and increased diagnoses as established facts.
However, the article is published as an opinion column framed explicitly as personal analysis rather than a news report. Under the Code, commentators are granted broad latitude to put forward hypotheses and express strong commentary regarding observed social trends. Presenting a distinctive viewpoint or theory within a commentary piece does not turn conjecture into factual reporting under Clause 1, provided the context remains clearly that of an opinion column.

We would also like to address some of the specific points raised under Clause 1:

Misrepresentation of POTS diagnostic criteria: A newspaper presents information (including medical information) to a general lay readership. Summarising the primary physical threshold for POTS as a heart rate increase of 30 beats per minute compared to sitting, conveys the essential diagnostic threshold of the condition to a lay readership. In the context of a 1,200-word opinion column, omitting the detail of full clinical tests which are carried out does not constitute inaccuracy or misleading presentation of facts under the Code. Describing the diagnostic threshold as "arbitrary" falls squarely within permissible opinion. It reflects an opinion held by medical professionals - including cited experts like neurologist Dr. Suzanne O'Sullivan who have questioned the diagnostic criteria.

Comorbidities and medical skepticism: Some readers provided medical literature showing biological links between overlapping conditions (POTS, ME/CFS, Long COVID, and Ehlers-Danlos syndrome). However, an opinion column is not required to detail clinical theory as a medical journal might. Under the Editors' Code, columnists are entitled to express and explore medical skepticism, cite experts (such as Dr. Suzanne O'Sullivan) and argue that alternative explanations (sociological or psychological) might account for rising diagnosis rates. These arguments represent the author's opinion, rather than factual news reporting. A raised heart rate upon standing is not unique to POTS and can occur in other non-pathological scenarios, such as prolonged physical inactivity. Pointing to the absence of a single clear physical biomarker and suggesting that overlapping conditions may have psychological rather than purely physical causes, represents permissible opinion, not factual inaccuracy.
NHS waiting lists: Pointing to long waiting lists was used as a broad rhetorical illustration of the strain on the NHS. The column is a commentary piece on an observed social media trend. It is not intended to serve as a guide to accessing NHS services as a child or as an adult. Under the Code, commentators are entitled to argue that increased demand puts pressure on public resources.

Social media trends vs. formal diagnosis: Regarding concerns about conflating social media trends with formal diagnoses, far from blurring the distinction, a central part of the author's argument is to draw that very distinction. A columnist examining cultural trends is entitled to critique how social media subcultures ("sickfluencers") influence health statistics and changing patient behaviour. As stated above, the author does not seek to detract from the reality of many readers living with diagnosed conditions.

Welfare costs and economic inactivity: Rising welfare costs and rising economic inactivity are matters of legitimate public debate, and columnists are entitled under the Code to express political opinions on how cultural shifts may impact state support.
Post-viral illnesses: Regarding concerns that the column ignores post-viral conditions such as Long Covid, it should be noted that a column is not a medical journal. Focusing on sociological factors represents the author's editorial focus rather than a factual distortion.

Pejorative language: As stated above, under Clause 12, the Editors' Code protects named, identifiable individuals from pejorative reference; it does not restrict critical rhetoric, stylistic phrasing, or commentary directed at general social trends and subcultures.

The Telegraph routinely publishes challenging commentary on sensitive public policy matters. While we recognise that complainants strongly dispute the author’s premise and rhetoric, along with her conclusions, we are satisfied that the article is clearly identifiable as opinion and operates within the bounds of debate protected by the Editors’ Code.

Yours faithfully,
Editorial Legal & Compliance
Telegraph Media Group
 
Perhaps you’ve seen it on a news segment on television about a transgender rights march, where every other attendee appears to be supported by a walking stick.

I'll take things that never happened for $500. Then I would use it to place a bet that if you conducted a representative survey of the young demographic, "'sickfluencers' turning chronic illness into a lifestyle trend and entrenching a culture of economic inactivity" is uncommon and not regarded as cool.

It has always been more socially acceptable to punch down on the sick and disabled than it has been for the sick and disabled to express their plights in public in a manner which does not promote the narrative of stoicism.

Especially when widening the scope to government policies and medical practices. They engage in something far worse, by enforcing the systematic discrimination against the sick and disabled who are deemed unworthy of support, using massively exaggerated stereotypes and statistics about laziness, malingering, and psychiatric morbidity.

During the height of the 2010s austerity measures and ATOS scandal in the UK, a survey suggested that the general population estimated that 40% of welfare recipients were malingering, when the detected fraud rate was around 1%. This gross discrepancy is largely explained by the type of toxic rhetoric politicians and newspapers used.

Underneath news articles about the ME/CFS, there were so many comments punching down on ME/CFS, especially against people who questioned the sacred cow of academia and psychosomatic ideology.

Or perhaps you’ve heard about it in your family WhatsApp group, when your sister tells you about your seemingly healthy niece’s new condition.

Just as reliable as the old 'my friend's father's cousin's uncle's colleague had chronic fatigue and cured it with X'.
 
Last edited:
Evidently many complaints to the Telegraph. Their response was posted on Reddit.

'The National Union of Journalists (NUJ) has repeatedly criticised the Independent Press Standards Organisation (IPSO) for its failure to monitor and act on the harm caused by negative narratives about disabled people and welfare recipients.'

'The NUJ has consistently argued that limiting Clause 12 (of the Editors Code of Practice) to named individuals creates a major loophole, allowing the press to target, stereotype, and dehumanize marginalized communities with impunity under the guise of editorial freedom.'


2023

Clause 12 of the Code on discrimination only allows a complaint to be raised about the reporting of an individual, not of a group of people. The NUJ reiterates its call for this clause to be opened up to cover discrimination against groups, which would strengthen the protection for minoritised groups who are the target of degrading reporting.

The NUJ campaign::
  • Clause 12 (discrimination) of the IPSO Editors’ Code of practice to be extended to allow complaints to be made about discrimination against groups of people and;
  • For IPSO to use its powers to monitor coverage of disability issues in national newspapers to identify and take action against systemic negative framing of disabled people and;
  • For IPSO to work with the NUJ and Disabled People’s Organisations to produce and promote reporting on disability guidelines.



2025
NUJ response to Press Regulation Panel call for information on press regulation in the UK December 2025


'A primary barrier to protection is that IPSO's code of conduct prohibits complaints over discriminatory reporting against groups of people. Instead, Clause 12 of IPSO’s code only allows complaints to be raised about the reporting of identified individuals. Complaints over coverage that targets and stereotypes people - including on the basis of age, disability, race, colour, religion, sex, gender identity, sexual orientation - cannot be upheld unless an element of factual inaccuracy is involved. This allows news publishers to perpetuate pejorative, prejudicial, and polemical narratives that have real-life consequences for marginalised groups.'

This lack of protection is reinforced by IPSO’s poor performance in upholding the complaints it does accept. The vast majority of complaints that IPSO upholds concern accuracy, most of which the NUJ believes could have been resolved without regulatory involvement by issuing clear corrections and apologies. Meanwhile complaints relating to privacy, intrusion into private grief, or discrimination are rarely upheld.
(My Bolding)

Re Clause 12 of the Editor's Code -
'This allows news publishers to perpetuate pejorative, prejudicial, and polemical narratives that have real-life consequences for marginalised groups.'
 
Last edited:



Support for disability benefits 'remarkably strong' report finds​

3 days ago​
Michael Buchanan​
Social affairs correspondent​
​
​
Support for disability benefits remains "remarkably strong" and cutting them would be "politically risky" according to a new report.​
The analysis, from the British Social Attitudes survey, found that fewer than one in 10 people favoured cutting welfare payments for the disabled, with almost half of people saying they would support more being spent on them, even if it led to higher taxes.​
The report comes amid mounting concerns among several political parties about the growing cost of disability benefits.​
Spending on the main disability benefit is forecast to more than double in a decade, reaching £41bn by 2030.​


Contrast those £41bn by 2030 with:
'Updated statistics from the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) show that, rather than “spiraling out of control”, social security spending is predicted to be lower in 2029-30 than it is this year"
 
Contrast with

The state pension is the largest single item of welfare spending, forecast to make up 42 per cent of the total in 2023-24.

Pensioner benefit spending is forecast to total £138 billion in Great Britain in 2023-24, of which we project £125 billion will be spent on state pensions. The same system operates in Northern Ireland, but spending there is not included in these figures or discussed on these pages as we include it separately in our figures for ‘Northern Ireland social security’. Pensioner benefit spending in 2023-24 represents 11.3 per cent of total public spending (up from 10.7 per cent in 2022-23), and 5.1 per cent of GDP.

 
It’s an opinion piece, they can say whatever they think. See what Jan Moir did to Stephen Gately.
Someone commented on what this means and how extremely screwed up this is: discrimination, even hate speech inciting harm, is fine as long as it's against a group of people and does not name individuals. So this means that acts of discrimination, and voicing support for them, tacitly or explicitly, are inherently protected because someone can say and do things on the basis that they are targeting (wouldn't be their word for it but it's the same) a group of people and be explicitly protected for it, but even factual complaints about it would be liable to antidefamation regulations since it would name a specific person, accusing them or wrongdoing.

Extremely screwed up society.
 
Someone commented on what this means and how extremely screwed up this is: discrimination, even hate speech inciting harm, is fine as long as it's against a group of people and does not name individuals.
The cherry on top is that this sentence would be both allowed and not allowed under that rule, depending on who it’s directed at: You’re faking your disability.

You as in me, or you as in us?
 
@Grigor on illness identity:

My Illness is not Part of my Identity​



So I'm a bit late to reacting to the
article in the telegraph. In fact, I
didn't read it. [snorts] I already saw
the title and the responses from the
community and I was like not going to
read another derogatory
article, you know. But the author, she
wrote a tweet on eggs or post on eggs.
And she said something along the lines
that
people treat their illness as a pillar
[music] of their identity, which I think
it's a lot of bollocks, you know. And
the reason why is because when I became
ill and I was completely in a coma state
with sunglasses and headphones and
whatever and I could not do anything,
[music] I really noticed that
the more I lost the the closer I
actually got to my [music] identity. I
thought that my dancing career or
whatever or things that [music] I did
were part of my identity. But the more
ill I became, the more I realized that
that was not the case. Of course, my
illness is all consuming. [music]
And when that's the case, of course, you
have to adapt to it. I think there is a
confusion about adaptation, what people
see versus identification. So, in other
words, losing ballet or losing my bell
career,
I didn't lose my identity because it
[music] was never my identity. And when
it comes to illness, yes, [music] I talk
about my disease a lot, but just like
with dance, [music]
it was an expression of the things I'm
dealing with. My illness is just a
circumstance of the situation that I'm
in. You know, whenever I see an article
like this, I
also feel sorry for the journalist in
some way because
apparently they
have such a narrow worldview that they
have no idea how it feels to lose that
much and then to realize that you are
much more than what you do, much more
than your job, much more than maybe
advocacy or whatever. You know these are
just expressions of things. It's just
fluff. It can disappear
in a heartbeat. But your core self it it
it remains intact. [music] They said
they are not your identity, not a
pillar. That's a lot of nonsense. It's
ableist. [music]
Yeah. It's really sad.
Yeah. The only thing that it harms many
patients, [music] it it harms people
with disability. You can only hope that
somebody doesn't have to experience this
themselves. But sometimes it would be
good, you know, it would be good for
somebody just to step in our shoes for a
while to really know how it feels.
Community has everything to be proud of
and it's fantastic that
people express themselves, especially
young women also because we know that
they're [music] often not taken
seriously by medical professionals. So
the fact that more young women and in
this case also men are talking about it
[music] I think it's a good sign you
know there there's more awareness about
the diagnosis people are being diagnosed
probably and treated but things can be a
lot better [music] and the fact that we
speak up about it is uh
only commendable you know Yeah,
we should be proud of ourselves. Yeah.
And [ __ ] this journalist. Yeah. [music]
Goodbye.
>> [music]
 
Back
Top Bottom